4 ms·
This one's already in the running for the most hedged and meaningless article of the year. > If Bitcoin were a currency, it'd be the worst-performing one in th
by baddox 12y ago
This one's already in the running for the most hedged and meaningless article of the year.
> If Bitcoin were a currency, it'd be the worst-performing one in the world, worse even than the Russian ruble.
> But Bitcoin isn't a currency.
Okay, it starts off with an admitted paradox of entailment. If 2 + 2 = 5, then Bitcoin is a Ponzi scheme for redistributing wealth. And besides all that, there are plenty of time periods over which Bitcoin would be the best-performing currency in the world.
> It's a Ponzi scheme for redistributing wealth from one libertarian to another. At least that's all it is right now. One day it could be more. Venture capitalists, for their part, are quick to point out that it's really a protocol, like the early internet, and its underlying technology could still be revolutionary. What are they supposed to say, though, when they've bet hundreds of millions of dollars on it?
This is a hedge that reveals the inane clickbait nature of the headline. The author isn't talking about Bitcoin, but rather about some group of people and firms involved with Bitcoin is some way. We could say "economics is a Ponzi scheme for redistributing wealth," because lots of people have utilized economics to implement Ponzi schemes.
> It has no inherent value, after all, because, despite companies trying to get free PR by saying they'll accept it, almost nobody uses it to buy anything other than drugs.
To make the claim falsifiable, the author would need to define "almost nobody." To make the claim accurate, that definition would need to be preposterous.
> Bitcoin miners, you see, borrowed money—and real money, as in dollars—that they could only pay back if Bitcoin prices kept rising, or at least didn't fall this much.
Bitcoin is not the first currency or technology around which foolish investments have been made.
> This means we don't need a bank to know that I've sent money to you and only you, but it comes at the cost of making it irreversible.
The irreversibility is likely a cost to some and a benefit to others. Since no one that I'm aware of has been forced to use Bitcoin, I don't see this as a problem. If you consider the irreversibility of a bitcoin transaction to be a significant cost, then do not make the bitcoin transaction.