3 ms·
The author seems to think that Linus's aggressive tone only has a single effect on the community - to dissuade developers from contributing. It's possible that'
by onion2k 12y ago
The author seems to think that Linus's aggressive tone only has a single effect on the community - to dissuade developers from contributing. It's possible that's true, but it's unlikely[1]. Things rarely have a single isolated effect on the world. It's entirely possible that the way Linus interacts with the community makes people stop and really think before they post lest they be 'flamed'. Or makes people more likely to group together for support from his 'burns'. Or keeps the community small enough to stop Linux becoming bloated (hmm..).
It's easy to focus on the downside of the way Linus writes his posts, but that doesn't mean there isn't an upside.
[1] This is an interesting example of the Principle of Double Effect - http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Principle_of_double_effect http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Principle_of_double_effect - The negative effect of writing aggressively is inseparable from the beneficial effect, consequently making the act good if posting is a good thing, if Linus is acting with good intentions, and if the downside of annoying people is less than the upside of being fiercely opinionated about the way Linux should evolve.
Thomas Aquinas writing 800 years ago about the morality of killing people in self-defence applied to whether or not flaming people on message boards is acceptable... This is why I love philosophy.