3 ms·
In addition to the other replies you've got, this kind of judgement is, I think, beyond most people's capability to make. Should everyone who works at Turn be
by JadeNB 12y ago
In addition to the other replies you've got, this kind of judgement is, I think, beyond most people's capability to make. Should everyone who works at Turn be shunned, or just those who work on this project specifically? If a previously honourable company starts doing dishonourable work, how long a window does an engineer working there have to find another job before he or she is shunned? What does it mean to 'enable' Turn? That is, could a third-party indirectly enable them? How do we make the judgement when this has happened? For example, should W3C be shunned for making a standard that can be abused in this way?
- jes 12y agoI appreciate your comment. For me, it's a matter of the degree to which the person sees the ramifications of what they are doing, and the degree to which they directly contribute to the bad actions. For example, the management team that has built a business around tracking people who clearly do not wish to be tracked is highly suspect, in my view. The sysadmin that runs the servers, less so. But if she/he knows what the company is all about, I'd urge him/her to either try to change the mindset within the company (likely, impossible) or start looking for another gig. I would not ask anyone to sacrifice themselves, but neither should they be facilitating unhelpful behaviors. Verizon, of course, is enabling Turn (as I understand the situation.) Companies that are customers of Turn are also enabling them, in my view. How do you see it?
- JadeNB 12y agoPrecisely because your questions seem particularly on point, I find them hard to answer; but I wanted to say that I appreciate your thoughtful engagement with respondents in this thread. It's a rare sight, even on HN, and a pleasure.