4 ms·
> Do I have this right? You're missing an important detail - this is nothing new. Banks have always borrowed money from the US govt (and others) at X% and loa
by anamax 17y ago
> Do I have this right?
You're missing an important detail - this is nothing new.
Banks have always borrowed money from the US govt (and others) at X% and loaned it at Y%, where X < Y. (There's no point in that arrangement if X >= Y.)
- monos 17y agothis is probably trivial economics but it always eluded me: when the govt is giving out amount X money, and wants amount X + INTERESTX back. how can that work? where should INTERESTX come from when they only gave us X?
- vitaminj 17y agoNon-government deposit banks are legally allowed to create money (up to some reserve ratio).
- vetinari 17y agoTime. The govt gives out X/year, not the final amount X. When they want it back, it comes from different 'tranches'. This ensures, that there is always debt. Money has value only if there is debt and you must use some to get out of it. Why would you need it otherwise?
- eru 17y agoAnd the Fed gives its `profits' back to the government to spend. The ECB does the same (perhaps more roundabout).
- aaronblohowiak 17y agoWith risk. What is the risk in buying US bonds?
- dandelany 17y agoThat the USD is increasingly worthless in the world economy.
- Confusion 17y agoThat has nothing to do with the security of a US government bond.
- deleted 17y ago[deleted]
- Xichekolas 17y agoWhy not? US bonds are redeemed for US dollars. If the dollar becomes increasingly worthless, why would you want to hold the bond? Granted, I think saying the dollar is "becoming increasingly worthless" is being hyperbolic.
- aaronblohowiak 17y agoNo, because the loans have to be repaid in USD. The only "risk" then is the opportunity cost of not investing in other capital classes.
- mynameishere 17y agoThe banks are borrowing short and lending long. There is a significant principle risk. If treasury yields spike up, the banks will take a bath.
- Xichekolas 17y agoBanks traditionally borrow short and lend long (savings accounts fund mortgages for instance). That is the risk they assume and what we pay them for. But in this case, they seem to be borrowing long and lending short (or at least borrowing short and lending short). It's not like the government is going to go demand it's money back like someone with a savings account is free to do. And really, would you take $200k to the bank and deposit it at 0.5% interest and then take out a $200k mortgage at 6%? You might if you were concerned about liquidity (unsteady income?) and could get at the $200k in savings when you needed to. But if you didn't have that flexibility, it wouldn't make sense.
- bitdiddle 17y agoexactly, and normally they borrow from other banks rather than the Fed, which the fed prefers. I believe the Fed only serves as the lender of last resort. The carry trade is nothing new either, it's often used for example when borrowing rates in other countries are favorable compared to rates on US treasuries.