4 ms·
What's the term for a program that's deliberately crippled to prevent you from doing what you want? Defective by design?
by tedunangst 12y ago
What's the term for a program that's deliberately crippled to prevent you from doing what you want? Defective by design?
- falcolas 12y agoDefective by Design is a FSF commentary about about how you should be able to use digital media in the same ways you would use physical media. They say nothing about the existing limits on your ability to re-distribute software or media (in fact, the FSF and GPL depend on copyright protections).
- hga 12y agoBut it sure sounds to me like the shoe fits. Enough that GCC is now existentially threatened by LLVM. ADDED: and I believe this is ~95% because of RMS's stewardship of the project (which already semi-died and was replaced by a fork), not the GPL, which is not a bad fit for a complete work like a compiler.
- scj 12y agoWould Apple's desire not to use the GPLv3, and subsequent funding of LLVM be related to RMS' actions?
- hga 12y agoRMS's stewardship of GCC most certainly includes re-licencing it under the GPLv3, it's all one of a part. And don't one or more of the BSDs have problems with the GLPv3 GCC? It's just not eeevil Apple (and that's part of why I swore off their products in 1987).
- detaro 12y agoFreeBSD switched to clang, OpenBSD afaik maintains forks of the last GPL2 versions. NetBSD and Dragonfly use GPLv3 gcc versions.
- terrywhite 12y agoIt's not defective because you are not the "user" to Stallman. The GPL is about limiting coders freedoms to maximise the freedom of end users (to see code, recompile it, alter the product they purchased). For Stallman a program/tool is "defective" if it enables programmers to limit end users access to code, .e.g. by enabling proprietary addons to the compiler.