7 ms·
How do climbers like these reconcile drilling bolts into the rockface with the 'leave no trace' ethic?
by chrisseaton 12y ago
How do climbers like these reconcile drilling bolts into the rockface with the 'leave no trace' ethic?
- NathanKP 12y agoBecause human life is more important than not leaving a trace.
- codingdave 12y agoThey are not mutually exclusive.
- baddox 12y agoThat depends on how strictly you interpret leave no trace.
- 001sky 12y agoHuman life or human ego?
- jacalata 12y agoAnd leaving no trace is less important to some people than climbing.
- marcusrussi 12y agoWell, some of the bolts were already there, and I'm not sure if Tommy Caldwell and Kevin Jorgeson actually drilled any of their own bolts, but I wouldn't be surprised if they put in a few. Bolts have always been a source of controversy in climbing – in fact, bolts were the main controversy in the first ascent of the Dawn Wall (/ Wall of Early Morning Light) back in 1970, so much that the first ascensionist's rival Royal Robbins actually climbed the route and chopped the bolts off as he went. There have been similar controversies all over the world, another notable example being on Cerro Torre in Patagonia. Unless a climbing area is a designated "sport climbing area", bolts are generally not placed unless there is no other way to protect a stretch of climbing. Climbers try to place devices that don't damage the rock (nuts, cams, tricams, hexes, etc.) first, but sometimes none of those devices will work as they all rely on jamming against something, and blank faces do not have the cracks and holes into which jamming gear can be inserted. When this happens, bolts are placed because there isn't any other way to protect the climbers in the event of the fall. So, I don't really have a good answer to your question except to say that the use of bolts has always and still is a huge source of controversy in the climbing community. These days, with sport "crags" being the exception, climbers try to rely on other "clean" methods of protection before turning to bolts, which is in stark contrast to past eras where bolts and pitons were the predominant way to protect pitches.
- sliverstorm 12y agobolts are generally not placed unless there is no other way to protect a stretch of climbing Which, it should be noted, describes a lot of terrain in Yosemite. The glaciated black granite provides limited opportunity for protection.
- steveax 12y agoImportant to note that Robbins changed his mind and stopped chopping bolts 2 pitches into the 2nd ascent as (according to Lauria) "the quality of the aid climbing was much higher than he had ever expected of Harding or Caldwell and, of course, it was also taking us an awful long time to chop all those goddam bolts." [1] The seminal article on "clean climbing" was authored by Yvon Chouinard and Tom Frost and appeared in the 1972 Chouinard catalog [2] [1] http://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Royal_Robbins#Wall_of_Early_Morning_Light http://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Royal_Robbins#Wall_of_Early_M... [2] http://climbaz.com/chouinard72/ch_page2.html http://climbaz.com/chouinard72/ch_page2.html
- nether 12y agoJust watch Reel Rock 9: Valley Uprising to learn all of this.
- erjiang 12y agoIt's a tough debate. On one hand, bolts are not very visible and no wildlife is going to try to eat and choke on a bolt. On the other hand, it's permanently altering the rock, and bolts don't have an infinite lifespan. There are also cases of landowners disallowing white chalk (or chalk in general) because it visibly stains the rock and doesn't wash off very quickly. Bolts allow cliffs to be used for recreational climbing, much like how trails alter the landscape, but allow the land to be used for recreational hiking. No human activity is 100% impact free, unfortunately.
- sandworm 12y agoSome landowners ban chalk thinking that it's the chalk that makes routes white. It isn't. In most rock the hardest stuff is the quartz crystals. As all the soft stuff is eroded away by foot traffic (mica and such) the white quartz is left exposed. You can always spot a climbing route by the polished-white toeholds. Chalk or not, climbing makes marks.
- famousactress 12y agoIt's not without controversy, and climbers are far from unanimous about it. The decision to bolt is definitely one that the climbing community at least takes seriously and has a vocabulary and some rubrics around (though admittedly there are factions of opinion on it). Generally the decision to bolt is favorable only when it's unsafe to climb with traditional gear. The impact that bolting has is rationalized worthwhile due to it's (arguably) low direct impact on the environment and the fact that sport climbing proliferates lots of outdoor enthusiasts with the attention and dollars that brings.
- betenoire 12y agotraces will be left, regardless. Natural protection (cams, nuts, etc) damages the rock too. Sometimes much more than a bolt would have. I've seen plenty of "cracks" that were nothing more than a stretch of piton scars. A well-placed and installed bolt can reduce the wear on the rock, and can blend in if done right. A lot of climbing gear that is meant to be left can be bought in color tones the casual observer is less likely to notice.
- steveax 12y agoBeating pins in and out is a lot different that placing and removing a stopper. The only rock that is significantly damaged by clean climbing gear is (soft) sandstone and the like.
- sandworm 12y agoSome of these aid routes (the pitons) eventually go clean as the scars get big enough to hold a nut or the new paper-thin cams.
- thaumaturgy 12y agoTo add to the other comments, there are also camouflaged bolts and hangers which are popular (and even required) in some areas. Climbers in general care a lot about the places they climb, and often tend to them as well or better than many other groups. There are organized cleanups and trail management and self-policing, and relations between land managers and climbers are usually OK, with climbers willing to cooperate with access restrictions for the benefit of an area (with the notable exception of Hueco Tanks and probably a couple other places). If someone unnecessarily bolts a route, they can usually expect to hear about it from other climbers, and the bolts might even be removed. Given that casual observers often don't even realize the bolts are there, climbers really do fuss a lot over relatively little impact. Of course, like any other group, climbing has some jerks too. (But proportionately less than many other groups.)
- sandworm 12y agoIt depends on the route. Place bolts beside a crack to facilitate sport climbing and you should expect the hangars to be bashed flat (pulling out the actual bolt is often very difficult). I've participated in this myself. And before anyone screams, the debate on "fixed protection" is something best left to experienced local climbers. Every climbing area has their own traditions on the subject. The first rule is most always: Don't change the nature of the route to suit your climbing style. Respect those who setup the route before you. Putting new metal on an existing route, camo or not, is akin to spray-painting a Rembrandt. Replacement of old/weak hardware is a different matter. Absent immediate safety, this should still be left to experienced locals.
- thaumaturgy 12y agoFWIW, I appreciate you doing that. People taking the time out to self-police the community is part of what makes it pretty great overall, which helps keep access open for everyone.
- sliverstorm 12y agoFirst is the issue of safety, which many others have talked about here. Sometimes a bolt is the only way. Second is the fact that sometimes a bolt is actually the lesser impact. Bolts last a pretty long time, and if a route is highly traveled, the bolt can help offload what would have been gradual damage to the rock, flora, and fauna. For example, if you have six climbing parties a day rappelling off a tree at the end of the climb, that tree is going to sustain damage over time. A bolt placed nearby can serve the same duty easier, safer, and with less impact to the tree. To draw on other recreation, have you noticed stairs on hiking trails? A popular trail can experience so much erosion on steep sections that something so blatantly "leaving a trace" as installing stairs is actually the lower impact choice.
- blhack 12y agoIt is certainly a contentious thing. A consideration, though, is that if they're preserving the rock face by not drilling bolts into it, then what are they preserving it for? I wonder if you can even see the bolts from the ground (I doubt it).
- rhino42 12y agoAn attentive climber can see bolts from the ground at up to maybe 90-100 feet away. Mostly because of fortuitous sunlight reflections. The general idea is that at some point in the future, we might be able to protect these difficult routes. So we preserve it for that. This argument is more legitimate in some cases than others. For instance, maybe someday we'll have some non-destructive way to protect thin cracks and flakes. But it is very unlikely that we can say the same about a barren face.
- steveax 12y agoThe other thing that is worth preserving for is a climber bolder than you who is willing to climb it without drilling that bolt ;-)
- snowwrestler 12y agoIt's a shame you're getting downvoted for this, because it is a real and fairly popular sentiment in the climbing community. The concept of "fair means" is based on the idea of setting limits on the artificial aids that a climber uses to reach the top. For example, pretty much every climber agrees that taking a helicopter to the top is not fair means. It's context-specific, too. On El Cap, taking the hiking trail up the back to reach the top is not considered a "climb" on par with ascending the cliff. But on Mount Rainier, hiking the top counts as a climb even if you take the easiest way up (basically because the easiest way up is still not easy). Free climbing itself is actually a form of fair means--ascending the rock using only what the rock itself gives you for progress. All gear does is provide a safety net. Climbing without bolts and pitons--known as climbing "clean"--is also a form of fair means. It takes as its guiding principle to leave the rock as you found it. Under this approach, climbers will indeed leave blank faces unclimbed. Those bold enough to climb such faces with minimal protection are respected as having shown great commitment to their ideals.