3 ms·
Politics = human actions that affect distribution of power in society. See the end of this comment for examples of political and non-political things. > It's a
by pron 12y ago
Politics = human actions that affect distribution of power in society. See the end of this comment for examples of political and non-political things.
> It's a bit unreasonable to ask adwords engineers to layer on some post-hoc fix...
Maybe so. But this article notes the interesting fact that failing to do so is a political action. We can leave the discussion of what we should do to another time. Right now it's just important to understand what it is that we are doing.
> also completely unfair to the individual humans
Again, that is a question of policy and values. You may find it unfair and I may think the opposite is unfair; that's a matter of political orientation. But this article is not about what's fair and unfair, but an objective observation of the role computers play in the dynamics of society.
> And of course, built into all of this is the assumption that statistical disparities are all caused by mistreatment.
Not quite. What's built into this is the fact that human actions -- intentional or inadvertent -- affect the distribution of power in society. Whether or not there's mistreatment is a specific question pertaining to the specific histories of specific countries and societies.
> That is unlikely to be true.
Well, this is a question of fact, and research has conclusively shown a direct link from slavery and Jim Crow (that lasted for 250 + 100 = 350 years more or less, and ended, as official legal policy, only 50 years -- one generation -- ago) to the current distribution of power among races in American society.
EDIT: people who hold liberal values do make one relevant assumption: that it is very unlikely that certain groups would voluntarily (i.e. free of any influence and persuasion) yield power (over them) to others. Theoretically, this assumption could be wrong, but so far we have no reason to believe so. Also, this seems like a sensible assumption, and the burden of proof should be on those who think it's false.
> "political" in the sense of "anything that ever affects anything", then sure - ad serving is political.
I mean political as in political[1]: human actions that affect distribution of power in society. If a volcano erupts and destroys a town -- that's not political. If however, the volcano is known to be dangerous and therefore only poor people buy houses in its vicinity, there may be politics involved. The invention of the locomotive is purely technological, but choosing which cities the railway passes through might be political. Machine learning is technological. But programming computers to take actions which may affect the distribution of power based on machine learning extracting information from past data is political.
[1]: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Politics#Politics_as_an_academic_discipline http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Politics#Politics_as_an_academi...
- yummyfajitas 12y ago...research has conclusively shown a direct link from slavery and Jim Crow... A link. They haven't shown that every disparity is caused by it. And the rapid social movement of various other groups (e.g., vietnamese, filipinos, mexicans) suggests that historical explanations don't have great explanatory power anyway. I retract what I said. According to your definition of "political", ad serving, dating, renting a house, playing video games, etc, are all political acts. Very few actions by humans are not political.
- pron 12y ago> They haven't shown that every disparity is caused by it. True. But all they needed to show -- and they have -- is that this is the largest contributing factor, which explains most of the observed effect (in fact, they didn't even need to show that, only that it's a large contributing factor; if you were born with one weak leg and I take a hammer to the other one, doesn't mean that I'm not responsible for you being confined to a wheelchair). What, AFAIK, hasn't been found is other contributing factors (that you seem to allude to), but I won't deny their theoretical existence. > According to your definition of "political", ad serving, dating, renting a house, playing video games, etc, are all political acts. No. First, this is not "my definition" but the real definition, which you are free to look up on Wikipedia at your leisure. Here's the link -- again -- for your convenience: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Politics#Politics_as_an_academic_discipline http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Politics#Politics_as_an_academi... Second, many actions by humans can be political, if they influence the distribution of power in society. Note that this is not a binary definition: one action can be more or less political than another. Finally, why are you trolling? Are you trying to understand this science or make fun of it?
- yummyfajitas 12y agoWhat, AFAIK, hasn't been found is other contributing factors... Clearly you aren't that familiar with the research then. There are many disparities in work and academic effort, labor force participation, criminal propensity, IQ and career choice. I've not seen any analysis that controls for all of these or any remotely accurate predictive model. I guess given your voluminous command of the literature, you'll provide one? Finally, why are you trolling? Are you trying to understand this science or make fun of it? I was merely linking to some interesting and relevant articles on causal calculus that relate to the issues in the article. You are the one who went on a random tangent about how everything is political and I should use the most expansive possible definition for certain words, and somehow I'm denying science if I don't.