4 ms·
"Threads was ludicrous propaganda" Actually, Threads was actually fairly optimistic about the likely scale of a Soviet attack on the UK: http://en.wikipedia.o
by arethuza 12y ago
"Threads was ludicrous propaganda"
Actually, Threads was actually fairly optimistic about the likely scale of a Soviet attack on the UK:
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Square_Leg http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Square_Leg
Also Threads was attempting to show the actual state of preparation of the UK for nuclear war - so saying that a nuclear war is easy to survive if you are prepared is a bit silly as the UK (and the US) really weren't that prepared - that was the point!
- hga 12y agoWhen you add the lies about "life wouldn't be worth living afterwords" it goes from e.g. being a potential call for action to get prepared into "Better Red Than Dead" propaganda.
- cbd1984 12y agoActually, the "Life wouldn't be worth living afterwords" was more associated with the anti-war nuclear disarmament group. The people who wanted us to be prepared to strike were the ones who thought war would be survivable and the conditions afterwords tolerable, at least for some substantial chunk of the population. Maybe that's all just my perception.
- hga 12y agoNope, not just all your perception (although the "prepared to strike" ones were split between the "and also protect the population" types, and starting with JFK and Robert Strange McNamara, the truly MAD ones (Mutual Assured Destruction, which to take a riff from Doctor Strangelove, would have worked a lot better if the Soviets accepted it, instead of correctly thinking it was profoundly immoral)). The question here, is what side do you think the "Inspired Nineteen Eighty Four!" BBC was on?
- rhino369 12y agoIt was realistic about the initial attacks and aftermath. But the idea that a nuclear winter would send the UK back to the middle ages is ridiculous. Hell, someone would at least take it over for the arable land.
- arethuza 12y agoI agree that the long term effects based on nuclear winter etc. are arguable. But the whole point was that an advanced technological society depends on the connections between people - and most people in the UK would have died in the initial attack or in the immediate aftermath due to simple things like starvation. Edit: "the idea that a nuclear winter would send the UK back to the middle ages is ridiculous." A early, probably 1960s, review by the UK government (who actually had plenty experience of the impact of bombing) concluded that the UK would cease to function as a society if we were attacked by three H-bombs - indeed our ambassador to Moscow apparently had a debate with a tipsy Khrushchev on the point....
- hga 12y ago"the long term effects based on nuclear winter etc. are arguable" Not really at this point, e.g. the TAPPS study has been thoroughly debunked (details on request), LLNL 3D modeling says at worst a "nuclear fall", which I note would be much on the order of or less severe than many historical volcanic events (see https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Year_Without_a_Summer https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Year_Without_a_Summer). All the way down to the life histories of those exposed to radiation by Hiroshima and Nagasaki: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Atomic_bombings_of_Hiroshima_and_Nagasaki#Hibakusha https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Atomic_bombings_of_Hiroshima_a... As for the latter point, would not e.g. the US, reduced to about a Civil War level of population etc., trade tasty technological things, and/or food with the U.K. and any other county easily accessed by ship? The death rate would certainly be a lot higher in the crowded and food importing U.K., but Threads sounds way too dystopic. I'm going by the Wikipedia summary, but it didn't sound like it had even Bronze Age levels of trade with other countries. One neat thing I've read as of late is that the tin for all the bronze used in the western half or more of the Mediterranean came from Britain. Apparently the Iron Age happened in part because of apparent disruption of that trade, iron weapons of that era weren't as good as the bronze state of the art, but they were cheaper. So e.g. a Roman solider would have an iron sword while his centurion and higher were more likely to have bronze.