4 ms·
> In fact, Turn has told EFF that they do not believe that either Do Not Track or a user deleting their cookies is a signal that the user wishes to opt out from
by yellowapple 12y ago
> In fact, Turn has told EFF that they do not believe that either Do Not Track or a user deleting their cookies is a signal that the user wishes to opt out from tracking.
What the fuck, Turn? You got a different explanation for what the fuck "Do Not Track" means?
Are they for fucking real right now? I mean, I've seen my share of grade-A corporate double-speak, but this takes the goddamn cake. Holy fucking shit. Thank God I'm not a Verizon customer in any capacity (that I know of). With this kind of bullshit, I don't plan on that changing any-the-fuck-time soon.
- quesera 12y ago> What the fuck, Turn? You got a different explanation for what the fuck "Do Not Track" means? Easy there. IE10 defaults to Do Not Track enabled. So sending the header is not explicitly representative of the user's wishes. Convenient, isn't it?
- fortmeaded 12y agoSplitting hairs, but it's not exactly a default. It's a preselected option. The user gets some notice and has to accept.
- higherpurpose 12y agoI think that's a difference without a distinction.
- coherentpony 12y ago> IE10 defaults to Do Not Track enabled. So sending the header is not explicitly representative of the user's wishes. "By signing up for [insert service here], you agree to the privacy policy." How many times did you actually agree with the privacy policy? Devil's advocate, I know, but it's a sobering reminder that pretty much anything you use gives information that is sold. Open a bank account? If so, notice any new junk mail? Pretty hard to live life without a bank account. Your information is still sold to third parties.
- plorg 12y agoTo play another devil's advocate, shouldn't that also imply that IE10 users sending Do Not Track are in fact explicitly representing their desire not to be tracked? I mean by that same argument the user, by using Windows/IE10 did in fact choose the default settings of the browser, per the terms and conditions agreed to upon installing/purchasing Windows/IE. Live by the T&C, die by the T&C - unless you can hide your scumminess through underhanded or obfuscated tactics.
- merrua 12y agohttp://xkcd.com/1432/ http://xkcd.com/1432/
- hackuser 12y ago> IE10 defaults to Do Not Track enabled. So sending the header is not explicitly representative of the user's wishes. > Convenient, isn't it? That might be an excuse, but it's not the reason. They easily could read the DNT header and the user agent, and trust DNT headers from non-IE10 browsers.
- quesera 12y agoAbsolutely. They're interpreting the situation with strict literality because it is in their benefit to do so. They have a perfectly valid reason for what they do: it's strongly beneficial to their business model to operate in a scummy but probably-legal way. They are hardly unique in this. Since we have little market recourse (Verizon is often the only option, and we are not customers of Turn), and we have no legal recourse (again, scummy but almost certainly legal in almost all circumstances)...what is left? Well, there are technical solutions to the problem. TLS is a good start. Browsers can be smarter about third party cookies. The Verizon Overcookie can be stripped by a proxy. VPN can solve many problems... This glommed on tracking junk is fragile. I strongly resent being drawn into the arms race, but it is winnable. It will take something dramatic (and who knows how long) for our outrage to be shared by a critical mass of customers/voters, so for now, I think technology is the solution. But I donate to EFF too.
- cpeterso 12y agoThis is why Apache added code to ignore IE10's DNT header: http://www.cnet.com/news/apache-web-software-overrides-ie10-do-not-track-setting/ http://www.cnet.com/news/apache-web-software-overrides-ie10-... https://github.com/apache/httpd/commit/a381ff35fa4d50a5f7b9f64300dfd98859dee8d0 https://github.com/apache/httpd/commit/a381ff35fa4d50a5f7b9f... but, ironically, it was soon disabled by default: https://github.com/apache/httpd/commit/3dd6fb6882ae2b453c90d51e777e88bc420a0cb1 https://github.com/apache/httpd/commit/3dd6fb6882ae2b453c90d...
- rhizome 12y agoIf the tables were turned, the tracking would be a CFAA violation.
- yellowapple 12y agoI don't use Internet Explorer. I use Firefox. If I have Do Not Track set (which I do), it means that I have explicitly requested to not be tracked, and that such a header is explicitly representative of my wishes. The sooner we have a full list of all companies which are doing business with Turn, the happier I'll be, since that would provide me with a better target for my (admittedly excessively) strongly-worded frustration.
- coherentpony 12y agoGloriously filthy composition, but that's probably due to the expected increase in blood pressure from having your civil liberties stripped from you. I am in unconditional agreement with you here.
- oldmanjay 12y agoI get that this falls in line with the accepted local opinion but I thought HN aspired to be better than pandering garbage filled with vulgarity.
- hobs 12y agoVulgarity is to be used sparingly and effectively, and I think many voices want to say the same thing, and it is a valid part of the discussion. Overall it would have been classier to limit it to the first sentence, but sometimes you have to get spittin mad to get your point across.
- yellowapple 12y agoMy apologies. I'm usually more composed than that, but sometimes one encounters this level of malice and simply snaps.