2 ms·
You are seriously saying that trans-border data flows are so analogous to the operation of custom houses that the 4th it completely meaningless just because som
by Zigurd 12y ago
You are seriously saying that trans-border data flows are so analogous to the operation of custom houses that the 4th it completely meaningless just because someone is carrying my data across borders?
Funny how tariffs on imports were never applied to data. That analogy proved to be invalid. And yet, tariffs are what border searches were meant to enforce.
- rayiner 12y agoThere's no analogy. Borders are fundamental--states exist in part to create the difference between "inside" and "outside" the border. And historically the understanding has been that states have authority over anything that crosses the border into or from foreign territory. The tariff issue is irrelevant. Congress chose not to apply tariffs to international data flows. They did it for pragmatic reasons, not because they couldn't.
- Zigurd 12y ago> They did it for pragmatic reasons, not because they couldn't. I didn't climb onto the 10 foot roof with a 6 foot ladder because it wouldn't work, not because I couldn't. Like that?