3 ms·
Well, let me try to convince you of the futility of trying to convince other people to change their views.... oh wait... :) Anyways, the last point, handing ca
by pm90 12y ago
Well, let me try to convince you of the futility of trying to convince other people to change their views.... oh wait... :)
Anyways, the last point, handing cash out to people, will essentially not work for the exact same reason: logistics. Who will do the handing out? The same agencies that are supposed to give grains at subsidized rates? How well is that working?
- ihnorton 12y ago> Anyways, the last point, handing cash out to people, will essentially not work for the exact same reason: logistics. Not that I disagree with the broader point, but a number of countries have had electronic benefit transfers for years (possibly decades). Perhaps this wasn't feasible on the scale of India in the past - I don't know - but it is much more feasible now with the widespread use of mobile phones. There is probably already an Indian equivalent to the m-pesa mobile-based money transfer system in eastern Africa. There is a growing body of evidence supporting the effectiveness of direct, "cash"-based transfers in reducing poverty, from Joia Mukherjee (MIT Poverty Lab) and others. EBT and mobile transfers have the added benefit of significantly reducing opportunities for graft.