4 ms·
Somebody has to actually write the new functionality, and then many more people have to learn the new functionality. Anyway, this thought experiment has basica
by nostrademons 12y ago
Somebody has to actually write the new functionality, and then many more people have to learn the new functionality.
Anyway, this thought experiment has basically been done. "Ditch the backwards compatibility, start with a new language, make it fast by design, and rewrite all the packages that make it super popular." It's called Julia. And it's popular among some people, but for a lot of others, the maturity of the Python ecosystem still makes it a lot more attractive despite the performance & multi-language issues.
- rdc12 12y agoBut Julia is a really young language, drawing that comparison is a bit premature, be more interesting to look at that in 2-4 years time
- ForHackernews 12y agoJulia is incredible, but I worry about its future because, unlike some other promising-but-not-quite-mature languages like Go or Rust, Julia doesn't have any kind of corporate or organizational patron promoting it and investing big money in it.
- rdc12 12y agoAnd yet it has created a remarkable amount of buzz around it already
- Derbasti 12y agoIsn't it being developed by the MIT? I'm not sure about "big" money, but it sure is being backed.
- ForHackernews 12y agoAFAIK, it doesn't have any kind of official institutional backing from MIT. Some of the creators are MIT faculty, but I don't think that makes it "An MIT Project" in the way that Go is a Google Project.
- grayclhn 12y agoTrue, but unlike Go or Rust, it probably only needs to be better than Matlab to have a successful future.
- ForHackernews 12y agoThat might be true, but I think they're also targeting some of the R / NumPy market. Those are both pretty mature, and it could be hard to make inroads.
- grayclhn 12y agoDefinitely. My (indirect) point was that scientific computing is a much less competitive area than Go and Rust are targeting. And I can imagine a world where NumPy, R, and Julia are all strong projects. Arguably, lack of commercial support is a bigger problem for mature projects than young projects. Whether or not Julia pulls away users from R probably has more to do with how much R adapts to new directions in statistics than with anything Julia does (assuming that julia passes a minimum threshold of credibility, which it probably doesn't yet for most statisticians.) A lot of my interest in julia comes from a specific simulation that I need to run to prototype a new estimator that would be infeasible in straight R. If R were faster, I wouldn't bother.... (To preempt the obvious reply, I could always write the slow part in C. But if I need to introduce a different language anyway, why not look at other options?)
- cossatot 12y agoI believe that Julia still uses a lot of C/FORTRAN packages that numpy relies on, like BLAS, so they're not really re-written in Julia (at least yet?).
- CyberDildonics 12y agoI think he meant re-do the bindings. A lot of Julia is written in itself, but not things like that. Large libraries benefit from Julia's extremely simple C calling mechanisms.