4 ms·
No no. I take issue with the mentality that just because two students in a lab can quickly approach state of the art, necessarily implies they have hit on a re
by taeric 12y ago
No no. I take issue with the mentality that just because two students in a lab can quickly approach state of the art, necessarily implies they have hit on a revolutionary approach.
I am all for promising results. But the "two students in a lab" is borderline meaningless to me. The real story is, "we performed some research, and it looked like it had promise. So we kept at it."
Basically, I reject the "it was clear that if we could get results that good on the first serious try..." I mean, first off, was it the first try, or the first serious try. Why the qualifier? Secondly, science and progress is full of things that were clear, but wrong.
I don't like arguing this point, as I do want to preserve the optimism that is in the air. However, it does grate at me, at times. It is essentially survivor bias in action.
- grayclhn 12y agoFair enough. I agree that it's at best lazy rhetorical shorthand here and I can see why it could be grating.