3 ms·
I object to a job guarantee because I think people's time has value and I don't want it squandered on makework. While I think people can find important dignity
by dllthomas 12y ago
I object to a job guarantee because I think people's time has value and I don't want it squandered on makework. While I think people can find important dignity in work, I think paying people to do things that aren't needed destroys that dignity.
- AnimalMuppet 12y agoEspecially when the "worker" figures it out.
- nhaehnle 12y agoThe argument is that there are plenty of things that are obviously useful (or even needed) which aren't being done today because too many people incorrectly equate "useful" with "profitable" - and so only the profitable things end up being done, while many useful things remain undone. The fact that your strawman appears so frequently shows that knowledge about the details of a Job Guarantee are not spread widely enough yet.
- dllthomas 12y agoIt's not a straw man. How do you tell apart a job guarantee from any old program doing things that need doing? The difference is that, with the job guarantee you may eventually have to start creating make-work; otherwise, it is not a guarantee. I oppose make-work, so I oppose the guarantee. I do not, on these grounds, oppose creation of jobs to do things that are not make-work.