4 ms·
Why College Shouldn't Take Four Years
- yummyfajitas 17y agoThe first thing we should do before reforming college is to decide what our goals are. Then we should figure out how to achieve them. Unfortunately, most stated reasons for college/education in general serve as justification for the existing system.
- tokenadult 17y agomost stated reasons for college/education in general serve as justification for the existing system. That sounds right to me. What would you suggest as reasonable goals for after-high-school schooling that would make for a better system?
- cschneid 17y agoI agree with the grandparent post. We need to define why college exists in the modern system. In the more distant past, it was purely academic. Research, experimentation, etc. Somewhere in the last century the goal of schools shifted to be an unfocused trade school. "Learn to write well, every job needs that!". I'm not opposed to either approach, and believe that both need to exist in the world. But the idea of a 4 year college falls awkwardly in between those two ideas. I think the reason we are in this situation is because we confused cause and effect. Back when college was a much more limited institution, the smartest and best connected went to school. They then got the best jobs, and earned more money. People saw that and said "Aha! College leads to better jobs". What they missed was the "Aha! Smart people get the best jobs!". So the push to get everybody into college started, since it would guarantee the student's financial future. That of course hasn't been sustainable, and it has ruined the bachelor's degree as a useful resume signal that you are part of that top tier of people. We need to reevaluate how important exclusivity is to universities, reevaluate how kids can be trained for high end jobs (can you do a trade school for computer programming?). It may be as simple as a marketing campaign saying that plumbers and mechanics can't be outsourced and make a ton of money.
- seanc 17y agoJane Jacobs has brilliant essay on this topic; the difference between educating and providing credentials. Dark Age Ahead, ISBN-10: 0679313109
- yardie 17y agoIt was also pushed along by the Vietnam war. Kids didn't want to be drafted, and a lot of teachers didn't want to see their brightest as gun fodder. The only way to get around the draft was to get into college. Thus began that sneaky grade inflation problem that all highschools and colleges swear doesn't exist.
- wallflower 17y agoMy law school friends bemoaned the fact that it is literally impossible to finish law school in anything less than 3 years because the governing board makes it unfeasible (basically milking the future lawyers for an extra year of tuition (talk about ethics), ridiculous class scheduling)
- tokenadult 17y agoUndergraduate major sequences can work that way too. Depending on how frequently classes are offered, and with what other conflicts with other classes, it can be impossible to complete a major sequence in less than four years from college entry even for a student who has advanced courses in the major and a year or more of AP credit upon college entrance. Some colleges make that four-year experience worthwhile, but at other colleges that is mostly marking time.
- Torn 17y agoWorld University rankings for 2008 - http://www.topuniversities.com/university-rankings/world-university-rankings/2009/results http://www.topuniversities.com/university-rankings/world-uni... Seems the US does indeed have a lot of the top-ranking universities up there
- edw519 17y agoCollege doesn't take four years now. I finished in 3. AP credit from high school, 2 summer sessions, and a few extra courses was all it took. Anyone ambitious enough can do it. The first thing to do is stop thinking like the crowd. Default thinking is for most people, but not everyone. I suspect most people here already know that.
- tokenadult 17y agoWhat was your major? Can any entering freshman with no previous courses in the major department finish in three years? (That was barely possible for my major at my alma mater, back in the 1970s.) Were you working to pay your bills while going to college? That makes a difference for a lot of students too. Props to you for doing something besides the default.
- steveplace 17y agoIt depends if you're willing to take classes over the summer as well, it's certainly possible.
- tokenadult 17y agoWillingness to take classes during the summer can be constrained by the necessity of working for expenses during the summer.
- scott_s 17y agoAlso by what classes are offered during the summer. In the computer science departments I've been in, junior and senior level classes aren't offered during the summer.
- deleted 17y ago[deleted]
- jacquesm 17y ago
- ax0n 17y agoI got hired away from college and in some ways I still kind of regret not finishing. I'm glad that in my career, you don't really need a degree to succeed. A lot of my peers are degree-less, but having at least a Bachelor's does seem to give people an edge in the hiring process. For that, I usually blame HR. I did complete 4 years of high school in 3 years, though, by hitting college classes at night for high school credit, taking one or two credit classes through the school district each summer and by limiting the number of non-credit or decreased-credit school-day options such as study hall or teacher aide. I do wish that it was as easy to buck the college system. Usually, though, pre-reqs are structured so you have to push though no fewer than eight semesters in order to accomplish everything to get your Bachelor's.
- sketerpot 17y agoI've found that you can often skip prerequisites if you just don't tell anybody you didn't take the required classes. If I had done things properly, I wouldn't have been able to take most of the classes I really enjoyed.
- elai 17y agoMaybe way back when they didn't really use computer systems to track classes. Now if you don't have the prereqs in the computer system, the computer wont let your register, therefore the teacher wont have you on your class list and you wont be able to get a grade on your transcript.
- sketerpot 17y agoI just graduated from college a few months ago. The prerequisite system is so full of special cases, and so riddled with verbiage like "or equivalent classes, or permission of the instructor", that they didn't even bother to track prereqs by computer. (Also, I spent a semester in another country, and the records didn't transfer. Essentially, that semester was a black box in which I could plausibly be assumed to have taken any class. Maybe that helped.) I'm surprised that other schools track prereqs by computer. That sounds like it would be very rigid and high-maintenance.
- steveplace 17y agoIt probably shouldn't, however colleges have a monetary incentive to extend your duration as a student.
- harry 17y agoAs I work at a good sized institution I gotta disagree. The effect I actually see is that students who spend more time at our university take up disproportional resources and end up costing the university money - Since students who take >4 years typically fill up required courses then drop out - the courses aren't filled efficiently. There are many other reasons as well for a University to want "graduate in 4", but that's the first ones to come to mind. It's a major program here and the administration has been researching and passing new tuition policies. You can read a report done by the Office of Institutional Research and Planning here at KU: http://www2.ku.edu/~oirp/GIF/GIF_TaskForceReport_090205.pdf http://www2.ku.edu/~oirp/GIF/GIF_TaskForceReport_090205.pdf
- steveplace 17y agoI'll take your data over my anecdotes anytime ;)
- HistoryInAction 17y agoI think the most amazing thing about this article is that it was written (or at least bylined) by a sitting senator. I don't agree with many of Sen. Alexander's political positions generally, but wow! That's a policy paper right there and a rare thing for a politician to do, generally. Basically, this piece seems intended to 'pull' the average student back towards a four-year average by giving them opportunities to graduate early. However, I feel it doesn't actually incentivize them to graduate unless they're already driven to do so. @yummyfajitas, tokenadult, It would definitely be interesting to graduate in three years, but I think the better option is to regear the fourth year as a transition year, with few classes and geared towards internships, externships, coops, and on-campus research. It should propel you to grad school, your vocation, or even give you a chance to meet co-founders and enter startupdom.
- jbellis 17y ago> I think the most amazing thing about this article is that it was written (or at least bylined) by a sitting senator. I did a double-take when I saw then name, then skipped to the end to see the byline. Yes, it's the same one. (Didn't know he used to be president of the University of Tennessee, either.)
- yummyfajitas 17y agoInstead of graduating in 3 years and getting work experience in the 4'th year, students should stay in school and get work experience (*ternship, coop, research) in the 4'th year? Apart from being an opportunity for the college to take an "internship fee", "computer fee", "student activities fee", "PIRG fee", etc, what purpose does this serve that 3 year graduation would not?
- fpgeek 17y agoIt gives the student an opportunity to get a taste of the working world before making their first major professional decision. That, to me, is worthwhile.
- yummyfajitas 17y ago
- pegobry 17y agoCollege shouldn't take four years, but it shouldn't take three years either. Everyone works differently, and everyone has a different rythm. Some people know what they want to do for the rest of their lives at 13, some don't know into their twenties. Everyone should be able to adapt their college experience to their own needs and wants.
- yummyfajitas 17y agoSome people know what they want to do for the rest of their lives at 13, some don't know into their twenties. In general, when considering a big ticket (e.g. $100,000) purchase, I usually wait until I know what I want to buy before writing a check. Maybe these twenty-somethings should do the same.
- allenp 17y agoI think there is too much pressure for a lot of high school graduates to immediately attend college for this to be feasible. A lot of people spending $100k+ on tuition probably spent at least half that on their high school tuition, so the whole "oh just wait until you're ready" thing doesn't really hold water for the parents that are paying the bills. The real problem, I think, for these students is not in their inability to choose a major (since the large majority of them choose something), but in their lack of experience to provide them a basis for understanding what they are really interested in combined with external pressures regarding what are acceptable fields to pursue.
- dustingetz 17y agogoing to college isn't the same as buying a porsche. There's a cultural standard to go to college immediately after high school, and breaking it has severe career consequences. Its also a wicked problem -- you need to probe and iterate to find the answer.
- sellis 17y agoShouldn't your major play a factor in how many years it takes?
- larsberg 17y agoI've always thought that even after four years, that really is just barely enough time to get decent awareness around developing software. Assuming you were a CS major the whole time. The only thing worse than being bad at what you do is being bad at it and not knowing it.
- dustingetz 17y agothe decent programmers I've worked with all have a passion for software and learned it informally. Uni is notoriously bad at training software engineers.
- liuliu 17y agoI think that most decent programmers start to program before college and the rest of them are really talented at this.
- Alex3917 17y agoI think the best way to improve college would be to ban the practice of granting degrees altogether.
- dustingetz 17y agoYou guys talk about undergrad like you're there for the education. Hackers, moreso than 'normal' people, need college to develop social skills and other soft subjects. Grad school is for real learning.
- asciilifeform 17y agoYes, let's bleed an extra cube-farm year out of every serf.
- zck 17y agoOne of the downsides of taking less time to graduate is requiring earlier decisions. Many students don't graduate with their major unchanged from what they thought it at the time they matriculated. Personally, by the time my freshman year was over, I had taken only three courses total in what would become my two majors (math and computer science), and one didn't count (C.S. for non-majors). I had no idea what I wanted to major in when I went to college. I needed that time to decide. Of course, moving one year of college into summers would make for the same amount of work each semester, but temporally compressed, at the cost of removing all your intra-college summers. No summer internships, no summer jobs. That means you can't go work for google; you can't work for Fog Creek. You can get an internship during school, but that won't be full-time; just a day or two a week. For many students, they'll be away from their families for most of those three years, which would consist of nearly-constant work.
- deleted 17y ago[deleted]
- yardie 17y agoIt doesn't have to be this way. I've looked at the French university system and it makes sense. Unfortunately, with the Barcelona agreement, they are switching from the pretty decent system they have to the anglo-saxon model. If you are unfamiliar you are given a license? for each year you complete. So you would receive Bac+1, Bac+2, and a Bac+3 is the equivalent of bachelors. Employers specify how much time and which degrees they are looking for when you apply for work. I've seen some only require a Bac+1 and a few want a Bac+3. This is completely unlike the US model where if you are 1 or 2 semesters away from receiving a degree (I'm sure some of you have a few friends like this) you are only a highschool graduate no matter how much time you've invested at the university. Also, I'm a 6-year grad, 1 was working, 1 was cooping, 4 were actual university time. My final year was a straight year (May-May) of school. It was hard, physically, because during the summers my school tried to cram an entire semester (4 months) into 4 weeks. While this looked doable on paper you end up chewing through a lot of material, disregarding it, and then repeat the following week. I remember nothing from my summer courses. If your schedule didn't mesh perfectly with the courses then you might have to wait a year until a required course becomes available again. I pushed, shoved and begged my way into every class my final year. Because I wasn't an athlete or honor student I had to wait for enrollment. This wasn't my timeline, just the realities of the university system. Knowing that I would be kicking around campus until spring made me desperate. Universities have been kicking around the 3 year degree for years and decades. Until they, fundamentally, change how courses are distributed, how schedules are dictated this thing doesn't have a snowballs chance in hell of gaining any traction. I've heard the same thing for years, 3 years means less pressure on classes, less cost, and the continuous use (no breaks) of knowledge. But the reality is whether you do it during the fall or the spring, the costs are still the same. Comparatively, it's more expensive since summer courses usually max out at 12 credit hours while a normal semester can go to 18 at the same price. Fewer courses are offered, during the summer and the ones that are available are generally freshman, sophomore courses. If you are an upperclassman there is very little for you except a few uni requirements. College shouldn't take 3 or 4 years. It should be a continuous thing with clearly defined goals. That way someone shouldn't have to be on the line for a 4 year degree. If they happen to find a job that only needs 2 or 3, instead of the nebulouse "some college", then they should feel confident in applying because the employer can gauge their level of education fairly.
- seanc 17y agoThe CEGEP system in Quebec is quite good. 3 years High School , 2 years CEGEP (sort of like community college), and then 3 years university for a bachelors. Foreign students like I was do a year 0 (they really call it that, at least at McGill) at a university, and then meet the Quebec students in our major the next year. So like the French system, there are more chances to get off the train and have a useful credential, plus many students do the freshman year close to home for less money.
- HistoryInAction 17y agoA basic round up of webtalk about this subject: http://www.theatlanticwire.com/opinions/view/opinion/Pros-and-Cons-of-Blitzing-Through-College-1333 http://www.theatlanticwire.com/opinions/view/opinion/Pros-an...
- Daniel_Newby 17y agoAs usual, they are trying to fix government meddling with austerity measures. As usual, it will not work. "Meanwhile, tuition has soared, leaving graduating students with unprecedented loan debt." Because the government subsidized interest rates and abolished underwriting standards. The latter was done by making it impossible to write off student loan debt in bankruptcy, meaning lenders could give a student loan to anyone with a pulse and still write it down as an asset on their books. Higher education is just another part of the monetary bubble. "Because of the recession, Harvard is laying off workers and Stanford is selling a billion dollars of its endowment." No, that's because their money managers stashed the grocery money in derivatives, turning a liquidity crunch into an insolvency crisis. (And thus answering the question of whether the MBA and quant muppets were trained to be thieves or trained to be idiots.)
- valeriekcats 17y agoI'm 57+ and it has taken me since 1999 to get my AA and I still have to make it another 2+ years to get my BA. I work to make ends meet I support a disabled mother, husband and grandson...........I want my Masters and I'll take the time it takes to get it. Psychology is not a simple study and these morons want us to do our degrees in 3 years with 40 units per year........I still take 24 and I still don't get a full night sleep........be real PLEASE!