6 ms·
Free food is such a no-brainer, if you're a manager. For £5 of pizza you can get £50-100 of work, easy, and the workers think they're getting the better deal...
by gaius 12y ago
Free food is such a no-brainer, if you're a manager. For £5 of pizza you can get £50-100 of work, easy, and the workers think they're getting the better deal...
- Swizec 12y agoThis is why I like to say "Just pay me more, I can take care of my own perks. Promise." Sure, free food is great and all. But we're not kindergarteners are we? I'm an adult and I like to take care of my own food (and such). Free beer and pizza is for helping your friend move. Or for giving a talk at a *camp event. It's not for producing hundreds of thousands if not millions in value for your employer.
- cornellwright 12y agoAs an employer that provides free food, I think there's more to it than that in that both sides receive more value. We don't provide free food in order to pay our employees less. We provide free food because we see a lot of value in everyone eating together and employees get a lot of value in just not having to think about lunch or spend the time to go out and eat somewhere. I think most people get more value you out of the free food than if they were simply paid what it cost to provide. In the case of free food I see it as where both employer and employee do better with the in-kind perk than the equivalent cash alternative.
- Swizec 12y agoTrue, it does save time and thought. How much of depends primarily on location. The benefit is greater at something like a Google or Facebook campus, and much smaller at a small office in a downtown area with 20 restaurants in a 5min walk radius. But one too often sees perks like these offered as "Well, we're a startup, we can't pay you market rate, but we feed you". And that shit ain't right.
- meddlepal 12y agoYou provide free food because you get more working time out of your employees. Any other benefit your pushing is quite honestly, bullshit. They're sitting together? Great; odds are they're talking about their job and that's only beneficial to the employer. The other problem with free food is that it starts to feel like an obligation to consume it. I like eating out about once a week otherwise I brown-bag it most of the week with yogurt, fruit and some peanut butter crackers. If you make free food a perk (1) I don't feel like i'm maximizing my benefits (2) people start to think i'm not a team player because I don't want to eat pizza/burritos/chinese/indian/<Insert Food Here> five days a week.
- cornellwright 12y agoI fully embrace that we get more value out of providing free food than it costs us. That plus the fact that almost everyone seems to like it is enough of a reason to do it. Is sitting together and talking about your job ONLY beneficial to the employer? I feel like better communication and more discussion hopefully leading to doing a better job is also beneficial to the employee. Working on a more successful team probably leads to higher satisfaction and better long term career prospects. Even when I've worked in places that didn't provide food, all or almost all of the team still usually ate together, just because we liked what we were doing and enjoyed one another's company. My point is employees aren't losing anything by taking or not taking the perk. We wouldn't pay someone more not to eat the food. Aside from all the weird bad team dynamics that would cause it would also be a net-loss to the company. When people work from home, we also don't pay them any more, despite that we order less food and they have to buy/cook their own.
- Mandatum 12y agoIs sitting together and talking about your job ONLY beneficial to the employer? Yes, yes it is. Unless of course they're talking about leaving in which case it might not be.
- phamilton 12y agoIn an organization that enables and embraces employee initiatives, I have found that eatting together greatly benefits me, the employee. Cross team socializing has led to many new initiatives that were profitable for the company and for me personally (promotions and raises came as a result). Eating together can be accomplished through culture alone but providing food is probably easier and more successful.
- ryanSrich 12y agoThis is such an outdated way of thinking (asses in seats). Your company then completely eliminates the possibility of remote work if this lunch time eat-along is so important to the cogs in your machine. You're not providing your employees with food because it benefits them. You're providing your employees with food because it forces them to always be working. > We provide free food because we see a lot of value in everyone eating together and employees get a lot of value in just not having to think about lunch or spend the time to go out and eat somewhere. This is literally saying that your employees get free food so that they can stay at work and only think about work and only eat with people from work...
- MichaelGG 12y agoSome places may make it work, but teams not being together is a huge drawback. I think Peopleware covered it and it was one of the top detriments. Something like a 50% penalty in project schedules when teams were remote. That lines up with many projects I've seen first hand, too. Calling it outdated doesn't change anything. There's also tons of non-engineering stuff that benefits from being together, onsite. Stray comments might lead to huge import improvements. In my pervious company, there were always large things we'd find out when we'd have team leaders meet up. And this was a small 15 person business! It takes a lot of directed effort to make remote work. The GP post about wanting people together has a lot going for it.
- ryanSrich 12y ago> but teams not being together is a huge drawback Define together? What does that even mean? Together in the same room? I'd have to completely disagree. Teams working together is extremely important. Teams _being_ together, as in co-located, is just a preference. > Peopleware covered it and it was one of the top detriments Peopleware has ideas that have stood the test of time. However their opinions regarding remote work have not. The tools available to teams and engineers today are far superior to those in 2000 (not exactly sure on that date) > Something like a 50% penalty in project schedules when teams were remote This has absolutely nothing to do with remote work. This is just pure mismanagement. You cannot half-ass remote work. It's either a company wide culture or nothing at all. > There's also tons of non-engineering stuff that benefits from being together, onsite Like what? > Stray comments might lead to huge import improvements Just because you're not co-located does not mean you're just in silence throughout the day. There are a slew of chat clients and voice applications that allow remote teams to communicate easily throughout the day. > In my pervious company, there were always large things we'd find out when we'd have team leaders meet up. And this was a small 15 person business! Just because you're remote doesn't mean you don't have meetings. It also doesn't mean you never meet with people in person. > It takes a lot of directed effort to make remote work It takes a lot of directed effort to make any company culture work. And what exactly does "work" even mean? I've seen companies that are a complete mess and they have everyone strapped to their desks. Doing remote work right takes no more effort that doing co-location right. You just have to recognize the difference.
- kylec 12y agoI agree with this. My employer provides free lunch three days per week and I find myself wishing it was every day. Going out and finding lunch on my own is a huge hassle and takes a long time. I'm happy to quickly pop down to the cafeteria, grab a bite, and head right back to work. Win win.
- gaius 12y agoThey've done a number on you!
- thedufer 12y agoI'd like to second this. Where I work we get catered lunch, and it's clearly a win-win. Getting food outside the office is at least a 15 minute round-trip and, amazingly, almost always costs more than catering. We also have a good culture around it - people who don't feel like socializing frequently take food back to their desks instead of eating with everyone else, which I think removes some of the issues people take with the idea.
- Terr_ 12y agoIt's also a social signal for social animals: "We are doing well, we have ample necessities, you should be with our group."
- kelseyfrancis 12y agoI once had a major tech company tell me during negotiations that "you can't really put a price on free meals", which I thought was a truly absurd thing to say.
- jacalata 12y ago"That's valid, and that's why I'm going to consider them as $0 when calculating my total compensation".
- patio11 12y agoI have heard this line enough with regards to Google that I believe it is Standard Operating Procedure. Your counterparty knows they are in a negotiation. They have been in thousands of negotiations. They have a written list of words to say because they win negotiations. You can adapt to this environment, for example by coming in with prepared messaging of your own, and not meekly acquiescing to their first offer when their second offer is their first offer plus the food they were going to give you anyhow. (News you can use guys: this is also Standard Operating Procedure.)
- eru 12y agoWhy come in with a prepared message? You don't have to counter their message, when you can just dismiss it. Focus on the numbers.
- benihana 12y agoI feel like this is something that only inexperienced people fall for though. It's nice to get food, but perks like agency, autonomy, and trust are so much more important than free soda and pizza. Especially when I can get paid more and buy the kind of snacks I like.
- wyclif 12y agoAgency, trust, and autonomy are great, but they're no replacement for rock solid health, vision, and dental benefits, plus a matching 401k. Now that's sexy. Disclaimer: I'm married and a father.
- benihana 12y agoHa, touché. I was coming from the assumption that those things are a baseline that you'll get at most salaried programming jobs, but you're right for calling out that assumption. The hilarity of maturing. At 19, pizza, soda and video games after work were sexy. At 31, a stable retirement plan is what gets me revved up.
- GFischer 12y agoHowever, the absence of those can make you sad and bitter. I work at a company with rock solid health, vision, and dental benefits, very good working hours, and I can't wait to get out. It's full of married employees with children that hope to retire here. It is an excellent place for pregnant women, but no good if you're young or have any kind of ambition.
- wyclif 12y agoIt's not an either/or. Ideally, I prefer the both/and.
- gaius 12y agoIt is a bit more complex than that, a generation of geeks have been socialised to believe that eating free pizza at work is "living the dream". Even guys who are well experienced in the industry can fall for it. There are a whole bunch of tricks a savvy employer can use that cost next to nothing compared to the overtime the workers do in return for it.
- orblivion 12y agoYou may be right that it's not a win for the developer. But when talking about perks like this one, I don't understand why people approach analysis as if it's an adversarial relationship. A good deal for the company may also be a good deal for the developer. Why should I only accept a perk if I think I'm screwing over the company? However much they benefit from it, outside of assessing my negotiating position, is none of my business. To put another way, why would I expect to be offered a perk if it didn't benefit the company as well?
- gaius 12y agoIt becomes adversarial when its used as a substitute. E.g. companies who push the line that lower than market wages are compensated for by pizza, table football, beanbags, stock options...