4 ms·
Have you ever had your credit card stolen? Have you ever had it frozen and not been able to spend your own money? These things happen constantly but never happ
by CyberDildonics 12y ago
Have you ever had your credit card stolen? Have you ever had it frozen and not been able to spend your own money? These things happen constantly but never happen when paying with bitcoin. The more you have to deal with banks the more of a breathe of fresh air it is to pay in btc.
Credit card fraud is incredibly rampant and the security measures in place by banks and sites is so over the top it becomes difficult to even use them. Use ghostery? Your transaction won't go through with an unknown error. Use a VPN? Your transaction won't go through with an unknown error. Paying from a different computer? A different IP? Using a different address? All these things are a recipe for being on hold with your bank for 45 minutes when you all you wanted to do was order $50 of stuff from NewEgg.
- gst 12y agoI use my credit card a lot for all sorts of things. In the past 3 years I can only remember my card being rejected once. An when this happened I immediately got an automated call that allowed me to confirm my transaction (so I was still able to use that card to pay). My card was also stolen once (someone copied the magnetic stripe). Once this someone did a transaction on the other side of the country I immediatelly got a call from Amex which proceed to refund that transaction and to send me a new card. IIRC a replacement card arrived in the mail on the next day. In the mean time I just used my debit card to pay for things.
- hurin 12y agoYou obviously have no idea what you're talking about. The consumer isn't responsible for Credit Card fraud - if it's stolen my bank reimburses me for transactions I did not commit. If bitcoins are stolen you get what? Specifically the lack of fraud protection is obviously advantageous for merchants (who often are the ones, not the banks, paying out in the case of fraud) but for the consumer its distinctly worse.
- knocte 12y agoBitcoins can't be stolen. Period. A different thing is that you may suck at protecting your operating system.
- sukilot 12y agoAs a percentage of total money supply, mtgox was the biggest theft (or loss, there is no differene to victims) of currency in modern history.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- acdha 12y agoWhat an amusingly incorrect display of pedantry. Check your convenient local dictionary and you'll find something like this: 1. to take (the property of another or others) without permission or right, especially secretly or by force: (http://dictionary.reference.com/browse/steal http://dictionary.reference.com/browse/steal) Note that the definition does not take into consideration whether you think the victim should have done more to protect themselves, just as the fact that every year thousands of criminals are successfully prosecuted for stealing even in cases where homeowners did not have dogs, 24x7 security guards, etc.
- knocte 12y agoGood point. Also the analogy that other person raised ("Your stuff can't be stolen. Period. A different thing is that you may suck at protecting your house") is a good one too. However, we're talking about different things here. When do bitcoins really get "stolen"? When terrible things happen, like if people install malware or trojans by accident, or don't apply security updates to their systems. This, to me, is the equivalent of leaving the door of your house wide open. Not simply not putting an alarm system, you know. That is, if you want to use bitcoin, have some common sense and minimal computer knowledge, first (minimal includes knowing how to keep your operating system updated, not be a certified sysadmin).
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- venaoy 12y ago> The consumer isn't responsible for Credit Card fraud Wrong. In many cases he is responsible. Scenario #1: 60 days (typically) after the transaction, the customer has no recourse to report fraud. You were browsing your credit card statements and notice a $50 charge 2 months ago that you never authorized? Tough luck. Scenario #2: When the card was physically present during the transaction, and when a pin code was used, the customer is always (edit: I meant "typically") held responsible unless he can prove he and his authorized users were definitively not present.
- hurin 12y ago>Scenario #2: When the card was physically present during the transaction, and when a pin code was used, the customer is always held responsible unless he can prove he and his authorized users were definitively not present. I think you ought to fact check on Scenario #2 (at least in the US), The merchant is responsible for confirming the identity of the customer matches the one stated on the card - the customer does not need to prove anything. Link (re pin number use): http://www.occ.gov/static/news-issuances/memos-advisory-letters/2001/advisory-letter-2001-9.pdf http://www.occ.gov/static/news-issuances/memos-advisory-lett... As for Scenario #1 - the 60 day limit is quite reasonable. What kind of investigation of unauthorized usage could a bank possibly conduct 60 days after an unauthorized $50 payment?
- venaoy 12y agoRegarding the advisory letter, it just requires the bank to "investigate". The bank can still conclude the transaction was authorized and deny your claim to cancel the transaction. So it will be your responsibility as a customer to prove that you were not present during the transaction. Regarding scenario #1, it is irrelevant if the amount is $50 or $1000. My point is, you have no recourse. Credit cards won't protect you from fraud in this case.
- hurin 12y agoAgain. You are incorrect and you don't what you're talking about, banks need to send a written explanation of a denial and in most cases they aren't partial (because usually they aren't the ones paying the refund) - since legally the merchant is responsible for confirming customer identity (it's not the customer that would have to prove they weren't there). Anyways, debating the effectiveness of consumer fraud-protection is quite beside the point, since Bitcoin offers absolutely no fraud protection and very circumstantial utility (i.e. the ability to make anonymous or pseudo-anonymous payments).
- shit_parade 12y agoCredit card fraud results in billions of dollars in losses every year, this is a problem bitcoin will very likely solve at a fraction of the cost.
- sanswork 12y agoThis makes sense since the Bitcoin system has been basically immune from fraud and scams up until this point.
- CyberDildonics 12y agoI didn't say anything about liability, I was talking about credit cards being canceled and suspended.
- ObviousScience 12y agoHave you ever had your bitcoins stolen? I'd rather have my credit card stolen, which I'm not liable for if I report it promptly, instead of just being out of the funds permanently.
- aianus 12y agoThe difference is that I don't go around sharing my bitcoin private keys with Target like I'm forced to do with my credit card details. FWIW I've never had any BTC stolen but I've had multiple credit cards canceled by my bank 'for my protection'.
- Nursie 12y agoActually, as the USA will finally move to EMV over the next year or so, no, you don't share your private key with target.
- wuliwong 12y agoObviously if I'm keeping my bitcoins in a private wallet on my computer and the computer is stolen, then I they are probably gone, like cash. But, I would assume that it is possible to have some insurance? If I had my house insured and cash was stolen, I could be reimbursed by the insurance, correct? I would assume the same thing could be done with bitcoin? And what about a situation like with Coinbase, if they are "hacked" or whatever, isn't it at least theoretically possible that the bitcoins could be insured? I think just as bitcoin fanatics are overzealous about the enhanced security of bitcoin, the other side can get a little short-sighted by not imagining any scenario where your bitcoin deposits are insured in some way.
- vectorpush 12y ago> Have you ever had your credit card stolen? I have. It was pretty inconvenient, but after a call to the bank, the stolen card was cancelled and the unauthorized transactions were reversed. If your bitcoins are stolen, the money is gone forever without any possibility of recovering the funds. > Have you ever had it frozen and not been able to spend your own money? No, that's never happened to me. I have once had a very large transaction automatically declined in the past, which was also inconvenient at the time, but the bank called me about it within 60 seconds of the transaction and I was able to resolve the issue right there. Reflecting on it later, I decided I liked the fact that my bank sought additional verification before authorizing a very large and unusual transaction. > Credit card fraud is incredibly rampant and the security measures in place by banks and sites is so over the top it becomes difficult to even use them. This is not an issue for me or anyone I know. I've never had a bank card payment rejected because of ghostery or an IP address or my VPN. Besides, even if I did, there is no reason why a business could not use identical signals for rejecting a bitcoin payment, especially since the consequences of bitcoin fraud or much more severe for the consumer. For the vast majority of consumers, bitcoin as currency, offers almost nothing in the way of advantages over bank cards; that's just the reality. This isn't to say that bitcoin is useless or that banks always have their customer's best interest at heart, but there's really no denying the fact that banks are safer and more convenient than bitcoin for most people.
- rhino369 12y ago>Have you ever had your credit card stolen? At least 3 times. It didn't cost me a cent. Chase sent a new one over 2 day air. Have you ever reversed a bitcoin charge because of a fraudulent seller?