3 ms·
I am not sure I understand the article or the findings or whats it's trying to claim. My oldest son is in a charter school the most hotly debated one of them:
by ThomPete 12y ago
I am not sure I understand the article or the findings or whats it's trying to claim.
My oldest son is in a charter school the most hotly debated one of them: Success Academy. Its biggest problem is not attracting kids but building more schools and making sure they keep getting funding. His school is in Williamsburg and some people come from upper east to attend the school (the kids meet at 7.30)
Furthermore of course distance is always going to be an issue for some but I frankly don't see it in real life as most kids don't get to choose at all.
Maybe there is something I am missing.
- russelluresti 12y agoYeah, the article is a bit weird. It's looking at something VERY specific and not really the broader "are charter schools good?" argument. The idea behind the article is this: people claim that charter schools, known for better academic performance, will cause public schools to increase the quality of their own academics because parents will be able to choose to send their student to the better school. Basically, the idea that increased competition will increase quality across the board. The article says that this may not be the case because academic performance isn't as significant a factor as people might think. Most people will say that, if given the choice between a Grade A school and a Grade C school that they would send their children to the Grade A school. But after looking at the actual decisions made, it appears that many people would be fine with a Grade C school if the Grade A school was 2 miles further away. Or if the Grade C school had a football program and the Grade A school didn't. In other words, if public schools and charter schools are competing, they're not actually competing on academics (since parents aren't using academic performance as a deciding factor). Instead, they're competing on other factors: location, extracurriculars, etc. And if the schools aren't competing on academics, then there's no reason to believe that increased choice will create increased academic performance across the board. At least, that's the point the article is trying to argue.