12 ms·
> I'm not saying he can do no wrong, but I'm just flabbergasted that there are still so many armchair critics and naysayers when it comes to Elon Musk. That's
by Someone1234 12y ago
> I'm not saying he can do no wrong, but I'm just flabbergasted that there are still so many armchair critics and naysayers when it comes to Elon Musk.
That's why you're a fanboy. Nobody is perfect, and Elon Musk likes to make fun of the competition quite publicly when they have an issue, while ignoring his project's own failures.
It is hard to even discuss the man on HN as anything that could even be taken as critical gets downmoded or flagged. Just look at yesterday's hyperloop discussions, nobody could say anything critical without being very actively attacked. By the way make sure "show dead" is turned on to see the full discussion.
Honestly his track record is very impressive indeed. His aspirations are also impressive. However his fans are insufferable as is HN's general attitude about the man. When someone is treated as if they're beyond reproach and their ideas are also, you're just asking to get led down the garden path.
The hyperhoop concept in particular is pretty bad, and the white paper leaves more questions than it does answers. The cost is too high and the value too low Vs. normal high speed trains (e.g. Japan). Plus there are massive safety issues surrounding it (as you can see from the thread yesterday, that were largely just ignored and downmodded).
Overall I'll be happy when people start acting rationally around the guy again. Currently I feel like I at a One Direction concert surrounding by a bunch of screaming teenage girls (on HN in particular).
PS - I wouldn't dream of criticising this rocket failure. Rockets are hard, the last 80 years have proven that again and again.
- krallja 12y agoDefine your acronyms, please: HK
- transburgh 12y agoI think he meant HN (Hacker News)
- Someone1234 12y agoI did. I updated to HN, since HK could be confused with e.g. Hong Kong and I have no idea how popular Elon Musk is in Hong Kong. :)
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- iamcreasy 12y agoWell, Elon Musk said talking about hyperloop was like shooting his own foot. It was a premature idea. But the interesting part is some(more than some) people are actually trying trying to come up with a real world implementations of hyperloop and so far their verdict is 'it's doable' and they are working on it. And these people are engineers from reputed companies around the world. I don't particularly like the concept of fan boy either, but like you said, this man has impressive track records. And that's absolutely brilliant. The thing that intrigues me is in the new innovations he had in his rocket, and why NASA didn't have it before SpaceX.
- sillysaurus3 12y ago"Premature idea" is probably better phrased as "not feasible on technical grounds." Even tlb said it has huge problems. The steel expands in summer due to heat. Where does it go? Roads can expand using those interlocking teeth things, but hyperloop has to remain a closed system. Oh well. Everyone should dream once in awhile. EDIT: So... is this incorrect?
- iamcreasy 12y ago"Imagination is more important than knowledge." - Albert Einstein
- iamcreasy 12y agoDespite down votes, I still strongly believe the idea outweighs the blame for not thoroughly answering all technical questions. And as others have already pointed out that the technical problem isn't as big as it sounds. Also Elon Musk has announced to build a 5 mile test hyperloop track in Texas yesterday.
- forkandwait 12y agoHow about hedging your statement to "not CURRENTLY feasible using TODAY'S materials and structural concepts (trusses, etc)". Space flight and industrial production of fertilizer were both considered impossibilities when first proposed.
- moogleii 12y agoWell, it is easy. You just say it is, while your army of engineers slaves away in the background 6 days a week to prove you right. Tada! Pharaoh: "Pyramids? Pffft, easy."
- ForHackernews 12y agoAmen. It's also kind of insulting how much HN has bought into this "Great Man" theory of engineering and development. Sure, Elon Musk is a smart guy and seems to be a good leader who sets bold goals, but the real geniuses that make SpaceX possible are the brilliant engineers working there--who you've never heard of. Watching the way HN reacts to SpaceX, in contrast to say, NASA, or the ESA makes me think those organizations should hire a charismatic frontman, too. Edit: For example, see my sibling comment: "The thing that intrigues me is in the new innovations he had in his rocket, and why NASA didn't have it before SpaceX." (emphasis mine)
- paulwal 12y agoYou described every organization or company ever. Jobs didn't personally write the code for iOS but he created the vision and made it happen.
- ForHackernews 12y agoYeah, and I also think there's way too much Jobs-worship in the technology industry.
- scrollaway 12y ago> Watching the way HN reacts to SpaceX, in contrast to say, NASA, or the ESA makes me think those organizations should hire a charismatic frontman, too. Well, yes, I think they should. People are drawing the completely wrong lessons from Jobs/Apple. "There's too much worship!" well, duh. Jobs inspired people, and that inspiration led to extremely dedicated fans. Jobs made use of that in the tech sector, but where we really need it is in sectors which are highly affected by the good will of humans. Charity. Science. Care of the planet. The development of the human race. Very-long-term thinking. All these need charismatic frontmen, people who inspire others to think about their own future and the future of others.
- ceejayoz 12y ago> Watching the way HN reacts to SpaceX, in contrast to say, NASA, or the ESA makes me think those organizations should hire a charismatic frontman, too. Absolutely, yes. Hell, look at what Chris Hadfield did for the CSA.
- leo_mck 12y agoI am not familiar with the hyperloop concept so maybe I am wrong but I never understood the "cost is too high" argument. Is this not almost always the case on every technology breakthrough? Things like gene mapping and 3D printing comes to mind - someone had to started doing it at prohibitive costs so we can evolve the tech and get the prices down.
- Someone1234 12y ago> Is this not almost always the case on every technology breakthrough? In the case of the hyperloop the technology isn't too bad. We can likely build it without developing too much. Most of the technological problems are already largely solved in aircraft design. In this case it is more a "this cost literally too many resources" problem. High speed rail is fairly simple, you clear land (expensive), flatten it, even it out, and then lay metal tracks with wooden/concrete sleepers. With the hyperloop you're literally building a tunnel that has to withstand weather including extremes, withstand negative pressure internally without crushing, transfer the weight/internal/external forces down to pillars, and yet still you're left with the "clear land" problem as nobody wants to live under a hyperloop track, or have it blocking their natural sunlight. Hyperloop might see some savings as it requires less land than high speed rail, but you'll easily offset that by physically how many resources go into the tunnel and pillars (and raising the tunnels into position and sealing them). If all hyperloop was was a tunnel in the sky it might be easier to imagine the financials making sense. But then you add negative pressures within, and you're talking about aircraft skin the entire length of the thing, and then dealing with attaching these pieces of loop together on-site (so presumably double-riveting them like aircraft skins are, which is time consuming/expensive).
- kevin_thibedeau 12y agoIt would seem that the hyperloop is just an invented charade developed for use as a carrot to manipulate states into dropping their laws against direct sales from car manufacturers. That would explain why Texas is being courted now. They lost out on the gigafactory and may be more willing to capitulate to get a piece of other Musk projects.
- mrprint 12y agoit's not only hyperloop, "Musk said Texas could be a contender for future Tesla car or battery factories." And I am sure he will build them there as he needs plenty of them in order to produce millions of cars "by 2025"
- hawkice 12y ago> Elon Musk likes to make fun of the competition quite publicly when they have an issue, while ignoring his project's own failures. This seems pretty harsh. It's not like he went home, curled up in a blanket with a hot cocoa and told the engineers to figure it out by the time he came back to the office.
- SEJeff 12y agoNot sure what you're saying reflects reality. When Orbital Science's rocket recently exploded, Elon's words were nothing but polite: https://twitter.com/elonmusk/status/527247155954610176 https://twitter.com/elonmusk/status/527247155954610176 And his comment on their rocket being the butt of a joke, using engines literally made in the 1960s and stored in Siberia were true. It is upsetting, but still not as surprising that they suffered catastrophic failure having such an adversion to new tech.
- gamegoblin 12y agoOne example of his being polite doesn't mean he doesn't also make fun of competition publicly. Look at the interview where the interviewer asks him about a competitor's electric car (BMW I think) and he just laughs for a not-insignificant amount of time followed by something like "have you seen the thing?"
- Redoubts 12y agoHave you seen it, though? It's an appropriate response for most.
- SEJeff 12y agoHis theatrics aside, he wants to make electric cars viable and take us to mars. Even if he ultimately fails, if he makes everyone else rise up to compete with him, we as humanity win.
- threeseed 12y agoTesla didn't start the electric car resurgence nor is it likely to take us to Mars. The way I see it Elon is rising up to those around him not the other way around.
- dredmorbius 12y agoElon is rising up to those around him Sometimes -- and I'd argue often -- leadership consists more of both 1) getting out of the way of and 2) enabling those who Want To Get Shit Done. I find the fanboiism somewhat tedious (I don't find the top comment of this thread all that insightful), but I do admire Musk for seeming to hit a number of remarkable goals. That said, I find Tesla and Solar City more impressive/promising than SpaceX (technical challenges and accomplishments notwithstanding) or the Hyperloop (ultimately an idea that's been rightfully junked in the past). Given the history of US industry of doing just the opposite -- stalling and preventing needed innovation -- if I had to pick a single attribute of his that I find most encouraging it's his leadership in that regard.
- threeseed 12y agoI couldn't agree more. The circlejerk over Elon and his companies is so frustrating. It's actually impossible to have a reasonable debate over one of the world's most issues i.e. electric versus hydrogen cars without there being people downvoted into oblivion.
- seanflyon 12y agoCould you give an example of a constructive comment that was killed? While certainly there is a lot of optimism around what Elon is trying to do, I don't think that "I feel like I at a One Direction concert surrounding by a bunch of screaming teenage girls" is a reasonable reaction.
- dlwj 12y agoImagine you need to cross a tightrope to do something amazing and everyone is afraid of heights. Some forms of criticism are useful but yelling out "Hey, it's 2300 meters to the bottom, be careful!" is not very useful. People often know the negatives, it's just easier to do the task when you don't look down. Often this requires self delusion. Otherwise "Don't look down, or think of white polar bears" would work for everyone.