11 ms·
>Bitcoin is the electronic version of "let's buy a lot of gold and stash it somewhere". It's even worse than that because normal people at least have a decent
by hueving 12y ago
>Bitcoin is the electronic version of "let's buy a lot of gold and stash it somewhere".
It's even worse than that because normal people at least have a decent idea of when their gold is secure. A non-techie just has to trust that the online bitcoin provider or author of the wallet is doing what he/she really says and in a secure fashion.
- tribaal 12y agoYou're completely right.
- tlrobinson 12y agoDedicated hardware wallets help to some extent, and they already exist and work (e.x. Trezor). It's hard for people to understand backups, security updates, "don't open that funny-cat-photos.exe file from your aunt", but easy to understand "if this device is lost or stolen, my money is gone" You have to trust the hardware (open source hardware/firmware will be an improvement), and verify addresses out of band (see https://medium.com/@octskyward/why-you-think-the-pki-sucks-b64cf5912aa7 https://medium.com/@octskyward/why-you-think-the-pki-sucks-b... for solutions), but otherwise you can safely use it on even a malware infested computer. As a bonus, it can be protected by a pin (with firmware-enforced rate limits). And backups of the seed can be made in case the hardware wallet is stolen/lost/destroyed. They can even be split up using Shamir's Secret Sharing. (Eventually mobile devices will be able to accomplish the same thing. You could imagine a more advanced version of Apple's "Secure Enclave" that presents the user with a UI (rendered by the Secure Enclave coprocessor) to authorize transactions)
- facepalm 12y agoActually I find the problem of stashing gold very tricky. A bank vault seems like a bad idea because of the history when the government seized the gold and people weren't allowed to open their bank safes without a policeman. Hiding it at home seems risky because of burglaries. I haven't found a solution yet, that's why I don't own any gold. With bitcoin, at least I can spread the risk, like putting a part of the "secret" into a bank vault, hide part at home, at a friends house, whatever. The risk of a simultaneous burglary in two unrelated houses seems low.
- hueving 12y agoUnless you had a virus on your computer when you generated the keys, in which case it doesn't matter.
- tlrobinson 12y agoSee my comment about hardware wallets: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8885114 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8885114 For the truly paranoid you could even generate your seed using coin flips or dice rolls... http://www.swansontec.com/bitcoin-dice.html http://www.swansontec.com/bitcoin-dice.html
- facepalm 12y agoNo that is relatively easy to circumvent by creating the keys offline. The cold storage key never needs to get in contact with the internet.
- tribaal 12y agoThat's exactly why I think it won't see more than marginal adoption. The benefits of bitcoin are outweight by having to secure your private key(s) yourself.
- simonh 12y agoYou can do exactly the same thing with gold, i.e. holding it in different banks in different regulatory districts. If your friend's house is burgled or burned down. The one advantage of Bitcoin in this respect is that you can back it up in case of disk failure, house burning down, etc.
- tlrobinson 12y agoThat's different than using Shamir's Secret Sharing [1] to split the private key/seed across multiple safe deposit boxes. If one safe deposit box full of gold is stolen, that portion of the gold is gone. If a safe deposit box containing 1/5th of a Shamir's Secret Sharing secret is stolen, the secret can't be reconstructed by the thief, but can be reconstructed by the owner if they still have access to 3 of the 5 pieces (for example). [1] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Shamir's_Secret_Sharing http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Shamir's_Secret_Sharing