5 ms·
India Is Building the World's Largest Magnet to Hunt Neutrinos
- quonn 12y agoWell, if you are still at the receiving end of much international support, if millions of your people are still dying of hunger ... Then, maybe, a mars mission and now this should not be one of your priorities. For example, Germany does not have a mars mission. But if you're Indian, you can apply to many _German_ government programs to do come here any study for free. While _your_ government wastes your money on hunting neutrinos. This is a very unfortunate state of affairs. edit: I will say this, whether HN wants to hear it nor not. I'm happy to spend some karma. :)
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- quonn 12y agoMy comment has actual content, addresses a real social issue and has a positive intent, unlike yours. But to your point: You can remind me of Hitler as much as you want. Everyone does it. I'm ok with that. I was born 50 years after he was elected and I'm politically on the left-liberal side, which is exactly opposed to right-authoritarian. I sure don't feel responsible.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- quonn 12y ago> Why are you mooching off american web/forums instead of developing your own german websites? What's wrong with american websites? Please explain. > when there are people going to bed hungry in your "Germany" Here, as in most parts of Europe (maybe I should have written Europe in my first comment, to avoid people Godwining me), there is a working social system that prevents this. The government pays for whatever you need, currently I think about 1200 Euros per month, for free.
- negamax 12y agoThe moment Swiss bank changed their rate Euro crashed 25% to it. It has pretty much declined against INR by that much as well in past six months. Good for you that your government rather borrow money and spend it lavishly to buy votes instead of doing anything worthwhile with it like India. Only a matter of time when Euro will have no real value if you continue down this path. Your whole continent is pretty much acting like Greece. Corrupt but pretending there's any substance.
- dang 12y agoPersonal attacks are not allowed on Hacker News, even when someone else has commented inappropriately.
- sremani 12y agoHow do you expect Indian Physicists to get employment by building toilets ? Or by going around with begging bowls to Germany and collect some food. Your argument is so much racist in multitude of ways, why the heck there is Royal Society of Science when there was poverty in London in 1800s. May be India has no right to build labs till all Indians are fed ? FYI, India produces more grain than it consumes the problem is logistical, economical and political. There is no wide spread hunger deaths, even though abject poverty is a reality. Having a mars program or science lab is not stopping India from resolving these issues. Please just go away, when you have no idea what you are talking about. There are 47 million people on food stamps in america and 1 in 3 children in US go hungry at night. So may be we should close NASA and Stanford and wait till this problem is resolved. Correction: My 1 in 3 was based on ads of North Texas food bank, apparently it is incorrect. As others replied it is close to 1 in 5.
- quonn 12y ago> There is no wide spread hunger deaths Here is the first Google result I got: "India's hunger 'shame': 3,000 children die every day, despite economic growth". http://worldnews.nbcnews.com/_news/2012/02/16/10424930-indias-hunger-shame-3000-children-die-every-day-despite-economic-growth?lite http://worldnews.nbcnews.com/_news/2012/02/16/10424930-india...
- balabaster 12y agoLet's say you have $10, you can feed yourself for $10 or you can go hungry today and invest that $10 for $20 back tomorrow... tomorrow, you can feed yourself and invest the rest for more back the next day. Your vision lacks forethought. Tomorrow you can feed many times more people with the yield from today's investment than you could today if you didn't invest.
- hueving 12y agoThat would be great if detecting neutrinos was related to India's food industry.
- jonsen 12y agoSocietal evolution is not that simple http://www.santafe.edu/research/themes/human-behavior-institutions-and-social-systems/ http://www.santafe.edu/research/themes/human-behavior-instit...
- maskedinvader 12y agocorrect me if i'm wrong, but this is what you are saying "poor countries should spend money on feeding the poor instead of funding fancy science projects" well allow me to retort, having science projects trying to answer some of the biggest un-answered scientific questions would help with the following: 1. Retention of Talent: would enable physists to stay in india rather than immigrate elsewhere. 2. Boosts Economy: Expenditure as salary stays within the country and can help boost economy. 3. Innovation : innovation in advanced fields of physicts/space exploration can help develop new consumer technologies. 3. would enable governments to get international fame/credibility and quite possibly a seat at the big boy table. Now you might wonder is this worth it, well I believe its worth spending a fraction of the GDP to fund such projects. Its not like all the funding given to such projects can solve the various poverty related problems the country faces.
- quonn 12y agoFirst, thank you for this reasonable response. To address our points: 1) Maybe. But probably you can retain many good scientists when doing projects that will contribute the GDP eventually. 2) Sounds plausible. 3) It can, but India fails to develop even basic technology at scale in decent quality. I guess I will get downvoted again, but this is simply a fact. I have lived in India for a year. I know. 4) I guess that is the purpose. It might also get foreign governments to reconsider their foreign aid, perhaps rightly so. If India would be where China is now, I would understand all this. But they aren't. Not even close. Not even in 20 years will they be close. And they are not, because they don't deal with the important issues _first_.
- negamax 12y agoI am Indian. Which German programs can I apply to, to come over there to study for free. All that welfare is creating a generation of utter retards. Germany is likely the only EU country which has upside left due to great work ethics. Pretty much everyone else is living on borrowed money and is in decadence. May be EU should lift everyone out of state dependence instead of sending Europa probe? No it shouldn't. Someone has to be extremely ignorant to not see disconnect between these challenges.
- parennoob 12y ago> But if you're Indian, you can apply to many _German_ government programs to do come here any study for free. While _your_ government wastes your money on hunting neutrinos. This has nothing to do with actions of the Indian Government. If you don't want the German Government to run programs for international students, feel free to appeal to them.
- quonn 12y agoWhy should I? I think it's a good idea to run these programs.
- jogjayr 12y agoYou're spending your karma in the wrong place. Your logic is simplistic: those people don't have money, so they shouldn't be spending it on things I consider frivolous (for someone in their situation). You're failing to consider the following: 1. How does a poor country become rich? Why by developing its science and technology, of course (well technically, by becoming more productive, but you know what I'm saying). If we don't develop our own science and tech, we're going to be relegated to manufacturing textiles and outsourced software projects pretty much forever. Doing those things hasn't eliminated hunger so far, so why expect anything different in the future? 2. How much aid does India really receive? According to Wikipedia (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_countries_by_foreign_aid_received http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_countries_by_foreign_ai...) it ranked 18th on the list in 2012. Sounds high, until you consider that the normally-considered-developed countries of Israel and Turkey are 4th and 5th on the list. On a per-capita basis, I'm willing to bet it is even lower 3. How much do you really know about how the Indian government spends its money? Did you know we spend about 38 times as much on our armed forces as our space agency? Like any other large government, we waste money on some areas and allocate and spend it wisely in others. Research that produces results is never a waste and many Indian government agencies (ISRO and DRDO) have a solid track record in this regard. 4. There are immediate benefits to science and tech spending to even poor Indians. For example Oceansat-2, a remote sensing satellite launched by ISRO (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Oceansat-2 http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Oceansat-2). Per Wikipedia, it's used for coastal zone planning and identification of fishing areas, among other things. Other satellites provide weather information, which again is used by fishermen, many of whom are poor. Not to mention all the spin-off technology from defense and other research (handwaving, but I can't be bothered to look up citations right now). EDIT: ISRO also _makes_ money by taking on satellite launching contracts. Their commercial arm Antrix Corp made $33m profit in 2013-2014 (if I'm doing the conversion right: http://www.antrix.gov.in/pdf/ANNUAL_REPORT_2013_2014_English.pdf http://www.antrix.gov.in/pdf/ANNUAL_REPORT_2013_2014_English...) 5. Like another commenter has mentioned elsewhere, we produce surplus food. The reason it doesn't get to all the hungry people who need it is pretty much the same reason people go hungry in developed countries: market failures and government aid not reaching the right people at the right time. These aren't things that are solved by diverting money away from research (unless it's to hand out straight cash to poor people, I guess, which almost no country does). There's always a rash of commenters saying "feed your hungry" whenever they read a story about India doing science. I hope I've reduced their numbers by one at least.
- kryptiskt 12y agoThat Germany doesn't pull its weight in space reflects badly on Germany, not India. Germany should shape up.
- dang 12y ago"Please avoid introducing classic flamewar topics unless you have something genuinely new to say about them." https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- trhway 12y ago>Well, if you are still at the receiving end of much international support, if millions of your people are still dying of hunger ... Then, maybe, a mars mission and now this should not be one of your priorities. man, your sentiment and logic is understandable. Yet, do you seriously think that by dropping Mars mission India would have changed anything in the plight of the poor people there? There still would be the same poor and no Mars mission. The Mars mission serves enlightenment and progress and those are the most effective things which improve society and the lives of poor in particular (wrt. enlightenment for example - judging by the price tab, India's Mars mission didn't have any corruption or money mismanagement to speak of which on its own is a great achievement on par with developed Western countries and well ahead of countries like Russia or China)
- pavel_lishin 12y agoI wish they would explain how a magnet is going to help them detect neutrinos.
- im2w1l 12y agoWas thinking the same thing. INO's website[0] explains it. They will look at the tracks of charged particles produced when the neutrinos interact with atomic nuclei. [0] http://www.ino.tifr.res.in/ino//about.php http://www.ino.tifr.res.in/ino//about.php
- joelthelion 12y agoAlso I'd love to know how strong the magnet is.
- tjradcliffe 12y agoThe link im2w1 provided has some useful detail. Here's a former neutrino physicist's take: 1) They are looking at atmospheric (cosmic ray) neutrinos, not solar neutrinos like most of the other large underground detectors (SNO, Kamiokande, etc). When cosmic rays (mostly high energy protons) strike nuclei the upper atmosphere, they create a shower of high-energy particles, including neutrinos and anti-neutrinos. Cosmic rays make an interesting laboratory for some important processes because they have energies that go far higher than anything achievable in accelerators. The LHC has collision energies up to 1.3E13 eV (about 13,000 times the mass of a proton). Cosmic rays have energies at detectable fluxes up to 10E20 eV or and likely useful flux for this kind of experiment at energies a factor of ten or more greater than the LHC is capable of, and they do it for free: all you have to do is build the detector. 2) When high-energy neutrinos or anti-neutrinos interact with the material of the detector, they produce particle and anti-particle showers. How much of each is dependent on the detail of the weak interaction coupling constants and other neutrino properties. So one wants to know in detail how much of each type of particle is created. There are various ways of doing this, but it is an unfortunate geometric reality that most of the mass in any detector is close to the outside of the volume (this is a pain because most of the background in such detectors comes from the outside, and you typically have to put geometric cuts on that excludes the outer detector volume, losing up to 25% of your detector mass in the process). Because of this, many high-energy particles created by neutrinos in the detector will leave it before they stop, so there is no way to use annihilation radiation to identify the anti-matter (positrons, anti-muons, etc). Therefore a uniform magnetic field is applied to make the particle tracks curve. By looking at the energy loss in the sensitive (scintillator) layers of the detector the mass and energy can be determined, and the curvature of the track gives the charge, whose sign depends on whether it is a particle or anti-particle. 3) This is a good way for India to approach this problem. I've worked with Indian physicists and they are as good as physicists anywhere. This mine has played a minor role in neutrino physics for many years, and it is the deepest of its kind in the world (SNO was at about 2 km depth, this is over 4). Cosmic ray neutrinos have not been as much studied as they might, and at high energy there is always a change of seeing something odd or unexpected. The technological challenges, while formidable, are likely surmountable and the odds of getting some good physics out of the system are high.
- ChuckMcM 12y agoWow that is a lot of centrifuges, err I mean magnets! I'm disappointed that Popular Mechanics didn't go into the theory, this is better http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/India-based_Neutrino_Observatory http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/India-based_Neutrino_Observator... but still not great.
- la6470 12y agoWhenever someone posts a news about India .. like say "India says they will give a dollar to everyone in the world" or some other crap .. why do Indians become a punching bag and a majority of Americans starts attacking them in any forum? Is it because Indians are in average not as good looking as other races or because Indians think they are little bit superior in intelligence than other races? Really I wonder... because at the end of the day Americans who have really tried to understand India becomes friends for ever.
- diy123 12y agoHello HN'ers, I am a long-timer lurker on HN, don't post anything, don't have Karma. But I do want to respond to the comment by quonn below, which is an example of a broader type of comment for these kinds of news: some _developing_country_ invests in _scientific_project_. People say, why are you wasting money on this when you should be feeding your people? To that I say, countries should be feeding their people, as well as investing in science. As an individual, you are constrained by money because you can't print it. To a country, money does literally grow on trees, and a country can print as much money as it wants. What should a country do to remove poverty? Invest in projects that create jobs - massive infrastructure projects come to mind here. But also invest in cutting edge science and build a scientific infrastructure. A country should, to create new knowledge, attempt that which others have not attempted. Kennedy's Man on the Moon speech is very much in this spirit. Eventually scientific progress made anywhere benefits all humanity. So I cheer India (or any other country) in such efforts.
- quonn 12y agoThere is nothing wrong with investing in science per se. But there is a choice how to spend your money within science. If you are already a rich country, sure go ahead, burn money on CERN or whatever it is. It probably won't provide a tangible benefit for your people, but it is worth it for everyone in the long run. Nobody disputes that. But this depends on the economic reality in your country. Most people who responded to my comment basically ignored that reality. It's about priorities.
- chimeracoder 12y agoHow rich does a country have to be, then, in order to be able to "burn money on CERN"? What is the "acceptable threshold" of poverty, healthcare coverage, civil liberties, and so forth at which a country can decide to divert money towards investing in science instead of solving these problems? It's analogous to this XCKD, except with money instead of time: https://xkcd.com/1232/ https://xkcd.com/1232/
- ta75757 12y agoa country can print as much money as it wants Printing money is essentially a tax, because it reduces the value of the currency everyone else is holding through inflation. Or another way: money is not physical resources, it is a measure of resources. How could printing money increase the physical resources available to a country?
- forgotAgain 12y agoIsn't the earth's core the world's largest magnet? [Edit: to the downvoters: it's the weekend, have a sense of humor.]
- miduil 12y agoYou are the second on hn in under a week who gets down votes for that ;) (I still wonder how to down vote here). https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8875820 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8875820
- HCIdivision17 12y agoGosh, take the idea seriously for a second: think of the accomplishment of putting a detector down there! We're a few generations out from even hoping to have the material science needed for it, but maintaining a comm link with a thing through the mantle is strangely uncommon science fiction. Like it's too wild an idea to ever take seriously. Unlike, say, warp drives and indefinite longevity.