4 ms·
Nice != Good Niceness is about worrying about how other people feel. Sometimes caring about other people's feelings (especially in the short term) can lead to
by dnautics 12y ago
Nice != Good
Niceness is about worrying about how other people feel. Sometimes caring about other people's feelings (especially in the short term) can lead to duplicitous, decietful, dihonest, fraudulent, counterproductive or wasteful behaviors.
Being "good" in a sense is optimizing against those behaviors, which usually is an orthogonal concern to niceness, but sometimes leads to distinctly being not nice. I can't say one way or another if Linus is overoptimizing, but given a choice between niceness and goodness, I pick goodness.
- comrh 12y ago> Niceness is about worrying about how other people feel. I really disagree. Niceness is about CONSIDERING people's feelings. Not overly worrying or bending to them or self censoring but just being aware of your effect on other people. Linus seems to be aware but thinks that considering other people is a waste of time and I think that is a pretty toxic attitude.
- dnautics 12y agoI think you're putting the emphasis on the wrong word here. The important thing here is not worrying/considering but "feel". I would guess that Linus makes a categorical distinction between emotional and physical welfare - because emotional welfare is ill-defined and easy to manipulate from the 'reciever's' point of view, he considers it at worst a waste of time or at best a secondary consideration after definable things, like achieving a software objective.
- jrochkind1 12y ago> Sometimes caring about other people's feelings (especially in the short term) can lead to duplicitous, decietful, dihonest, fraudulent, counterproductive or wasteful behaviors. I think this is a lie that liars tell themselves. When you say you are lying to spare someone else's feelings -- what you really care about is your own feelings, protecting yourself from having to deal with their reaction to the truth. I think it's lying and lack of concern for the truth that actually lead to counterproductive and wasteful behaviors. Have you ever worked somewhere where nobody trusts each other and nobody tells the truth about what's going on? I think many of us have. How's that situation for productivity? Neither the OP nor anyone else is asking Linus to lie about anything.