3 ms·
So in layman's terms, would I be right in saying that the defense is effectively saying that the prosecution is taking a "shotgun approach?" In a more obvious c
by zamalek 12y ago
So in layman's terms, would I be right in saying that the defense is effectively saying that the prosecution is taking a "shotgun approach?" In a more obvious claim, they are said to be pulling random people off the street?
If that's the case it's a fascinating defense, I'd love to be able to watch it live.
- andrewfong 12y agoI don't think that's accurate. The defense has only identified one other person investigated by the police, which doesn't make for much of a "shotgun". I think the defense is probably doing one of or both of the following: (1) The defense is trying to impeach the testimony of the aforementioned DHS agent. The unstated implication is that if the agent changes his opinion about the identity of DPR, then his opinions aren't very reliable and shouldn't be taken seriously by the jury. (2) If the underlying reasons for this DHS agent's belief that Karpeles was DPR are still valid, then the defense could use those reasons to show reasonable doubt as to the true identity of DPR. Basically, "if the DHS agent doubted that DPR was Ulbricht, then it's reasonable you doubt that too!"
- zamalek 12y agoRight, all about that "reasonable doubt" thing we always hear about. Still a fascinating case, thanks for the clarification!
- roel_v 12y agoNo, in layman's terms: they're bullshitting in a desperate , last-ditch attempt, because any sane defense has a snowball's chance in hell (even less than this insane Scooby Doo-style 'revelation') and (apparently) the prosecutor didn't agree to any plea bargain (because let's face it, anything less than the 20 years this guy is looking at would be an awesome deal for him). Is there really anyone who seriously thinks this guy is not going to convicted?
- ErrantX 12y agoAbsolutely; this isn't really a defence in so much as it is attempting to nullify the prosecution evidence. They can get away with the argument it's introducing reasonable doubt that Ulbricht is the only candidate for being DPR, whilst the ulterior motive is really to establish the DHS agent as an unreliable witness.
- NoMoreNicksLeft 12y agoAre you asking if I believe he's going to be wrongly convicted, or just convicted?
- roel_v 12y agoYou honestly think he didn't do it? Look, I don't know the guy, and all I have to go on is what I read online, but I would have believed Hans Reiser over this guy.
- NoMoreNicksLeft 12y ago> You honestly think he didn't do it? I honestly haven't heard anything that classifies as evidence. Even if there is real evidence, all I have is hearsay about that evidence. So how the fuck would I know? I bet you have opinions on whether Bill Cosby is really a rapist too, eh?
- roel_v 12y agoWell then why do you post conspiracy theory sounding empty rhetorical questions¿ Edit: dont know about cosby, no indictment or reporting on the evidence eh?
- okbake 12y agoHere is an interesting article posted a few days ago on Motherboard as well: http://motherboard.vice.com/read/cirrus-bitcoin-bucks http://motherboard.vice.com/read/cirrus-bitcoin-bucks It mentions how an undercover agent was able to correlate the the times DPR was logged in to times that Ross Ulbricht was on his laptop in public places immediately prior to his arrest. Its certainly not 100% conclusive or anything but is it corroborating evidence that the prosecution is using to suggest he is guilty. Personally, I'm waiting to make up my mind on the matter of his innocence until the trial brings forward more evidence.