2 ms·
Fine. One more time, then I'm heading to the bar. > Good to know social justice inquisition can be conducted without actually engaging with someone. Silence th
by vinceguidry 12y ago
Fine. One more time, then I'm heading to the bar.
> Good to know social justice inquisition can be conducted without actually engaging with someone. Silence the infidel! He speaks heresy!
There does seem to be a quasi-religious aspect to the social justice movement. I consider it a feature rather than a bug. Just be glad it's not a real inquisition. If you think this is bad...
> Institutions can be precisely and accurately defined. We can start with units of individuals.
Okay, let's give this a shot. How about the institution of Hollywood? You have the film makers, actors, film crew, producers. Then you have the major studios, the lawyers. How about the accountants? Are they part of the institution? They work on location in the industry, so let's throw them in.
What about the cinemas? They're not in Hollywood proper, but they license the movies and make a profit off of them. Doesn't feel completely right, but lets add them in too.
The people that go to the cinemas? They're the ones that keep the system going, that ultimately decide what movies get made. Feels even less right, but let's throw them in for good measure.
People that watch movies and television? You mean, "everyone"? That's the problem with your approach. The line that says whether someone's in an institution or not is always going to be at least somewhat arbitrary. Institutions are intended to be this way, to have wide-ranging social effects.
What about the institution of slavery? Is everyone that profited from slavery a part of the institution? If so, you're back at "it's no one's fault". If not, you're ultimately being arbitrary as to who is contributing to an institution.
I hope this satisfies your desire for precision. I spent five paragraphs outlining one specific concept. Imagine if I had to do this for everything you bring up in your long posts. I'd need even more words to be as precise as you'd want me to be. That's why I said precision and accuracy aren't always possible. It was as precise as I could convey that concept without writing a book about it.
Now that I've spilled all these words on one topic, I find myself with little left in the tank for the rest of your points. Now I shall silence and marginalize and conduct a crusade against you by not replying to any of your future posts. Think about that for a moment.
- sighsighsigh 12y ago> There does seem to be a quasi-religious aspect to the social justice movement. I consider it a feature rather than a bug. Just be glad it's not a real inquisition. If you think this is bad... When people lose their jobs, their ability to feed their family, and their ability to provide for their future... all because someone generated pixels that made the faithful squeamish... Yes, that is a de facto inquisition. > Hollywood Example You loosely defined professions and roles of the Hollywood "institution" and still didn't name any individuals. And you left out the cleaning crews, the assistant producers, the politicians who get tax revenue from Hollywood productions, the recipients of social welfare programs from those tax dollars, the cocaine dealers for those amazing Hollywood parties, the cloud datacenters that distribute the movies, and the lumberjacks who cut down the trees to produce the large billboards. And that's just the tip of the iceberg on who actually makes up the Hollywood "institution". Those incidious lumberjacks. They must be punished because insitutioniness! You attempt to speak of the difficulty to deliniate blame, but in reality, you are only speaking in terms of pragmatic resource expenditure. If there was a cheap and easy way to punish the hundreds of millions of people consuming the output of the Hollywood "institution", you'd absolutely do it with the ease of which you silence individuals via flagging and down votes! I don't doubt that for a second. But since not even the mighty social justice crusade has such power, they have to keep the rhetoric and the strategies more pragmatic. Which means the lines YOU are INDIVIDUALLY using to determine who is and is not part of the "institution" is only as objective as your ability to punish effectively. You simply target whoever you can reach and then justify it as collateral damage. > What about the institution of slavery? Is everyone that profited from slavery a part of the institution? If so, you're back at "it's no one's fault". If not, you're ultimately being arbitrary as to who is contributing to an institution. I state it again: How many people can your religion punish at the same time? If you can effectively punish hundreds of millions of people, then I'm very sure you'd happily do so. But since you can't, you'll go after whatever you can afford... for the cause, you understand. > Imagine if I had to do this for everything you bring up in your long posts Oh, the horror of exchanging perspectives. You'll do anything to preserve the free hand you need shift who is an isn't part of an institution. Punishment is more important than anything else, and we can't let something a rigid as a precise category get in the way, can we? In reality, your enemy is whoever you can afford to go after at that moment in time. That's the actual precise answer you are actually saying. > Now that I've spilled all these words on one topic, I find myself with little left in the tank for the rest of your points. Now I shall silence and marginalize and conduct a crusade against you by not replying to any of your future posts. Think about that for a moment. I've given it exactly one moment and I have concluded that you either need a bigger tank or more experience with handling perspectives that you don't agree with.
- afarrell 12y agotake heart in the fact that this random reader found your exploration of "What is an institution if you can't say who is an is not a part of it?" enlightening and will probably use your words in some later conversation.
- vinceguidry 12y agoYeah, I think of troll-feeding as an excellent opportunity to think more deeply about things that I hadn't really considered previously. The problem is that, at least in this community, it produces these crazy ginormous threads that totally overtake the rest of the discussion. And to be honest, most people don't do it well at all. So not only is there this huge blob, but there's nothing really interesting in it. Not every form of discourse is appropriate for every forum.
- vegedor 12y agoIf the range of individuals involved in cinema covers the whole board, it just goes to show that cinema is an American institution. Nevertheless, an extreme individual could absolutely not endorse the whole of it. Individual blame is virtually arbitrary, but really, patterns of behavior are identifiably and problematic and can be attributed to persons. >I'd need even more words to be as precise as you'd want me to be. Ironically, that's the exact opposite of what precise means, taking the sentence out of context at least. This thread is rather sad, because you two actually seem to try to say the same thing.