12 ms·
None of Google Domain's features are novel. In fact the article spent most of its time talking about an up-sell. Which isn't to say Google Domain isn't a good p
by Someone1234 12y ago
None of Google Domain's features are novel. In fact the article spent most of its time talking about an up-sell. Which isn't to say Google Domain isn't a good product, just that we now should look at price because nothing else seems interesting...
~ Google Domains charges $12/year for .COM, .NET, .ORG.
~ NameCheap charges $10.69/year for .COM, $11.98/year for .NET, and $11.48/year for .ORG. Sometimes with an 18c/year fee tacked on.
~ GoDaddy charges $12.99-13.99 for a .COM but that might increase randomly because they're scumbags.
So my point is that this article claims that everyone is "rushing" to this new product, and while this product doesn't seem "bad" it also isn't exactly market changing. The prices are well within 10% of the market (sometimes higher, sometimes lower) and the features are pretty generic also.
Can someone explain why Google Domains is compelling and not a "me too!" product?
- rpedela 12y agoPrivate registration usually costs extra, but not with Google domains. That is a compelling reason to me. I also like the clean interface, some of the other vendors have horrible interfaces.
- rndn 12y agoWhat is private registration?
- blfr 12y agoRegistration without revealing your private information in the whois database. Providers usually put their own details there and forward emails to the end user. Depending on the registry, it's unavailable or at least against the rules for some tlds.
- wnevets 12y ago.us for example prohibits it.
- nly 12y ago> Depending on the registry, it's unavailable or at least against the rules for some tlds. And yet other TLD registries are sensible enough to make privacy the default for private individuals. .EU isn't bad in this regard, and others like .SE even go so far as to hide your name (most only hide your postal, email, telephone) Frankly I don't know why anyone who can avoid it would want to touch Verisign TLDs with a barge pole... they have the continued gall to keep putting their prices up despite more competition than ever, and fail to raise the bar on basics like whois protection. Even .UK domains can be had for $5/year with registry level whois protection for heavens sake.
- MichaelApproved 12y agoIt's an add-on service that domain registrars offer which hides your personal information from the public. When you register a domain, it's a requirements that you list contact information publicly. Companies usually don't mind doing this but many people don't want to list their home address and phone number for the world to see. Private registration lists a proxy company's information as the contact for the domain and they forward the information to you.
- ewzimm 12y agoWith standard registration, the site is registered to you with ICANN. With private registration, it is registered to your registrar and you are provided access. Whois will show their info. Note that this means you are technically not the owner of the domain, and you may be limited in your ability to transfer it, sell it, or do other things with it. Permissions are limited to what the registrar allows instead of what ICANN allows, although in most cases they give you nearly full control. You'll just have to read their terms if you want to know what you can do with it.
- duskwuff 12y ago> Note that this means you are technically not the owner of the domain, and you may be limited in your ability to transfer it, sell it, or do other things with it. This is a myth. ICANN has published requirements on how private registrations must operate; ownership of the domain always goes to the paying owner, not the registrar.
- ewzimm 12y agoThat's interesting. Do you know where the requirements are published? I've read language recently from at least one registrar specifically stating that private registration prevents transfers to other registrars. Maybe this was before these new requirements were published.
- zippergz 12y agoIn my recent experience, private registration prevents transfers because you are unable to receive the email message that contains the code you need to complete the transfer. I am still able to transfer my domains, but I need to turn off private registration first, so the email is sent to my real email address. This seems like a silly problem, and one that the registrars cold solve if they wanted to, but obviously they don't.
- umurkontaci 12y agoI believe some of the registrars provide a rolling email address on your whois info, which forwards the mails to your inbox. But the address is changing at intervals, therefore if anybody scraped the address it won't be of use.
- tim333 12y agoIf you don't have private registration a whois query on the domain shows the public your name and address. If you do it shows some nominee company instead. For example https://who.is/whois/habinow.com https://who.is/whois/habinow.com is one of mine that is private while https://who.is/whois/ycombinator.com https://who.is/whois/ycombinator.com is pubic and shows Nicholas Sivo as the admin and an address and phone number for y combinator
- LeoPanthera 12y agoPrivate registration has always been free at gandi.net. Also they do not suck. https://www.gandi.net/domain/whois/ https://www.gandi.net/domain/whois/
- marincounty 12y agoYea, but their domain registion prices are high. I have always appreciated the honesty/integrity/simplicity of gandi though.
- martinml 12y agoYou might want to try NameSilo. Cheap, free privacy, 2FA, acceptable interface.
- markdown 12y agoA new provider? Us old timers stay away from those. Do you remember RegisterFly?
- StavrosK 12y agoOr NameTerrific.
- iancarroll 12y agoUniregistry is great but they have limited TLD support, sadly.
- tim333 12y agoI second NameSilo. $8.99/domain and so far that's it - no jacking the price on renewal etc.
- nly 12y ago$15-17 for .com/net/org, but as well as whois protection you also get a 1 year SSL cert. Unlike StartSSL, this includes fee-free revocation. Probably not worth much given that 'Lets Encrypt' is just around the corner, but it's still a respectable gesture. They also have a really good management UI, responsive customer support, free (roundcube) webmail, and DNSSEC management (Namecheap lacks this). Also, they're French, if you're feeling a bit US-wary lately.
- chhantyal 12y agoI ordered a domain recently on Namecheap, with free privation registration addon.
- Navarr 12y agoNamecheap is generally free WhoisGuard for a year on new registrations
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- Animats 12y agoPrivate registration on a business domain is a scumbag flag. Use it only for blogs and such.
- SiVal 12y agoI don't agree. I have a one-man online business, which means I can operate from home to save a lot of money, making it possible to charge less to my customers while still making a profit. I really would rather not have people who are angry at the business, for whatever reason, have easy access to my home address.
- sootzoo 12y agoThere's no requirement that you use your home address for registrars (or the IRS, for that matter). It's also not terribly expensive to get a PO Box/virtual office address, and if you're concerned about privacy then it sounds like it'd be worth it to you.
- Animats 12y agoIf you accept credit cards, and sell to people in California, you have committed a crime good for six months in prison. See http://www.leginfo.ca.gov/cgi-bin/displaycode?section=bpc&group=17001-18000&file=17530-17539.6 http://www.leginfo.ca.gov/cgi-bin/displaycode?section=bpc&gr... (d) A vendor conducting business through the Internet or any other electronic means of communication shall do all of the following when the transaction involves a buyer located in this state: (1) Before accepting any payment or processing any debit or credit charge or funds transfer, the vendor shall disclose to the buyer in writing or by electronic means of communication, such as e-mail or an on-screen notice, the vendor's return and refund policy, the legal name under which the business is conducted and, except as provided in paragraph (3), the complete street address from which the business is actually conducted. (2) If the disclosure of the vendor's legal name and address information required by this subdivision is made by on-screen notice, all of the following shall apply: (A) The disclosure of the legal name and address information shall appear on any of the following: (i) the first screen displayed when the vendor's electronic site is accessed, (ii) on the screen on which goods or services are first offered, (iii) on the screen on which a buyer may place the order for goods or services, (iv) on the screen on which the buyer may enter payment information, such as a credit card account number, or (v) for nonbrowser-based technologies, in a manner that gives the user a reasonable opportunity to review that information. The communication of that disclosure shall not be structured to be smaller or less legible than the text of the offer of the goods or services. (B) The disclosure of the legal name and address information shall be accompanied by an adjacent statement describing how the buyer may receive the information at the buyer's e-mail address. The vendor shall provide the disclosure information to the buyer at the buyer's e-mail address within five days of receiving the buyer's request. (C) Until the vendor complies with subdivision (a) in connection with all buyers of the vendor's goods or services, the vendor shall make available to a buyer and any person or entity who may enforce this section pursuant to Section 17535 on-screen access to the information required to be disclosed under this subdivision. (g) Any violation of the provisions of this section is a misdemeanor punishable by imprisonment in the county jail not exceeding six months, by a fine not exceeding one thousand dollars ($1,000), or by both that imprisonment and fine.
- aptwebapps 12y agoIt's free on Dreamhost. I don't use them for hosting anymore, but still keep a few domains there. 10 bucks a year for .coms. The interface is ... almost ok. It's cluttered because it's used for more than just domain registration (think it's cPanel, actually) but the registration part is ok.
- ecesena 12y agoI found the console way better than Gandi, that I was using before. A few other integrations are simpler and quicker, such as creating email forwards. It seems also really well integrated with Google Cloud, but that's only relatively useful :) Edit: oh, and it's fast to update, especially if you use Google as DNS server as I do.
- Navarr 12y agoAlso automatically verifies ownership in Google Webmaster tools - which is really nice
- jaimeyap 12y agoI believe when you add whois guard to NameCheap, it actually comes out a little more than Google Domains, which I think offers free private registration.
- tamar 12y agoNot if you use a coupon code. Try WGSPECIAL. Oh, and if you renew for several years at a time, the cost per year goes down too. Disclosure: Namecheap employee
- anigbrowl 12y agoNo offense to you or your firm, but fuck coupon codes. When I go to Trader Joe's for groceries, I work out what I want to eat and note the prices. When I make one of the occasional trips to Safeway I spend half my time trying to match up what I went there to buy with the particular coupon that's running this week or that my wife added to loyalty card, and more time attempting to decrypt my receipt after I get home to see if I succeeded. Coupons are just a way of creating psychological anxiety about missing a good deal, an archetypal 'dark pattern'. That sort of thing actively drives people like me away from your business. I know I'm not a mainstream consumer, but IMHO neither is the average domain registrant.
- tamar 12y agoYou can say that to any firm then. Given our razor thin profit margins, the pricing is there for a reason. The coupon codes are also there simply to sweeten the deal. Bear in mind the products we're mostly represent cost a low $10. If we had more wiggle room on pricing, we'd offer low pricing all the time. It's just not feasible for a business like ours to do 24/7.
- anigbrowl 12y agoWhat I'm saying is that I am more quality- and convenience- sensitive than I am price-sensitive. Not because I'm rich, but because the mental overhead of coupon deals etc. carries a cost that typically exceeds the saving on the coupon. If you make the service sufficiently attractive, you can raise your prices. Admittedly this is a bit challenging when your firm is branded as 'namecheap' in order to attract the most price-conscious consumers, but companies can and do rebrand themselves. I mean, Google is charging more than you, and it's not like they couldn't win a price war if they were so inclined - they could probably sell domains for $1/year without significant damage to their bottom line. Maybe it's time to get out of the 'cheap' box.
- nostromo 12y agoOne of the headaches of setting up a domain is getting the email sorted correctly. Instant integration to Gmail is a nice feature. If you want privacy protection on your whois lookups, then Google would be cheaper than the other providers, as they sell it as an add-on. I also trust Google to have speedy DNS servers, if you're leaving the defaults in place. GoDaddy's DNS can be quite slow. Perhaps not a "mind-blowing" product, but one I'd consider using.
- adrianlmm 12y ago>then Google would be cheaper than the other providers, as they sell it as an add-on Godaddy also sells this as an addon, actually, every domain seller does, I don't know what is so special about Google's offert.
- kevinoconnor7 12y agoIt's included with Google. Thus if it's something you use (and most people do), then Google's pricing is very competitive for domains.
- DomKM 12y agoNameSilo includes whois privacy and is cheaper than any alternative (.com is $9/domain).
- crdoconnor 12y ago>One of the headaches of setting up a domain is getting the email sorted correctly. Instant integration to Gmail is a nice feature. name.com has had that for years. Click a button and it configures all the MX records for you and a few CNAMES on top (so you can do stuff like mail.yourdomain.com and calendar.yourdomain.com).
- MichaelApproved 12y agoI think this product is about filling a hole in their lineup of products, more than it is supposed to be innovative itself. The other products are innovative, this supplements those products. They no longer have to send people across the street for this critical part of hosting and can also easily integrate it with their other services, such as gmail forwarding.
- foolfoolz 12y agothey do include private whois, and X subdomains for your domain, X emails available... but game changing would include SSL for all, or free hosting from your google drive - even if it was just static content. it's a classic google "me too" project. i always get the feeling a lot of google projects come up because someone somewhere is going to be in a high level meeting with execs, and one exec sees something interesting and asks "why aren't we doing this?" and then someone gets to chime in "we already are!" and then they check the box for DONE and never look back.
- zrm 12y ago> game changing would include SSL for all Let's Encrypt is going to be doing that later this year anyway. https://www.eff.org/deeplinks/2014/11/certificate-authority-encrypt-entire-web https://www.eff.org/deeplinks/2014/11/certificate-authority-... https://letsencrypt.org/ https://letsencrypt.org/
- Thaxll 12y agoAlso knowing that they are managing their nameserver the google way.
- blfr 12y agoSecurity and convenience. It's tied to a Google Account which I already have and offers the same level of protection.
- rictic 12y agoThe primary reason I use it is to have two factor authentication defending my domains. [disclosure: Google employee]
- akadien 12y agoNamecheap has 2FA.
- StavrosK 12y agoIt has a weird SMS-based TFA thing, not the far more widespread TOTP standard.
- corford 12y agoNo weirder than the one used by Dyn or Paypal. Click a button, receive an SMS with a code, enter the code and login. Voila.
- StavrosK 12y ago> No weirder than the one used by Dyn or Paypal That doesn't make it non-weird. Obligatory Godwin, "meh, Hitler was no more horrible than Stalin or Pol Pot."
- smcquaid 12y ago
- larrys 12y ago"and not a "me too!" product?" It doesn't have to be anything more than a "me to" product. Noting that if you google "domains" they now come up as the 2nd organic link. Nice to be king, eh? Edit: I own a registrar and we compete with them (if you want to call it that). Obviously I am just referring to the fact that they can instantly rank high with what amounts to a beta product hence the "king" comment. Of course they need to be more than "me to" but that ranking goes a long way in getting them business even if they do very little.
- icebraining 12y agoNoting that if you google "domains" they now come up as the 2nd organic link. They come up as the 2nd for you. Google Search results are personalized. It's 6th in mine, behind Hostgator.
- larrys 12y agoGood point but checking kproxy proxy they are coming up 2nd ahead of godaddy for "domains". (Same with zend2.com proxy).
- poopsintub 12y agoIt's not compelling, it just fills the gap, as mentioned. It gives them more info to adjust their search algorithms and weed out bad apples imo. Now they know who has registered even private domains. Make an inadvertent "bad move" on one domain/site, and they will be killing traffic to everything you own.
- jedc 12y agoI've been a beta-tester of Google Domains for months, and it's just such a nicer experience than GoDaddy/Namecheap. Particularly with GoDaddy, I feel like there's always a chance I'm going to click on the wrong thing and then get subscribed to some ridiculous service. With Google, it's a clean, transparent, USABLE interface. I'd encourage people to try it out with a domain and form your own views. As for me, I'm moving all of my domains over to Google (as they get close to renewal.)
- tamar 12y agoHey jedc - Tamar from Namecheap here. Can you provide insights into the Namecheap experience? I hear the GD side. Would like to know what you mean from ours. As far as our dashboard, we're building a better user experience, so that's nothing to fret about. I bet you'd agree when it's live that the experience is far more stellar than anything you'd find anywhere else.
- yzzxy 12y agoHere's some feedback: your 2FA experience is terrible. I appreciate that you use 2FA, but I have to hit the send button multiple times to get a text message every single time on my US mobile phone. After that the form fails 50% of the time. I also find it frustrating that the domain dashboard has no clear path to my host record settings, which is 90% of the use case for me. I always have to click four or five times to find it. Otherwise I love the product and pricing, and I will probably continue to use Namecheap in the future.
- tamar 12y agoWell, that's all fair and all stuff we're addressing this year. The dashboard is, frankly, out of date compared to the UI experience people would expect from us in 2015. We're building that right now. And we plan to support TOTP 2FA, so you don't necessarily have to rely on SMS at all. But noted. Just wait -- we've got some pretty cool things in store for you.
- 12y ago
- kolev 12y agoI pay $8.19/.com with GoDaddy with the Domain Club - nobody can touch their prices, but GoDaddy doesn't have an API and according to their account executives I spoke to, they won't offer one anytime soon.
- waylandsmithers 12y agoSomething about Google feels more trustworthy to me than all the other registrars, so that's new.
- arfliw 12y agoTrust in the brand is negated for me by the fact that if this doesn't go well, I know they'll just shut it down or neglect it in a year or two. You want to know your registrar will be there in 10 years.
- billconan 12y agoit looks to me that google has run out of ideas.
- 6t6t6 12y agoBecause once they have the Credit Card number from a customer it is extremely easier to sell him other products. That's quite the Google way, they are not looking for the one-time immediate profit, but for customers that will somehow generate income in the long term. It seems it's not working bad for them.
- eunice 12y agothe innovation is 'united states only'
- DonnyV 12y ago2 words....Dynamic DNS
- arfliw 12y agoNameCheap and GoDaddy are two expensive options. There are many registrars where you can get .com's for under $10. $12 is really expensive...
- readme 12y agoNamecheap includes WhoisGuard with all their domains for those prices, so they're even LOWER than they seem. It seems to me that Google is just trying to throw their enormous weight into every space now and it sickens me. This is how we end up with mediocre goods and services... No thanks Google. They are much, much more than a monopoly at this point. Not to mention, with Namecheap, GoDaddy or really any other company, you can probably get ahold of tech support 24/7. Good luck getting that from Google... Not that I've tried yet, but my experience with them in the past has been that it's mission impossible to talk to a human being in charge of something there, unless you're trying to hangout with the devs on Google+ or something for smalltalk, which seems to always be available.
- shurcooL 12y agoFor me, and I think many others, the main advantage is a simple, sane UI. It just works, no surprises.