3 ms·
>A very crude approximation of what people are -- but one that's better than many others -- is this: once they've ensured their survival, people are happy when
by eli_gottlieb 12y ago
>A very crude approximation of what people are -- but one that's better than many others -- is this: once they've ensured their survival, people are happy when they get what they want, and what they want is what they cannot get.
Counterpoints:
* Why should an unsatisifability instilled in us by evolution be reckoned as more ethically valuable than our actual well-being?
* What evidence shows the unsatisfiability is even there? Long-term studies have showed that many people live contented lives for what appear to be understandable psychological reasons.
* Provided it is, why could you not find or produce genuinely engaging challenges that don't boil down to "avoid being murdered by the other monkeys"?
This line of thought loses most of its coherency and thoroughness after managing what starts out sounding like an argument that simply solving one human problem will not immediately bring about utopia and thus does not justify mass violence (motte), but ends up proving much too much by claiming, in the end, that human happiness is categorically impossible and therefore all projects to improve life must inevitably fail (bailey) and result in horrifying mass murder (reductio ad Hitlerum).
(Terminology hints: http://slatestarcodex.com/2014/11/03/all-in-all-another-brick-in-the-motte/ http://slatestarcodex.com/2014/11/03/all-in-all-another-bric... and http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Proving_too_much http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Proving_too_much)
- pron 12y agoI think you've taken my cynical description as some mathematical claim which it isn't. > Why should an unsatisifability instilled in us by evolution be reckoned as more ethically valuable than our actual well-being? It shouldn't, but it still means that people might do potentially bad things even if everyone's physical well being is ensured, because contentment trumps ethics. I'm not saying it's right jus that it is. > What evidence shows the unsatisfiability is even there? The only specific study that I remember off-the-cuff is the one mentioned here [1] (search for "Mike Norton"), but, of course, I think this "unsatisfiabilty" is what brought us here to begin with. Without it, we'd still all be hunters-gatherers. Some of it probably has to do something with social comparison[2] EDIT: This is a published study: http://jeffreypfeffer.com/wp-content/uploads/2011/10/DeVoeMoneyImportance.pdf http://jeffreypfeffer.com/wp-content/uploads/2011/10/DeVoeMo... (overview here: http://www.upworthy.com/why-do-rich-people-seem-to-always-need-more-and-more-money http://www.upworthy.com/why-do-rich-people-seem-to-always-ne...) > Long-term studies have showed that many people live contented lives for what appear to be understandable psychological reasons. The problem with that is that much of that contentment appears to stem from the fact that others have less [2],[3] > Provided it is, why could you not find or produce genuinely engaging challenges Perhaps. But it is also possible that we have destructive urges that require satisfaction. Freud spends half of his Civilization and its Discontents exploring the "death urge". It isn't science -- far from it -- but it's pretty compelling. > argument that simply solving one human problem will not immediately bring about utopia ... I wasn't discussing a specific utopia (even though I personally dream of both a communist utopia and an anarchist utopia), but my thought experiment is meant to doubt that any kind of utopia is possible for a significant period of time. Imagine not how to get there, but what there looks like, and then, think for a while on whether people will really be happy for long in your utopia. That is not to say that we shouldn't strive to build our utopia -- in fact, the impossibility of achieving it is what ensures we'll always have something to do. > claiming ... that human happiness is categorically impossible Again, my "approximation" wasn't a well specified law of nature. People are happy with their achievements for a while -- until they're not. In fact, most people are happy some of the time, and some people are happy most the time, but I don't think all people can be happy all -- or even most -- of the time. It's quite possible that people's happiness depends on others' misery. I don't think happiness is impossible; I think utopia is. [1]: http://www.newrepublic.com/article/120092/billionaires-book-review-money-cant-buy-happiness http://www.newrepublic.com/article/120092/billionaires-book-... [2]: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Social_comparison_theory http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Social_comparison_theory [3]: http://www.nytimes.com/2011/07/02/your-money/02shortcuts.html?pagewanted=all http://www.nytimes.com/2011/07/02/your-money/02shortcuts.htm...