4 ms·
From a non-economist point of view, the bit about deflationary technological advancement doesn't seem hard to understand at all. Summers claims it makes no sen
by DennisP 12y ago
From a non-economist point of view, the bit about deflationary technological advancement doesn't seem hard to understand at all.
Summers claims it makes no sense because price changes are accounted for in GDP. I'm willing to bet that GDP is not adjusted for Moore's Law, or we would have had much higher official growth numbers than we've had. Every iPhone is a more powerful computer than an early-90s supercomputer. Each iPhone sale does not add as much to GDP as each supercomputer did, even after adjusting for our modest inflation.
And yet that computational power is improving people's lives in all sorts of ways.
- nostrademons 12y agoThere's usually a paragraph in most introductory macroeconomic textbooks, as they introduce the definitions of nominal GDP and real GDP, to the effect of "Real GDP is GDP deflated by the price of a basket of goods. It cannot account for qualitative improvements in the nature of goods, nor can it account for substitution effects where an old good is completely replaced by a new good of equal price but higher quality. These effects are difficult to measure and difficult to quantify." And then because they are difficult to measure and difficult to quantify, they are ignored in the rest of the textbook. It's telling that a professional economist like Larry Summers can forget that paragraph. When you work with models day in and day out for your whole career, the models quickly become reality, even if the models have known flaws and blind spots that become very apparent when you apply them to everyone else's reality.
- smacktoward 12y agoI still remember the first day in my college freshman year Econ 101 class. The professor began by explaining how the foundational idea of the discipline is that people are rational actors who make decisions by weighing costs and benefits. I thought of all the actual people I knew, every one of whom had made major life decisions based on impulse, emotion or stupidity, and thought "welp, so much for economics then."