3 ms·
"I think we are more likely to enter a society that is more tolerant of people's behavior and private views than we are of one where everyone deletes data after
by jerf 12y ago
"I think we are more likely to enter a society that is more tolerant of people's behavior and private views than we are of one where everyone deletes data after a time."
In the personal social sphere, I can believe that. There, the primary threat is embarrassment, and that's a social construct.
But politically, economically, and anywhere where a larger-scale power relationship exists, I can't imagine that being the outcome. Sony's hack was not primarily a problem due to "people' behavior and private views". It was a component of their issue, yes, but there was also a lot of stuff that simply straight-up materially damaged their interests that would have been better if it had been purged before anyone got it. From the hoarder's point of view, the calculus changes as older material inevitably drops towards zero utility over time whereas the liabilities involved in it being stolen remain non-trivial. Right now, next to nobody is properly accounting for the liabilities, so people are storing more than they really rationally ought to.
(As I like to say, you can make anything look good by considering only the benefits, and you can make anything look bad by considering only the costs. Alas, the only path to a proper analysis is to consider both correctly.)
And from the other side, governments and litigants will want people to retain data for as long as possible precisely because it removes power from those being forced to retain the data, for good and for ill.