2 ms·
>Theology, meanwhile, requires you first to assume the existence of God That's just not true. There's plenty of theology which you can enter into without a pri
by foldr 17y ago
>Theology, meanwhile, requires you first to assume the existence of God
That's just not true. There's plenty of theology which you can enter into without a prior assumption of the existence of god. The most obvious example would be arguments _for_ the existence of God! But in general, most of theology can be appreciated while taking God's existence as a hypothetical. E.g. you can consider whether or not the existence of evil is compatible with the presence of an omnipotent and wholly good God. (And indeed, theologians spend a lot of time considering arguments _against_ God's existence based on the existence of evil, and these arguments clearly cannot presuppose his existence.)
By the way, have you ever read any theology?
- unalone 17y agoI have. I took a course on religion last semester. Generally, I agreed with and loved the various sociological theories—the things that tried to explain the psychological origins of religion, for instance, were fascinating. But past a certain point, I find that I lose interest. I can't entertain a debate over whether evil could exist under a good God, because I don't believe in God or in evil.
- foldr 17y agoIf you don't find it interesting then you don't find it interesting, but that's quite a retreat from what you were claiming in your initial comment. >because I don't believe in God or in evil. You don't believe that evil things happen?
- unalone 17y agoI believe that calling something evil is gross oversimplifation. Terrible things happen. Evil has overtones that I disagree with, if that makes sense.
- foldr 17y agoIt makes a little bit of sense, but I don't see how it's relevant to the problem of evil. You can pose the problem with pretty much whatever notion of evil you like: "If there is a good, omnipotent God, why do terrible things happen?"
- unalone 17y agoWell, yeah. That's why nonbelief hurts the debate also. My response is a simple "There isn't." Kind of a flat debate.
- foldr 17y agoAs I said, whether or not God exists, the question remains whether or not the existence of God is _compatible_ with the existence of evil. That's what theologians actually discuss. Stating God's non-existence just doesn't address the question at issue.
- jamesbritt 17y agoWell, it does in that before looking at the relationship of gods and evil, you first have to establish what, exactly, are the characteristics of gods, how many gods are there, etc. Do theologians consider the case for all of concievable gods? Multiple gods? Only one god?
- foldr 17y ago> Do theologians consider the case for all of concievable gods? Multiple gods? Only one god? Obviously, as has been explained, the problem arises in connection with all gods who are perfectly good and also omnipotent, so I don't quite see what you're getting at here.
- jamesbritt 17y ago"I don't quite see what you're getting at here." Without first establishing the number of gods and their qualities, questions about how they deal with evil seems pointless.