5 ms·
It isn't like the internet because electronic ledger technology and instant money transmission services already exist, and indeed are used by basically everyone
by notahacker 12y ago
It isn't like the internet because electronic ledger technology and instant money transmission services already exist, and indeed are used by basically everyone that BTC is accessible to. If using the conventional banking system occasionally seems like mailing floppy disks to people, the hurdles to effortless universal payments are regulatory rather than technological
"Access to news, music and videos in minutes from anywhere in the world with a computer modem" is a much more revolutionary pitch to the consumer than "but see, not only is blockchain technology better than those old mainframes your bank uses... it's decentralised... here's a CATO institute article.... yeah, and you can convert it back to dollars too"
- natrius 12y agoYou're right in the sense that distributed ledgers are effectively an end run around regulations and trusted parties who we pay for centralized ledgers today. I think you're underestimating how important that is. Transaction fees are going to zero. Markets are moving to blockchains: securities markets, eBay-style markets for goods, Uber-style markets for services. Markets that have been regulated out of existence will now thrive. Drug markets get all the press, but prediction markets will change the world. (http://augur.net/ http://augur.net/) We currently pay banks to keep our money safe and to make it digital so we can swipe a card or enter some numbers to send money. Distributed ledgers combined with current and future software do that for free. Today, everyone's money has to be in a bank, so they get to keep almost all the profit from your money. In the near future, your money will be safe, digital, and controlled by you. When you decide to lend it to other people, you'll get paid more to lend your money out. Most countries have currencies that harm their economies and/or decrease in value rapidly. Distributed ledgers and the financial derivatives that can be built on top of them will give the whole world stable currency. This outcome isn't just an end run around regulations or trusted parties: it's a new thing that just wasn't possible before. We have better technology to build currencies now. It's definitely harder to pitch blockchains to consumers as revolutionary, but if you think about it for a while and still conclude that it's not going to have a huge impact on the world, I think you've missed something.
- danbruc 12y agoMaybe there will be a successful cryptocurrency at some point but chances are (very close to) zero that it will be Bitcoin. Bitcoin is dying. EDIT: Read that [1] for my reasoning instead of blindly down voting opinions you don't like or at least point out where I am wrong. [1] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8905475 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8905475
- patrickaljord 12y ago> Bitcoin is dying. http://bitcoinobituaries.com/ http://bitcoinobituaries.com/
- danbruc 12y agoI am aware that I am not the only one convinced that Bitcoin will fail. Maybe the Bitcoin price will even stop falling and rise again once more, but finally it will fail. See the linked comment for my reasoning.
- patrickaljord 12y agoThe transaction fee argument is an old one, as the answers to your comments say, it isn't what will make bitcoin fail.
- danbruc 12y agoThey argued about the exact numbers but they did by no means show that the argument is invalid. Bitcoin has no important advantages over credit cards or PayPal, besides the claimed low transaction costs. And this argument is not true, not now and it is not obvious that it will become true in the future.
- patrickaljord 12y agoThe number one innovation from bitcoin is not its low transaction cost. Its the blockchain, that is to say the possibility for two people to make a transaction without a centralized third party involved.
- wyager 12y agoDo you really not see the difference between Bitcoin and, say, Paypal? Bitcoin closely resembles a strictly finite physical resource. Paypal does no such thing. Bitcoin is money. Paypal is a system for sending money.
- trevelyan 12y agoRight now all other electronic payment networks require the extension of credit somewhere in the system. Credit card companies offload the risk of managing this to payment gateways, but it is still there. This leads to expensive things like PCI-compliance requirements and chargebacks-for-profit. By eliminating the need for credit, bitcoin eliminates an entire horizontal layer in the payments industry. The first uses are thus obviously biased towards high-risk transactions, but it will be surprising if a lot of high-cost merchants like airlines aren't accepting bitcoin in 2-3 years, if only because 2-3% of a 3000 USD ticket is a lot of cash to pay a middleman if the consumer trusts you enough to handle the transaction directly.
- notahacker 12y agoCredit is a feature rather than a bug in the existing system And Bitcoin actually adds a horizontal layer: the average person needs to go to an exchange to get BTC[1]. Assuming they don't want to wait for the funds to clear, they're relying on credit to obtain the BTC (otherwise they're speculating on the price of an extremely volatile asset whilst they wait, which is hardly an improvement). They then pay the BTC to an entity that almost certainly converts them instantly back to USD via Coinbase/BitPay which again involves the extension of credit and acceptance of counterparty risk. The transaction may well involve more intermediaries than doing it in dollars. Sure, converting between regular currency and BTC currently involves lower spreads/fees than mainstream payment processors. But that's not the magic of the blockchain revolution; that's the exchanges' having an altogether different approach to risk management, regulation and near-term profitability than the mainstream processors [1]Or they could buy ASICs, I suppose, or go work for a funky startup that pays bonuses in BTC. But for everyone else, there's MasterCard
- trevelyan 12y agoIt is a bug having to ask for permission to collect money electronically. And assuming you get permission, it is a bug to get charged more than a penny or two for having your transaction processed. It's a bug not being able to receive/send cash anonymously, or to be censored because... because... what crime did Wikileaks commit? Credit is a bug if you're an offshore company that can't find a payment processor or has your payments held for three months before release because the War on Terror means offshore companies are now suspect. It's a bug when your business sounds high-risk or illegal but actually isn't. It's a bug because the people who get employed managing this risk don't do a good job themselves and are often complicit in gaming the system. And it is a bug when you're in an industry where credit card fraud is rampant, because now the inability of the industry to handle data security means you pay twice, once when you're ripped-off by the customer and then a second-time when you get ripped-off by your bank with the chargeback. The need for credit is a huge bug in the way it forces companies to be PCI-compliant (why should we be devoting massive economic resources to this?). And it is a bug in that it requires people to have credit cards, which requires them to have credit records, which brings up another set of problems.... Your complaint seems to be mostly that you don't have bitcoin and it would take you a single extra transaction to get it (something already easier than applying for a credit card, and/or paying your bills and frankly getting easier). But if you think bitcoin is more difficult than the alternatives, think as a conceptual exercise of programming a machine to buy and sell things with a credit card and pay its bills automatically. And once the tech is in place, apply for a credit account for the machine....