9 ms·
Apple, Your Developer Agreement Tramples on Free Speech and Innovation
- Fogh 12y agoApple is a private company, so stop trying to decide what they should or shouldn't do.
- caio1982 12y agoAre you implying consumers should not have their voices somehow heard (no matter how stupid their requests are) by private companies? I think your comment underestimate the power of consumers and customers of products -- and ultimately of boycotts. If this petition had been signed by 1.5 millions instead of just 1.5 thousand I wonder if you would consider it more... valued? Let them speak out if that is what they want.
- kristiandupont 12y agoForgive me, but what a stupid petition, presenting what is basically a consumer preference as a political claim! In my humble opinion, this does nothing but water down the potential significance of real petitions.
- poolpool 12y agoThis is insulting to everyone who fights for actual free speech rights. Another clickbait from eff.
- WhitneyLand 12y agoOk I up voted, but couldn't some of these points be made stronger? For example the security updates, what exactly is being proposed, that patches should be able to go into the App Store without review and Apple's static analysis checks? Or are they just saying there should be a checkbox during submission for "Security related, please expedite"?
- josephlord 12y agoThere is an email address where you can request an expedited review. I'm sure they would accept for security issues (assuming you only make occasional requests).
- k-mcgrady 12y agoThey do. Any major bug or security fix will get through with expedited review in less than 24 hours.
- mnem 12y agoExpedited requests generally get serviced pretty quickly, from experience. Within 8 hours both times I've had to request one.
- ctdonath 12y agoI've had an expedited fix go thru in 2 hours flat.
- matthewmacleod 12y agoHonestly, the DRM and security update aspects are probably acceptable restrictions – in that we know what Apple's policies are, and these are unreasonable in that context. If course, not being permitted to talk about the product or agreement is stupid.
- Mikeb85 12y agoIf people don't like Apple's terms, don't develop for them. Personally, I vote with my feet (ie. I currently own nothing Apple, the way they're going, probably never will again).
- dublinben 12y ago>If people don't like Apple's terms, don't develop for them. This has been the EFF's exact response, and this community has lambasted them for it. We are told that organizations like the EFF and developers of security/privacy software should compromise on their ideals and not forsake deserving users on iOS. This is a classic Catch-22, because providing beneficial software (Chatsecure, Firefox, etc.) to these users just perpetuates their abusive relationship with Apple.
- tedunangst 12y agoAre people lambasting them for not developing for Apple? Or are people lambasting them for all the accompanying crocodile tears?
- fpgeek 12y agoThe tears may have been predictable (and maybe even planned), but they most certainly aren't crocodile tears. These are issues the EFF and its membership deeply and sincerely care about. The whole point of the organization is to call attention to these issues and push for change. Complaining that they're working on their mission is pretty silly.
- Flimm 12y agoOr you can vote with your feet, wallet and mouth.
- NietTim 12y agoWat. How does a stores guidelines and agreements "trample" free speech?! It's their store, their rules. Don't like it? Start writing apps for another platform. A muslim supermarket can chose to not carry non-halal food. Does that Trample on My Free Speech if I were a meat producer?! No. I love this line: > Ban iOS developers from ever speaking about the developer agreement. Yeah. That's called NDA and is very common in contracts. Welcome to the real world, kid.
- ctdonath 12y agoYes, like it or not. Burger King says "Have it your way", it's your burger, but that doesn't mean you can jump the counter, cook the burger to your own exacting specifications, and pay for it in 1-peso coins.
- anon1385 12y agoThe politics of Apple really is quite fascinating. Is there any other company that people feel so passionately about that they are prepared to totally reverse their normal political positions? Mention Apple and you can get a bunch of free market libertarians to come out and demand strong consumer rights regulation, purely because they hate Apple so much. Conversely you can get a bunch of socialists sticking up for the right of a multibillion dollar mega-corp to use DRM, censor all competitors from their platform and sell products containing materials extracted through slave and child labour, purely because they like Apple products more than the alternatives.
- coldcode 12y ago"sell products containing materials extracted through slave and child labour" has no basis in fact; besides every phone manufacturer builds their devices in the same factories. At least Apple and a few others make attempts to verify conditions publically. Not everyone even tries.
- anon1385 12y agoHeh, you are kind of making my point for me here. Buying the rare elements needed to build a modern phone is just about impossible to do without sourcing things from the Democratic Republic of the Congo or other places where child and slave labour is likely to be involved.[1][2] The fact that all the other phone manufacturers are just as bad is a convenient line to use in 'winning' an online platform war argument, but it's not a good moral argument. [1] http://www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2013/mar/11/search-smartphone-soaked-blood http://www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2013/mar/11/search-... [2] http://www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2013/apr/25/smartphone-samsung-tin-bangka-island http://www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2013/apr/25/smartph...
- m_eiman 12y agoWell, at least they're trying: http://phys.org/news/2014-02-apple-conflict-metal-chain.html http://phys.org/news/2014-02-apple-conflict-metal-chain.html
- 12y ago
- coldcode 12y agoHaving developed for 5 years on iOS I've never found it a burden. Sure you might wait a few days for approval, but at least generally it keeps the App Store content dependable and trustworthy from a customer standpoint. Like people always say, you don't like the rules, don't play in the sandbox. While the EFF has a lot of good things to say, complaining that Apple should do things against its own rules is not constructive. Android is far more open which makes some people happier but makes their store far less trustworthy (and even less so if you get apps outside their Store). You as a developer always have a choice. I don't think this is a useful point of argument for the EFF.
- stretchwithme 12y agoYour not giving up your rights when you agree not to do one thing in order to do another. You're actually exercising your right to enter into contracts. You have the right to sleep all day. And perhaps you've agreed to not do that while you are collecting an hourly wage. Nobody's violating your right to sleep.
- hobs 12y agoThere are limits to what you can do in a contract for a reason. A hyperbolic example: "I agree to allow you to kill and eat me so you can pay my family thousands of dollars. " However I think that the rights signed away are not beyond the bound of normalcy. This is more of a campaign to change the expectations of the industry as they are all doing this in some form or another. The focus on them is just because they are high profile enough to maybe push the rest of the industry.
- blfr 12y agoApparently, people are generally fine with it. You will routinely hear nowadays that private agreements cannot trample on free speech because that only applies to governments. This argument even made its way to xkcd. http://xkcd.com/1357/ http://xkcd.com/1357/ The other issues are largely trade-offs. How much piracy are you willing to accept? How does it affect sales and availability of software for the platform? How soon should we patch? Right away or on Patch Tuesday? How thoroughly should we test? How much instability are we willing to tolerate? And so on.
- Gracana 12y ago> You will routinely hear nowadays that private agreements cannot trample on free speech That comic is a response to people complaining about "freedom of speech" after their harassing comments have been removed from a forum or article comment thread. I'm not sure the same line of thinking translates so directly to a corporate software development license agreement.
- blfr 12y agoWhat about getting fired. How many e-dramas have we seen lately over someone tweeting and losing their job? That's about as serious as a license agreement for someone doing iOS development as a full-time gig.
- delinka 12y ago"The right to free speech means the government can't arrest you for what you say." It doesn't mean anyone else has to tolerate what you say. It doesn't mean a contract between private parties (i.e. not a contract with a gov't entity) can't dictate the things you may or may not discuss about the parties or the agreement itself. In other words: "free speech" has nothing to do with anything except whether the government can arrest you for running your yap. Which further means a corporate software development license agreement can stipulate anything it wants. And you are free not to accept that agreement and not partake of the benefits the agreement bestows.
- jackweirdy 12y agoAlso, there’s a difference between “Free Speech” as an ideal, and it’s implementation or lack thereof in law (e.g. First Amendment to the Constitution of the US, Article 10 European Convention Human Rights, etc.)
- happyscrappy 12y ago>Developers shouldn't have to give up their rights to make an iPhone app. App makers should demand better terms, and the customers who love their iPhones should back them. If this is what EFF is spending my money on I will never donate to them again. I was with them on the battle to keep jailbreaking legal.
- bpatrianakos 12y ago> Developers shouldn't have to sacrifice their rights to speak and innovate freely just to bring their applications to millions of Apple users. Ummm... Is this really why they develop for iOS or are they just having fun mostly, enjoying their craft and (sometimes) making a small profit on the side. The App Store is but one way to get apps. Sounds like developers with the beliefs the EFF attributes to them would be better suited to developing for Jailbroken phones.
- ctdonath 12y agoThose barriers are erected precisely because the lack thereof was abused enough to warrant them. Take them down, and something worse than those limits will occur. The developer agreement is between the developer and Apple. It's nobody else's business. Jailbreaking tears down walls critical for user-convenient security. Walls, fences, and locking doors are normal in business. Security flaws can be serviced by expedited review, screening for anything else going wrong as well in as little as 2 hours. Normal review is required to ensure nothing traumatic happens. DRM ensures that what users get is what they expected from the developer. Repackaged-with-malware is avoided. I'm disappointed EFF would make such a lame list of complaints, while having locks on their doors.
- hahainternet 12y ago> I'm disappointed EFF would make such a lame list of complaints, while having locks on their doors. What are you talking about. Seriously nothing in your post makes sense.
- ceejayoz 12y agoI was able to make sense of the post. I'd say Apple prioritizes their customers' rights to have a secure, safe, functional device that's reasonably free from concerns over things like malware and other malicious app behaviors. This has some developer downsides, but as both a customer and a developer on Apple products, I'd prefer they prioritize the user experience over development.
- Flimm 12y agoApple is contractually forcing developers to not discuss the contract, in what way is that good for users? Apple can still have a walled garden without contractually requiring developers to forgo their right to jailbreak their own device. DRM does not benefit users at all. It is not necessary to have DRM to have a walled garden.
- sbuk 12y ago
- martingordon 12y agoIs this actually from the EFF or is the EFF Action Center a change.org-style site where anyone can submit petitions? I ask only because the text of the letter isn't particularly well written and contains some glaring mistakes: "Wrap every app in the Apple store with unnecessary DRM" (emphasis mine). Apple isn't the government, and no one is compelled to enter into a contract with them. The EFF's reason for removing their Action Center app from the App Store are outlined in this petition, which is ironic considering the app itself is a web app made native with the Ionic framework[2]. Nothing in Apple's terms prevents the EFF from releasing the app on the web (nor do they have to agree to any of Apple's terms to release a web app). [1]: https://www.eff.org/deeplinks/2014/12/sorry-iphone-users-apples-dev-agreement-means-no-eff-mobile-app-iphone https://www.eff.org/deeplinks/2014/12/sorry-iphone-users-app... [2]: https://github.com/EFForg/actioncenter-mobile https://github.com/EFForg/actioncenter-mobile
- soapdog 12y agoMaybe their app is taping on some Cordova API that is not available for the web. The only platform exposing similar APIs for hosted pages is Firefox OS and even so it doesn't expose sensitive APIs to hosted apps. There is another issue with hosted apps which is the discoverability of such apps. People on iOS tend to believe that things need to be on the App Store...
- nhangen 12y agoYou're right, and it also lacks the professionalism that is found in most EFF campaigns. Our company donates to EFF, so you could say that we support their efforts, but this particular campaign is garbage.
- izacus 12y agoJust because they're not the goverment, it doesn't mean their business values and practices are above reproach, criticism and complaints. Remember, corporations ARE ALLOWED to be criticized for their business practice choices and that's OK. Really.
- mcphage 12y ago
- putzdown 12y agoThis is illogical and amateurish. The title of the petition claims that Apple (1) tramples free speech and (2) innovation. Yet the detailed verbiage of the complaint gives no evidence that they trample free speech, and if their contract terms trample innovation it is a matter of interpretation. Apple's developer agreement bans developers from talking about the developer agreement. A bit draconian, perhaps, but hardly a trampling of "free speech", and actually quite common within contracts generally. The other complaints are simply silly. What's wrong with Apple insisting that developers not jailbreak their devices? What's wrong with Apple approving their own security updates? And we can debate about the morality of DRM, but if you want to see the difference between a DRM-protected environment and an unprotected environment, look at the difference between the App Store and Google Play. Profitability for developers, quality of software, absence of viruses... DRM does accomplish some positive results. And whether it does or doesn't, in no sense are anyone's "rights" quashed here. It's a contract, people. It can say whatever the parties to the contract agree it should say. If you don't agree with it, don't bang free speech drums and shout yourself hoarse about "rights." Just don't sign it.
- davexunit 12y agoThis comment just shows how good Apple is at what they do. They trample upon your freedom to do your computing as you wish and are praised for it. Look at how nice life is in Apple's walled garden! If someone other than Apple controls your computer, someone else could do something bad to it!
- _Simon 12y agoSo don't use Apple kit! Simple, really. But, if you espouse freedom of speech and freedom of choice, you must logically accept that people will want this choice. That's the problem with the OSS Stasi; the choice they mean is their choice or no choice...
- quadrangle 12y agoYou just stepped into an argument between an enormous corporation that imposes extremely long and draconian terms on their closed system they control and others who use pretty mild legal terms to keep their work in the public commons, and you called the loose bunch of community folks "Stasi".
- ekianjo 12y agoDon't develop on/for Apple devices. That's an easy fix.
- DennisP 12y agoI'm a bit surprised by all the people here who think that the best way to object to a corporation's contract offer is to just avoid working with that corporation. If that's all we do, how is the corporation supposed to know what it's doing wrong? Make a public complaint, and (a) you provide better feedback, and (b) you maybe convince other people to join your boycott, which improves your chance of modifying the corporation's behavior and making the world a little bit nicer.
- dsugarman 12y agonot buying their products or working with them is the most effective way to let them know they are doing wrong
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- rockshassa 12y agoI was able to get around this issue by not actually reading the agreement.
- bitwize 12y agoEFF, Your Overweening Moralism Doesn't change The Fact That Developers Target Us First. --Apple
- Tloewald 12y agoI don't see how this first item -- "Ban iOS developers from ever speaking about the developer agreement" -- is true. First, I don't see any such clause; second, you're allowed to discuss anything that's publicly available, and you can read the agreement without signing it as part of the developer program application process, so the agreement is publicly available and thus can be discussed. You're welcome. "Require Apple to approve every security update, which means that unaddressed security bugs could linger and leave users at risk." Yes, the App Store approval process could cause lingering security problems. In practice, Android -- which has no such requirements -- is festooned with malware and iOS is not. So let's protest a hypothetical problem caused by a solution to a real problem. Apple also requires that your code with signed and checksummed before installation. How evil! "Wrap every app in the Apple store with unnecessary DRM, which limits what users can do with their apps even if the code is published as free software." How is it "unnecessary"? It's how the App Store works. It's what allows Apple to remotely disable an app that turns out to be malicious (and which has slipped through the approval process). It's part of the iOS value proposition -- pay us extra to give you a device that won't screw you.
- lern_too_spel 12y ago> I don't see how this first item -- "Ban iOS developers from ever speaking about the developer agreement" -- is true. Section 10.4. It's plain English. "You may not issue any press releases or make any other public statements regarding this Agreement, its terms and conditions, or the relationship of the parties without Apple's express prior written approval, which may be withheld at Apple's discretion." Then you create a cartoonishly bad alternative and use that to justify Apple's policies. The Google Play Store isn't "festooned with malware," and nothing in Apple's review process catches malware. Similarly, every application that runs on Android must be signed, but it doesn't have to be signed by a certificate signed by Apple after paying a yearly developer fee and agreeing to an overbearing contract. The DRM is unnecessary because free software doesn't require it, and malware in the Play Store can be yanked off phones without wrapping apps in DRM, so your claim that it's for malware doesn't hold either. (The agreement doesn't restrict Apple from disabling apps for any other reason, unlike the Play Store agreement, which does. Applications installed by the user outside the Play Store are left alone.)
- dsugarman 12y agoHonest question, if you are interested in freedoms why not develop for Android? You know what you are getting yourself into when you devote your time developing for a closed system and culture like Apple's.
- lvillani 12y agoI'd argue that Firefox OS is an even better proposition if you care about freedom. Android is slowly becoming the shadow of its former self with more and more core functionality (from the point of view of a developer) slowly moving to Google Play Services (which is proprietary).
- _Simon 12y agoWhat, they think that 3000 signatures will make Apple change their terms? 3000 devs that in all likelihood will find another reason to whine? 3000 people that do not under what free speech is? Hey EFF! I want my fucking money back.
- spiralpolitik 12y agoIt's this kind of grandstanding that annoys the heck out of me and makes me want to reconsider donating to the EFF in the future. There are far more important and immediate fish that the EFF should be focusing their limited resources on frying. Once said fish are fried then start taking potshots at Apple's Dev Agreement.