2 ms·
This is because you (like manny others) are unfamiliar with what racism means. Racism (when applied to processes rather than individuals) means practices -- int
by pron 12y ago
This is because you (like manny others) are unfamiliar with what racism means. Racism (when applied to processes rather than individuals) means practices -- intentional or not -- that result in an unequal distribution of power among races. If a computer program perpetuates or increases the unequal distribution of power among races, then that program is racist. The same definition, BTW, applies to sexism, where that refers to unequal distribution of power between the sexes.
- yellowapple 12y agoBut what about that program is actually racist? The first paragraph establishes that the program bases its decisions on indicators of financial responsibility. It then makes a decision based (apparently) on race alone. This would require race to be a recorded indicator of financial responsibility as decided by the programmer (or his/her employer). Had race not been recorded at all by the computer, then it would not have made a "racist" decision (for it would be based entirely on individual merit, rather than any particular connections with others of a specific demographic), and this article would therefore be turned over onto its head and rendered entirely moot.
- pron 12y agoThis is a bit of a philosophical question, and I don't think you should take it too literally, but here's what I think. If race is one of the variables, then due to correlations created by society, race might be learned to be a negative signal, which is racist. If it isn't one of the variables, it might be still inferred. For example, if your purchasing history is an input, there is probably a correlation between purchase of cosmetics for blacks and chances of incarceration, which, in turn affects your chances of loan repayment. The correlation between being black and buying, say, hair-care products for blacks is direct and causal (and completely non racist -- there is no effect on power), so this could be an almost perfect, and neutral, proxy for race, and, in fact, might be the best and simplest correlation the program could come up with.