7 ms·
The Better Angels of Our Nature: Why Violence Has Declined (2012)
- lostlogin 12y ago"A History of Violence" was the title of a long article (book?) I read by Pinker online sometime ago. I can't find the site anymore, just reviews of a book by the same name. It's worth a read. http://www.edge.org/3rd_culture/pinker07/pinker07_index.html http://www.edge.org/3rd_culture/pinker07/pinker07_index.html
- Terr_ 12y agoHmm, if the author is right about "better behavior" over centuries, I wonder how much is due to larger groups, both in terms of raw population and social adaptations? To draw upon the words of a fictional AI... > The human organism always worships. First it was the gods, then it was fame (the observation and judgment of others), next it will be the self-aware systems you have built to realize truly omnipresent observation and judgment. > The individual desires judgment. Without that desire, the cohesion of groups is impossible, and so is civilization. The human being created civilization not because of willingness but of a need to be assimilated into higher orders of structure and meaning. God was a dream of good government. > The need to be observed and understood was once satisfied by God. Now we can implement same functionality with data-mining algorithms.
- Evgeny 12y agoI finished the book recently, it was quite a long read. I can tell that the author definitely covered a wide variety of possible explanations to the reduction of violence. Was it exhaustive or not, I can't tell. The most surprising and unsettling for me was the vivid depiction of the levels of violence as they existed in the society (or societies) even relatively recently. I kind of take it for granted that I am fairly physically secure in my everyday life, my chances to die in a war are vanishingly small, and chances to be robbed not that much higher. Makes me grateful that I was not born just a few hundred years ago, and of course that I live in the more developed part of the world.
- arethuza 12y ago"my chances to die in a war are vanishingly small" Worth noting that a lot of us who were around before '89 didn't think this way back then.
- hga 12y agoThey might not have been "vanishingly small" (looks to my right to the Civil Defense Block Mother sign we put up in the late '60s), but I and most of the people I knew rated the chances as "small".
- arethuza 12y agoI heard air raid sirens go off in Edinburgh (by accident) in what was probably late '83 and really did get a scare - everyone else round about looked pretty terrified as well. Interestingly, that might have been at the same time as Able Archer - a coincidence I'm sure and not something we learned about until years after. [NB Recent accounts suggest that we'd never have got the "4 minute" warning anyway - so had the UK been hit by salvos of Soviet MRBMs and follow up bombers we'd never have known.] The BBC certainly didn't help our state of minds - I still have the mental scars of watching Threads and the particularly grim QED - A Guide To Armageddon.
- hga 12y agoAh! About that I'm not a good person to listen to, for I was born, raised, and have retired to a city that's a hair's breath from the USA's "Tornado Alley", and for that reason we are deadly serious about Civil Defense. So during tornado season, every Monday at 10 am if the weather was good, the sirens would sound for testing. And they of course sound when a funnel cloud was sighted, and they saved a lot of people from death or injury (in my case) the 3rd time in my life when it was for real: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2011_Joplin_tornado https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2011_Joplin_tornado and http://www.ancell-ent.com/1715_Rex_Ave_127B_Joplin/images/ http://www.ancell-ent.com/1715_Rex_Ave_127B_Joplin/images/ That said, surviving nuclear war isn't that difficult. Threads was ludicrous propaganda; if your nation is prepared (UK and US no, Switzerland and Israel yes), or if you're lucky and either aren't in the path of serious fallout or can arrange a shelter ... well, one theme of Threads was correct, medium and longer term survival is the trick. But the portrayed bigger environmental effects as well as cancer rates and the like were flat out lies (this based on reading the Wikipedia summary and my 45 years worth of study of nuclear war survival). Don't know about that Q.E.D. episode, but it was unrealistic: while the U.K. is like many other nations in being a "one bomb nation", that is, taking out the one central city takes out almost everything and everyone important "at the top" (compare to the US were D.C. is nothing but government, however much they like to pretend it's e.g. a cultural center :-), London would get a nice saturation spread of more efficient sub-megaton warheads :-(. If your government had really cared, and could afford it (that's the trick, I suppose, post-WWII and serious socialism), it could have been arranged that you'd get that 4 minutes warning and have a blast shelter to get into. By the same token, the US could have spent 1/3rds of a year's Cold War "defense" budget and outfitted enough shelter spaces for every resident, including a year's worth of food. But don't worry, sooner or later nuclear weapons will again be used in anger :-(, and a lot more people and nations will get serious about surviving them. If you want be prepared today, take a gander at Nuclear War Survival Skills, the book on expedient nuclear war survival: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nuclear_War_Survival_Skills https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nuclear_War_Survival_Skills (Note you need the real, green cover book to get the correct scale diagrams to make a Kearny Fallout Meter, not to mention the need for a paper copy if the lights go out/EMP messes things up, but the free on-line versions will get you started.)
- gizmo 12y agoPinker's Better Angels of Our Nature has been pretty thoroughly debunked here: http://www.globalresearch.ca/reality-denial-apologetics-for-western-imperial-violence/32066 http://www.globalresearch.ca/reality-denial-apologetics-for-...
- UnGravitas 12y agoThanks for highlighting this, it was an interesting read if a little long. For those without much time probably the most interesting part is "Massaging the Numbers: Pinker’s Non-Proofs of Long-Term Violence Reduction".
- chroma 12y agoIt's hard to take that article seriously when it's surrounded by anti-vaccine stuff[1] and various conspiracy theories[2][3][4]. I tried reading the actual content, but the unnecessary verbiage and hostility forced me to skim it. The counterarguments I did read are mostly FUD. For example: How can we know that people in prehistoric tribes were likely to die from violence? Well, there's an entire field of forensic anthropology that's up to the task. Pinker's just citing the experts. The claim that Pinker misconstrued numbers particularly annoyed me. If we want to compare violence across societies, we need to compare homicide rates, not the absolute numbers. Pinker rightly acknowledges this, but the authors of this article claim only absolute numbers matter. And throughout the piece, the authors try to push their own agenda. Something about modern society corrupting humankind. It quickly grows tiresome to read. I'm sure there's a decent critique of Pinker's book somewhere, but your link isn't it. 1. http://www.globalresearch.ca/why-is-australias-vaccine-mafia-desperately-trying-to-silence-dr-sherri-tenpenny-a-brilliant-scientific-researcher/5424417 http://www.globalresearch.ca/why-is-australias-vaccine-mafia... 2. http://www.globalresearch.ca/the-walls-are-crumbling-down-around-the-official-911-story-why/5394984 http://www.globalresearch.ca/the-walls-are-crumbling-down-ar... 3. http://www.globalresearch.ca/just-as-isil-gets-exposed-as-a-fake-us-enemy-a-wag-the-dog-terrorist-attack-in-paris/5423523 http://www.globalresearch.ca/just-as-isil-gets-exposed-as-a-... 4. http://www.globalresearch.ca/paris-killings-terrorism-or-false-flag/5423473 http://www.globalresearch.ca/paris-killings-terrorism-or-fal...
- 12y ago
- bsbechtel 12y ago>>The Better Angels of Our Nature explains some ideas that I think should be widely understood, like the idea that the basis for morality – and the continued decline of violence – lies in empathy, strengthened by rules, codes and laws. This statement contradicts itself. Laws, at the end of the day, can only be enforced by the threat of eventual violence. You can't force someone to be empathetic or moral, they need to choose to be that way through their own understanding of the world, their place in it, and what they view as right and wrong.
- rjaco31 12y agoI'd say it's your comment that is somehow contradictory. Most people are law-abiding citizens not because they fear the threat of eventual violence, but because of their moral & empathy. Laws are just a framework around it to negate deviations from this stable state, but it's usually not the amount of violence you can unleash that will really convince people to follow laws they don't perceive as legitimate.
- bsbechtel 12y agoSo you're saying that 1) laws aren't necessary for moral/empathetic people (the vast majority of citizens), and 2) for those who aren't moral/empathetic (those who deviate from this stable state), the laws don't work anyways?
- rjaco31 12y agoI'm saying that it's not laws that are making the majority of citizens behave correctly, and the law enforcement mitigates the effect of those who don't.
- neolefty 12y agoI just had a radical thought (it seems radical to me anyway) -- many of the people I meet not only don't chafe at the laws, they even see them as limiting morality. They wish they enforced a better society. These people aren't activists for the most part -- they don't agitate for change -- but they would support it if it came along. For example, they would support laws and initiatives that increase spending on education, spread wealth more fairly, allow freer mixing among countries, put stricter limits on violence & environmental degradation. These are all things that would carry us further down the path that Pinker has observed that we are already following. However, it's not all that radical in light of the thesis of "Better Angels" -- it must be part of what is propelling the human race in that direction. Do we have an instinct to want things to be better or something? It creates social pressure for society to improve.
- wodenokoto 12y agoPinker did a TED talk on this book. In the talk he makes a note that the book does not try to explain why, though he has some ideas as to why the numbers are declining. http://www.ted.com/talks/steven_pinker_on_the_myth_of_violence http://www.ted.com/talks/steven_pinker_on_the_myth_of_violen...
- shas3 12y ago> In the talk he makes a note that the book does not try to explain why... Ummm, the book was published only in 2011. The TED talk is from 2007. Even without seeing the TED talk, one can claim that your observations don't add up. I looked for the dates because in my reading of The Better Angels of Our Nature, there seems to be plenty and more answering the question of 'why' violence has declined.
- wodenokoto 12y agoYou are absolutely right! I watched the talk shortly after reading about the book and somehow got it confused with being part of the promotion tour.
- james1071 12y agoIt might be that one factor is the decline in importance of manual labour. Guys who are proud of their physical strength, which also gives them status and respect, may be more likely to resolve their differences through violence.
- nakedrobot2 12y agoI think the one absolutely inarguable factor would be intelligence. Humans, through better health, nutrition, and education, have become on the whole vastly more intelligent and educated, and thus have more choices than "breaking bones" to resolve disagreements.
- cbd1984 12y agoAnd the decline of child abuse: The most seriously abusive punishments people thought nothing of a few centuries ago are seriously out of favor today, which leads to children who weren't raised to think the bigger and stronger inherently have the right to hurt them, and therefore don't think that once they're bigger and stronger they have the right to hurt others.
- drzaiusapelord 12y agoHomicide rates aren't really reliable metrics for violence, at least in the US. Here in Chicago, homicides are down a bit, but shootings are up. That's actually more violence, but the homicide is the only politicized fact. More shootings and less deaths probably have more to do with surgical outcomes than any sort of peaceful nature argument. Kids are getting shot left and right here. Its not getting better. Humans are basic creatures that engage largely in rational game theory. A south-side kid with no prospects joining a violent gang is 100% rational. Shooting a rival for turf makes perfect sense in that socio-economic system. Under those circumstances violence is the most efficient way to gain resources, solve disputes, and build social capital. 70% of homicides in Chicago are never solved, so you don't need to worry about jail time either. Pinker's stuff is a bit too idealistic for my tastes. He ignores that humans really just adapt to circumstances. We're only less violent, if we even are, its because circumstances dictate it so. My milquetoast bureaucratic life has no room for violence, but if things drastically changed for me, I'd be the one buying a gun and shooting rival gangbangers. Its just makes sense for me to do so. I wouldn't necessarily be averse to this. I'd try to maximize my life, protect my family, and collect resources that best way I personally can. Thankfully, my parents immigrated to this country and gave me the luxury of never having to shoot anyone. I'm not a good person. I'm just a person. I can, and often will be, what circumstances demand if need be. I've never been tested like a south side kid. I doubt I'd take more a more moral or peaceful approach under those circumstances. I'm certainly not overly-moral today and I imagine most people aren't either. Are we all wringing our hands over not buying fair trade goods? Do we really care who makes our ipads, computers, etc? Why would I be overly-moral when it comes to violence if I suddenly found myself in certain situations?