The main problem in reproducing the study is that it is very vague what counted as a formatting error. It would have been very reasonable to just upload the out

The main problem in reproducing the study is that it is very vague what counted as a formatting error. It would have been very reasonable to just upload the output from each participant so that the analysis of the results could be reproduced. But the main problem of the study is not its reproducibility. The main problem is that it is designed in a completely wrong way and it cannot seriously claim to answer the questions it pretends that it answers.