3 ms·
Computer Crime laws are already insanely disproportionate. They were created during a moral panic when only a few individuals, large multinationals and, large
by Someone1234 12y ago
Computer Crime laws are already insanely disproportionate.
They were created during a moral panic when only a few individuals, large multinationals and, large governments had computers and the government were worried that "hackers" could break into the electricity grid or the communications system and shut it down.
So right now you could literally break into someone's home, knock them unconscious, and then steal their laptop, but yet still get more jail time for "hacking" into their laptop than any of the previous crimes.
It only gets more insane when someone "hacks" across state lines. The federal laws are absolutely insane, and the only thing more disproportionate are some of the drug laws (many of which were also created during times of moral panic).
In particular are comic cases of when companies fail to secure things at all (e.g. leave data exposed to the public via hidden URLs) and then someone gets prosecuted because they "hacked" that company and "stole" that data.
- disposition2 12y ago> In particular are comic cases of when companies fail to secure things at all (e.g. leave data exposed to the public via hidden URLs) and then someone gets prosecuted because they "hacked" that company and "stole" that data. Which is my main concern with all the attention and push for change (or rather more laws and less privacy) in relation to the Sony hack (among others). Would Congress and the media be calling for equitable action if someone had physically broken in to the Sony Films offices and stolen the data, due to lax (physical) security policies? Doubtful, they'd probably be told to buy better locks...
- snowwrestler 12y ago> So right now you could literally break into someone's home, knock them unconscious, and then steal their laptop, but yet still get more jail time for "hacking" into their laptop than any of the previous crimes. Can you provide some examples? And not sentencing guidelines or what the prosecutors asked for; actual sentence lengths that were actually served by people convicted solely of computer crimes vs. time served for breaking and entering and assault and battery and theft.
- alistairSH 12y ago>In particular are comic cases of when companies fail to secure things at all and then someone gets prosecuted because they "hacked" that company and "stole" that data. <devil's advocate>If I leave my garage open, and somebody takes my golf clubs, is that not theft? Yes, the potential punishments are disproportionately harsh. Yes, the company is silly for leaving data exposed. No, it's not ok to take data because it's unprotected.
- click170 12y agoWhat about when you leave your garage door open, and someone comes in and makes a copy of your clubs. You still have yours. They now have a copy too. What did you lose in this other than the idea of "potential income"?
- rayiner 12y agoWhat if you leave your door unlocked, someone walks into your bedroom, and looks at the sex photos you and your wife took. Or rifles through your personal letters, bank statements, etc. Still okay just because they took a copy?
- Kalium 12y agoIt's not theft.
- Retra 12y agoYou lost your privacy.
- cortesoft 12y agoYes, stealing something is a crime whether the item is locked or not. However, cases like that of the Weev guy (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Weev http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Weev) are very different than someone coming into an unlocked garage and stealing your stuff. His case is more like a going into a store that is open and invites you in (this was a public website he went to). You are browsing around, looking at stuff for sale.. you then see an unmarked door in the middle of the store. It isn't locked, and doesn't say "Employees Only", so you walk in. The store can't then turn around and have criminal charges brought against you just because you weren't supposed to go into the door. There were no locks or signs, and you were in a place you were supposed to be. Now, if there was any sort of lock at all (even a crappy, broken, one that was easy to bypass) you could argue that it is a crime. If I send a standard request to a website, with no special forged auth or anything, and that website gives me back data, you can't blame the person who made the request. It is up to the website to tell me "no, you are not allowed to access that."