3 ms·
I'm saddened by the lack of academic rigour displayed in this thread. If you have not taught introductory computer science courses, then you have NO CLUE what m
by bjourne 12y ago
I'm saddened by the lack of academic rigour displayed in this thread. If you have not taught introductory computer science courses, then you have NO CLUE what makes a good introductory language choice. It appears James Hague isn't working as a teacher either, just giving advice to newbies, so his opinion is just that -- opinion.
What you want is field studies: "This year we used Haskell and 75% of all students gave up on programming stating that it was to hard. Last year we used Visual Basic and only 20% did. Ergo Visual Basic is probably a better first language than Haskell."
Lots of research is being done on the subject, see this survey: https://www.seas.upenn.edu/~eas285/Readings/Pears_SurveyTeachingIntroProgramming.pdf https://www.seas.upenn.edu/~eas285/Readings/Pears_SurveyTeac...
- cageface 12y agoPretty much everybody I know that eventually went on to write code for a living starting hacking on little toy projects long before they got anywhere near a computer science course. JS in the browser is a great environment for people to start experimenting and dabbling in the same way that things like LOGO and Basic used to be in the early PC era.
- oskarth 12y ago> What you want is field studies: "This year we used Haskell and 75% of all students gave up on programming stating that it was to hard. Last year we used Visual Basic and only 20% did. Ergo Visual Basic is probably a better first language than Haskell." Why is that necessarily a good thing? What are we optimizing for here, understanding or popularity? SICP review by Peter Norvig: > Donald Knuth says he wrote his books for "the one person in 50 who has this strange way of thinking that makes a programmer". I think the most amazing thing about SICP is that there are so FEW people who hate it: if Knuth were right, then only 1 out of 50 people would be giving this 5 stars, instead of about 25 out of 50. Now, a big part of the explanation is that the audience is self-selected, and is not a representative sample. But I think part of it is because Sussman and Abelson have succeeded grandly in communicating "this strange way of thinking" to (some but not all) people who otherwise would never get there. http://www.amazon.com/review/R403HR4VL71K8/ref=cm_cr_dp_title?ie=UTF8&ASIN=0262510871&channel=detail-glance&nodeID=283155&store=books http://www.amazon.com/review/R403HR4VL71K8/ref=cm_cr_dp_titl... EDIT: People seem to be downvoting a sentiment Knuth and Norvig expressed, rather than reflecting on the question posed - what should we optimize for in a intro to CS class and why?
- gearhart 12y agoIn our environment, everyone should have a rudimentary understanding of programming. If even 10% of your complete beginners class drops out, you're failing to achieve that, so for this purpose, you should be looking for the lowest common denominator. Javascript is that LCD. The Art of Computer Programming is a college level work - it makes sense for Don Knuth to aim it at the 1 person in 50 who could be a great programmer, someone who could progress the science forward, but his audience is very different to that described in the OP.
- olavk 12y agoI loved SICP when I worked through it, but I was already an experienced programmer at that time. I venture to guess that most of the people praising SICP actually has programming experience before reading it, even if the book purport to be an introductory course. I would probably have given up on programming if SICP had actually been my introduction to programming.
- olavk 12y agoDepends on which 75% you are weeding out. What if you are just weeding out people which haven't prior experiences in a more accessible language?
- dagw 12y ago1 person in 50 maybe has what it takes to make it to the level of programming where they can read and understand TAOCP and where doing so makes sense for them. However almost everybody smart enough to muddle through college has what it takes to learn enough programming where they can use it to solve some simple everyday problems they'll face in whatever job the end up in.
- endeavour 12y agoExactly this. Why are we trying to raise an army of procedural, object-oriented programmers?
- collyw 12y agoEasy for corporations to replace cheaply.
- threatofrain 12y agoI am not as confident in your predictor or badge of authority -- that teaching actually tells you how to teach. Most "teachers" you're talking about are researchers first, and lecturers second. They don't really think about pedagogical techniques, and they're not going to start. Plus, they most definitely aren't going to take motivational issues seriously. Most professors assume you have motivation, and if you don't, they aren't going to care. They're going to let policy take care of you. Also, like I've mentioned before, most professors are not teachers. They are lecturers. The difference is that a lecturer just spits out the information in a clean and accurate manner, but it's your job from there to handle your learning. On a gloomy ending, I would even note that most teachers ever probably don't care for the state of pedagogical research. They probably already have very strong opinions about how to model the student population or best learning methodologies.
- coldtea 12y ago>I'm saddened by the lack of academic rigour displayed in this thread. If you have not taught introductory computer science courses, then you have NO CLUE what makes a good introductory language choice. Judging from what most academic institutions teach as a first language, that seems to move with the fads of each period and what's "hot in the industry" (e.g. Java a decade and a half ago), that's also the case if you HAVE taught introductory computer science courses. >It appears James Hague isn't working as a teacher either, just giving advice to newbies, so his opinion is just that -- opinion. As is most "informed opinion" of academic teachers. CS is mostly a sub-field of mathematics, the rest of it is, as Alan Kay says, pop culture.