3 ms·
From the article: "Even though some readers call for a stipend to everyone, that simply is not going to happen, at least in terms of net results." From Wikiped
by dllthomas 12y ago
From the article: "Even though some readers call for a stipend to everyone, that simply is not going to happen, at least in terms of net results."
From Wikipedia: "The authorities at Speenhamland approved a means-tested sliding-scale of wage supplements in order to mitigate the worst effects of rural poverty. Families were paid extra to top up wages to a set level according to a table."
So... "basic income isn't going to happen, a priori, so I'm going to call the failure of this other system (that looks much more like what we're currently doing than like a basic income) a failure of basic income".
- SilasX 12y agoThat is actually an insanely common tactic in political debate.
- AnimalMuppet 12y agoIt is. And yet... has true basic income ever been tried, anywhere? If not, the best guide we can find is to look at the closest thing to it that has so far been tried (hopefully recognizing that the example is not completely equivalent, and therefore not completely relevant). If the new idea takes into account the experience of the old, and has revisions to specifically deal with the problems that the old system encountered, then the question is whether the changes are actually going to fix the problem. (You want to avoid "We painted it orange this time, so your previous experience doesn't prove that our approach won't work!)
- tonyarkles 12y agohttp://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mincome http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mincome Looks like it was tried as a 5-year experiment. I haven't looked into the details too closely though, although the statistics on Wikipedia seem relatively promising.
- dllthomas 12y agoThe sharp drop-off of means testing is precisely the thing that a basic income is intended to fix. The example cited isn't "basic income" any more than Welfare is.