2 ms·
>The assumption here is that asking questions divorced from scientific training is a reasonable thing to do. Of course it is a reasonable thing to do, e.g. "Is
by foldr 17y ago
>The assumption here is that asking questions divorced from scientific training is a reasonable thing to do.
Of course it is a reasonable thing to do, e.g. "Is there any milk left in the fridge?"
I suppose you're asking whether it's reasonable to ask "deep" questions without scientific training. I think that it is -- moral questions are an obvious example -- but in any case, bear in mind that most philosophers whose work touches on scientific issues _do_ have some scientific training.
It's really not possible to consider all this at such an abstract level. If you have something against philosophy or philosophers, you'd do well to point out some concrete examples of what you're talking about, instead of engaging in this sort of generic scientistic whining.
The biggest irony here is that your views are taken almost verbatim from a philosophical movement of the early 20th century (logical positivism). One benefit of reading some philosophy is coming to a realization of how unoriginal virtually all of your ideas are, and how much they owe to the intellectual culture you were brought up in.