6 ms·
Normal exercise will not cause weight loss - countless studies have shown that. But it will make you healthier, so it's worth it anyway.
by ars 12y ago
Normal exercise will not cause weight loss - countless studies have shown that.
But it will make you healthier, so it's worth it anyway.
- beachstartup 12y agowhile i agree, this concept is easier to sell if you approach it from a different direction - i.e. "you can't outrun your fork." this is much easier for most people to comprehend, since anyone who's ever been in a modern gym even once knows you can run an hour on a treadmill and wipe it out with a single donut.
- stinos 12y agoEasier to sell, maybe, but "you can't outrun your fork." is also a false statement, whereas the OP's isn't (so much - at least it's open for interpreation). You can outrun your fork. run an hour on a treadmill and wipe it out with a single donut. That's going to be have a pretty huge donut then :P (or I'd have to be running at a rather slow pace)
- IndianAstronaut 12y ago>That's going to be have a pretty huge donut then Not really. One hour on the treadmill burns about 600 calories or so. A cream filled donut the gas station next door to me sells is listed at 630 calories.
- cncool 12y agoI would say a 630 calorie donut is pretty huge. After looking at the calorie info for a bunch of Tim Hortons donuts, the average seems to be around 250 calories.
- lloeki 12y ago> I would say a 630 calorie donut is pretty huge Therein lies the rub: most people can't fathom they're eating way too much since they feel like it's normal because habit and social.
- pm90 12y agoSugar (and now HFCS) in everything magnify this problem. I wonder how much calories food would have if manufacturers reduced the amount of sweeteners. Probably makes the food taste worse though.
- thizzbuzz 12y agoAre you in Canada? I wasn't familiar with Tim Hortons, but Wikipedia indicates its a Canadian bakery chain. Come on down to the US and you will find 600 calorie donuts aplenty.
- jeltz 12y agoDunikin' Donuts goes from 220 to 550 calories, with the average somewhere around 350, so 600 kcal seems like quite a bit.
- eli_gottlieb 12y agoWeird. I usually burn about 400 kilocals in a 30-minute run on an elliptical machine. Technically, I am programming it to push my heart-rate to the top of the safe "cardio zone", but, well, exercise is all about pushing yourself, no?
- jeltz 12y agoHow much you burn depends a lot on your body weight. I am small (~55kg) so I burn about 600 kcal/h when jogging. Someone weighing 75kg will burn about 800 kcal/h if he runs at the same speed.
- beachstartup 12y agothe problem with being pedantic like this is that you just come off as a huge nerd to everyone, even other pedantic nerds. that's why i said "easier to sell", not "technically more accurate."
- DINKDINK 12y ago>Normal exercise will not cause weight loss What do you define "normal exercise" as? You cannot break the 2nd law of thermodynamics: if you calories in is less than your calories burned you must lose weight.
- jckt 12y agoI think he/she means that normal exercise, or rather the typical amount of exercise that people do, is insufficient to burn the calories in a normal diet. So while the exercise you do is healthy, you shouldn't be expecting weight loss, though at the same time you should expect less weight gain (which I wouldn't consider as weight loss).
- SiVal 12y agoNo, it's that people who exercise more tend to eat more, even when their primary reason for exercising is to lose weight. They either don't think about it or overestimate the calories burned by their exercise and allow themselves to eat a bit more, mistakenly believing that the net result is still negative calories. Moderate exercise is good for you whether or not you want to lose weight, but if weight control is one objective, you need to be more careful than most people realize to avoid eating more when you exercise more.
- sgift 12y agoYour body can regulate your appetite and your calorie spending to a certain degree, e.g. people who exercise often eat more afterwards, which negates the calorie burning effect (but it can also lead to changes in body composition: Fat is replaced by muscles).
- thret 12y agoDaily hard exercise - the panting, heart-pounding, drenched in sweat kind of exercise - increases your metabolism. You can eat whatever you want, as much as you want, and you won't gain fat. The 2nd law of thermodynamics has little if anything to do with calorie counting.
- 12y ago
- tribaal 12y agoYeah, it also seems to me people hear "diet and exercise" as if the second part was somehow optional :(
- jeltz 12y agoIt is optional if the goal is only to lose weight. I personally found it harder to lose weight when I started exercising since then I could no longer fast as much.
- rdtsc 12y ago"Exercise more" in reference to weight loss is also often promoted by fast or processed food companies, in an effort to divert blame for either not displaying nutritional information or making it misleading.
- throwawayaway 12y agorunning does use up calories. timing your exercise so that it's just before a fixed portion of a meal means you have used more calories than if you had not - and you still feel full. the surprising part is how little of a difference running makes, but it does make a difference.
- gadders 12y agoWeight loss is a poor metric. I don't really care what I weigh. I'm primarily concerned with increasing my strenght and building muscle, so if my weight goes up but my %fat goes down I'm more than happy.
- victorhooi 12y agoI do not agree with your statement. What do you even mean by "normal exercise"? I believe that most "normal" people are capable of doing enough exercise (combined with good eating choices) that they can lose weight. For example, say you have a 1-hour lunch break each day. During that lunch break, you could easily go for a 6km run (30-40 minutes), as well as have time for a shower, and grab food. If you're prepared to have a faster shower, and eat a quick snack, heck, you could even make it a 10km run (50 minutes). And depending on where you live, you might also be able to jog, or cycle to work - that's probably another 30 to 60 minutes of physical activity, depending on how far. (I have a 15-minute cycle each way). And maybe some mornings, you could get up early, and go for a swim, or go boxing or something. Either way, I personally know many ordinary people who manage to get a healthy amount of exercise, and achieve their weight goals. I also have a friend who quite honestly, eats what seems to be an incredibly unhealthy mix - think large amounts of junk food and deep-fried fast food. However, they manage to stay reasonably slim (think BMI 18) by doing insane amounts of exercise (several hours a day). So it's definitely achievable, assuming you have that sort of willpower. What studies are you referring to, that show that "normal" exercise will not cause weight loss? I'd be very curious to see them.
- vetler 12y agoIt's psychological. Of course; eating exactly the number of calories that are required to maintain your weight, and then you start to exercise - yes, you will lose weight. But people don't do that. They think "hey, I need a post-workout meal", and suddenly they're eating that in addition to everything else. And then it's the weekend, and they feel they deserve something extra because they've worked out a lot. Or they're already getting too many calories, and working out just makes them get fatter slower.
- arrrg 12y agoA BMI of 18 is not reasonably slim, it’s extremely slim, right (potentially unhealthy, depending on the individual)? Is that irony?
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- 12y ago
- easuter 12y agoWhat do you mean by "normal exercise"? For example, yesterday I burned ~750kcal on the treadmill. Are you trying to tell me this makes no dent in the calories I consumed throughout the day? If my objective was to lose weight, are you implying that doing such a workout couldn't lead to a calorie deficit and therefore expenditure of stored fat?
- Terr_ 12y agoI suspect he meant something a bit more holistic/behavioral ("In a study of people who promised to X...") rather than in a purely mechanical/metabolic sense. If the person is only thinking "exercise will make me weigh less", that outcome is unlikely because modern society makes it deceptively easy to wipe out all your gains with a "small" snack, and because the conversion of fat to muscle doesn't show much on a scale.