4 ms·
Should Psychological Neuroscience Research Be Funded?
- CognitiveLens 12y agoYes, it should be funded, but not without consideration of alternatives for particular measures. There is a lot of bad, expensive neuroscience work - much of it yields no significant result - but there are also important results that are unavailable by other means. It's good to inject caution but the potential for great advances in understanding how the mind works is still there.
- im3w1l 12y agoLet me formulate another thought experiment. We want to investigate the subjective experience of heat. Subjects are to put their hands into water heated or cooled using various procedures and rate how hot it is on a subjective scale. If we are ultimately only interested in the subjective experience, could a thermometer really add anything? There is one interesting property of the thermometer, it is very good at predicting how someone would rate it. Because of "survey variance", the thermometer reading is a better predictor of subject b's rating, than the rating subject a gives. Because the thermometer reading is a better predictor of the subjective experience, I would say that it is better at capturing the underlying phenomenon.