19 ms·
The only way a basic income can avoid being politicized and destroyed is by making it truly unconditional. See various government-run web filters as an example
by nitrogen 12y ago
The only way a basic income can avoid being politicized and destroyed is by making it truly unconditional. See various government-run web filters as an example of the creeping scope expansion every non-unconditional program will encounter. The easiest way to get people to stop fighting over which conditions are the right conditions is to have no conditions.
- Retra 12y agoYou are probably correct, but it would better serve the idea that people are actually being paid for what they are worth -- what responsibilities they are expected to uphold as citizens, rather than this idea that it is just 'free money.' A lot of people like to think that BI is paying people for nothing. It isn't. You still have civil responsibilities, and upholding those responsibilities has real economic value.
- nitrogen 12y agoYou are probably correct, but it would better serve the idea that people are actually being paid for what they are worth... "Worth" just gets to be too sticky of a subject. If I went to either side of my extended family and asked for a list of things that made someone "worthy" of receiving money, I would expect drastically different results. I think if we can't get people to agree on a choice, we have to restructure the problem to remove the need for a choice. Plus, I think we'd be better off if all the "worth" that anyone needed to deserve some dignity was simply being human. A lot of people like to think that BI is paying people for nothing. It isn't. You still have civil responsibilities, and upholding those responsibilities has real economic value. Civic responsibility is important, but as with defining "worth", it seems one would be unlikely to get much agreement on a definition.
- Retra 12y agoNothing I am suggesting requires you to define 'worth' or ask anybody for any opinions on it. People are valuable simply because they are alive. We can pay them to stay that way. If they refuse, we stop paying them. Anything on top of that is just to encourage a responsibility to share their successes.
- eru 12y ago> The only way a basic income can avoid being politicized and destroyed is by making it truly unconditional. Good luck with that. Do you pay citizens, or residents, or perhaps the intersection of them? Do you pay only adults? Or every one who has been born? How dead do you have to be to no longer get the money? (Ie keep your relatives on the machines for longer for money?) Anyway, I agree with your sentiment. But it's not as clear cut in practice. You still have conditions.
- nitrogen 12y agoGood luck with that. Do you pay citizens, or residents, or perhaps the intersection of them? Do you pay only adults? Or every one who has been born? How dead do you have to be to no longer get the money? (Ie keep your relatives on the machines for longer for money?) One would draw whatever line results in the least ambiguity and the lowest enforcement cost. Regarding end-of-life decisions, that's what medical ethics, living wills, and single-payer healthcare are for.