3 ms·
The Security of Data Deletion
- taeric 12y agoI can't help but feel this is a ship that long sailed. I ultimately support the idea, but we seem to have turned into a society of hoarders, when it comes to data. And, indeed, for many purposes this is quite useful. As far away as I think the day is, I think we are more likely to enter a society that is more tolerant of people's behavior and private views than we are of one where everyone deletes data after a time.
- jerf 12y ago"I think we are more likely to enter a society that is more tolerant of people's behavior and private views than we are of one where everyone deletes data after a time." In the personal social sphere, I can believe that. There, the primary threat is embarrassment, and that's a social construct. But politically, economically, and anywhere where a larger-scale power relationship exists, I can't imagine that being the outcome. Sony's hack was not primarily a problem due to "people' behavior and private views". It was a component of their issue, yes, but there was also a lot of stuff that simply straight-up materially damaged their interests that would have been better if it had been purged before anyone got it. From the hoarder's point of view, the calculus changes as older material inevitably drops towards zero utility over time whereas the liabilities involved in it being stolen remain non-trivial. Right now, next to nobody is properly accounting for the liabilities, so people are storing more than they really rationally ought to. (As I like to say, you can make anything look good by considering only the benefits, and you can make anything look bad by considering only the costs. Alas, the only path to a proper analysis is to consider both correctly.) And from the other side, governments and litigants will want people to retain data for as long as possible precisely because it removes power from those being forced to retain the data, for good and for ill.
- npsimons 12y agoFrom one point of view, the history of computing has been one of trying to maintain data integrity, which in turn makes it harder and harder to permanently delete anything. On the other hand, I can think of very few downsides to a more tolerant society, and fervently believe that it can't happen soon enough.
- saidajigumi 12y agoAnd not just data integrity, but capacity and culture work against "digital forgetting" as well. Capacity (re: cost per unit) has been growing (much) faster than our ability to generate correspondence. Now, the new default is to just go with the flow of our digital memory. Likewise, IT organizations have built in policies and practices around backing up and preserving data. New effort and planning around comprehensive deletion policies would seem to be the next frontier, both at the IT and individual levels. Deletion policies exist now, but in my experience these are often half-hearted compared to retention policies. Even (especially?) for individuals in companies, email and the like become a memory prosthetic. You don't need to make external notes, because you can always go back to email. Speaking personally, I know of many, many occasions where I've had to refer back to communications at least two months old. At some organizations, trolling the last year's email has been practically obligatory when slogging through annual reviews.
- abandonliberty 12y agoNewer generations are much more sensitive to the persistence of data, particularly the challenges it entails when it comes to social networks. A Facebook timeline is forever, but snapchat isn't. The display and archiving of human behavior ends it.
- higherpurpose 12y agoLocalization, localization, localization. Tighten up the security for tiny islands within the organization. Don't just do perimeter defense [1] and don't give a single computer access to thousands of other computers. Don't route and don't monitor everyone's emails through a single server. Use end-to-end encrypted email and ephemeral messages, as Schneier says. Something like Kobeissi's new Peerio tool would've helped Sony and MPAA from having embarrassing emails leak out (not that I wasn't glad to see them leak out). [1] - https://community.rapid7.com/community/infosec/blog/2015/01/07/the-sony-breach-demonstrates-the-importance-of-moving-beyond-perimeter-defense https://community.rapid7.com/community/infosec/blog/2015/01/... [2] - https://peerio.com/ https://peerio.com/
- coldcode 12y agoAt my previous job the company lawyers sent out monthly reminders to archive all emails and documents in case we got sued. Oddly enough the company could have easily done this from the server itself. I wonder if perhaps making employees do it meant it would never be saved as the server removed things older than 90 days.