3 ms·
> think it's largely because she is a woman Really? I haven't read anything like that. Seems to me most of her critics are from people who want Yahoo! to sell
by Someone1234 12y ago
> think it's largely because she is a woman
Really? I haven't read anything like that.
Seems to me most of her critics are from people who want Yahoo! to sell (or merge) so they make tons of $$$$$$. Before she came in they were set to strike it rich as Yahoo! went down in flames, now their money is tied up until she "fails" (from their perspective).
These people have just lost faith in the company after several consecutive failed executives promising similar things to Mayer. If she actually made Yahoo! profitable again they'd likely change their tune pretty quick, but she hasn't just yet, and she's spent a lot of "their" capital buying other companies which has further upset them.
Honestly I've seen very little "she's a woman" criticism, and rather a lot of broad criticism about the overall strategy. Although there has been a discussion of her interpersonal skills (however I've also read that about a lot of other, male, CEOs).
- freehunter 12y agoWell of course no one is going to say "she will fail because she's a woman". Bigots have learned to be a little more subtle than that. They would just criticize her strategy, while the same strategy from a male wouldn't draw the same criticism. I'm not saying that is what is happening here or that Mayer's strategy shouldn't be questioned, just responding to the "no one said 'because she's a woman' so it can't be sexism"
- smacktoward 12y agoI'm a pretty vocal opponent of sexism (to the point where I've been labeled by GamerGate-types a "SJW"), and I would criticize the same strategy if it was a man putting it forward. Or at least, I hope I would. There's no shortage of sexism out there, but it's dangerous to jump to the conclusion that any criticism of a woman is automatically rooted in sexism. That doesn't do social progress any favors either.
- freehunter 12y agoI'm not saying that is what is happening here or that Mayer's strategy shouldn't be questioned, just responding to the "no one said 'because she's a woman' so it can't be sexism". You can see the same thing happening with President Obama. All of the people who criticized him for his race directly have all but disappeared after his first few years in office. Now you get people who criticize him in more indirect ways. It's like natural selection of bigots, you need to figure out where the line of social acceptance is. Again, not saying anything about Mayer in particular. Just that the parent had said "it can't be sexism because no one mentioned that she's a woman" isn't a rational train of thought. Of course no one would directly mention it.
- andkon 12y agoIt's called the glass cliff: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Glass_cliff http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Glass_cliff She takes over after years of neglect at a time of even more substantial crisis, and yet gets and will take far more of the blame than her very incompetent predecessors for Yahoo's failure. What's worth wondering is whether her being a bossy boss woman was also responsible for her being sidelined and pushed out from the OC at Google: http://www.nytimes.com/2012/08/23/technology/in-googles-inner-circle-a-falling-number-of-women.html?pagewanted=all http://www.nytimes.com/2012/08/23/technology/in-googles-inne...
- gohrt 12y agoI doubt Larry Page cared whether she was a "bossy boss", since she wasn't his boss. He might have cared that she was his ex-girlfriend.
- wldcordeiro 12y agoDid she get pushed out? I thought it was her seeing an opportunity for a higher prestige+pay as a CEO vs being a VP.
- smacktoward 12y agoNot pushed out so much as sidelined -- it was clear that she was never going to get promoted beyond where she already was at Google, so if she ever wanted to move up she had to move out.
- larrys 12y agoHow is it a glass cliff? She didn't work at Yahoo and was not promoted into that role to take a fall. She was offered a job there and took the job. Her choice. Not the same as being pushed in any way shape or form. At all. Separately impossible to feel sorry for someone at that level of sophistication knowing full well that the job is not going to be easy. People take chances all the time when the upside is high enough. Of course she could have stayed where she was or taken an easier job.
- taxidrivermoe 12y agoThis could be called a nitpick, but it's kind of an important one. You say "made Yahoo! profitable again" as though Yahoo! were unprofitable. Yahoo has been profitable to the tune of over a billion dollars a year for a LONG time. http://ycharts.com/companies/YHOO/net_income http://ycharts.com/companies/YHOO/net_income