4 ms·
It's not quite that simple. Original sin was conceived of as a way to explain and deal with the everyday depravity of the time period. It was often described t
by vinceguidry 12y ago
It's not quite that simple.
Original sin was conceived of as a way to explain and deal with the everyday depravity of the time period. It was often described that people had weird, strange urges they couldn't understand or control. Christian atonement (prayer is nothing if not a form of meditation) was thus an early form of personal development. Later on, after people and modern society started to mature this got recast as a tool for social control.
Social justice philosophy does not make the claim that everyone is racist / sexist. The claim is that injustice and prejudice are institutionalized, and so there exist entire lines of thought, patterns of behavior, and such that arose out of the institutionalized bigotry that never would have existed without it.
To take a currently-topical example, the comic book store article. The author of the article came violently face-to-face with institutionalized sexism and what happens when you allow the economy to structure itself with a completely free hand.
You can debate the merits of whether this structure is right or wrong, whether comic book store owners should feel guilty about it and obligate themselves to change, and that's an important discussion to have; but the real issue is the fact that nobody knows about these consequences until they have this kind of enlightening moment.
Sexism is institutionalized in a way that nobody really digs into or understands it and can live their entire lives without appreciating the consequences it has on everyone. Is everyone racist / sexist? The question itself is a red herring, the real issue is this institutionalization.
- sighsigh 12y agoTo the audience, like I care about HackerNews points, down vote me to oblivion, plebiscite. To address your point, you say social justice doesn't claim everyone is racist, and them you say the racism is institutional... and then you mysteriously fail to define who makes up the institutions and who those institutions affect. (While implying it's everyone) The audience is left to subjectively define that to make you seem right. If everyone isn't racist and the racism is institutional, are there extra-institutional people wandering the earth, too enlightened to be bothered with such trivial institutioniness? What's the secret? Is it the yoga pants, the flannel, or the liberal arts degree? Define your actors. Precisely.
- woodman 12y agoThe solution to institutional injustice being what? I really feel for the folks trying to address the problem, but I've yet to see a solution based on a solid root cause analysis. I completely agree with your point on the "enlightening moment", it is quite an experience when your world view suddenly shifts due to new information. I would say that the root cause is ignorance at the human level, which gets incorporated into institutions - which are slow in adapting to social evolution. These institutions end up acting as drogues, slowing social progress. It might be time for us to evaluate the value of these institutions vs the cost. I doubt any of this is novel to somebody who a studied the problem, so I wonder why the solutions posed always seem to be bolt-ons.
- vinceguidry 12y agoYou're looking at it. The only real solution that could ever be effective is to raise enough awareness of institutionalized bigotry so there's a critical mass of people interested in real change. Realistically this means that issues will get raised and dealt with on smaller scales, slowly bringing awareness to more and more people. Over time more and more people will clamor for the destruction of cultural traditions rooted in bigotry. Which is precisely what's happening. The tech community, with its forward-thinking outlook, has become a foremost battleground. The larger feminist movement has been grappling with trying to include more men among their numbers, the vast majority of them just tune out feminist ideology. You can't destroy institutions. What you can do is change peoples' consciousness so social injustices within those institutions gain attention instead of being ignored.
- woodman 12y agoSounds like the plan is just more bolt-ons. Unless we are converging on a universally preferable society, this is a struggle that will go on forever as society evolves. I do agree that institutions can't be destroyed, as they're simply abstract concepts, but they can be disarmed in such a way that their influence is inconsequential (from the perspective of voluntary association). I do think the future is bright, the free exchange of information being key.