4 ms·
> This is a flawed, Marxist labor theory of value that can't explain why an artisanally-made handbag that takes 120 man-hours to produce still is valued less th
by pastProlog 12y ago
> This is a flawed, Marxist labor theory of value that can't explain why an artisanally-made handbag that takes 120 man-hours to produce still is valued less than a Coach/Prada/LV handbag that was machine-manufactured with no human labor.
Certainly it can explain it. The bespoke handbag has the labor of manufacturing done in one place, the machine-manufactured handbag has the labor of manufacturing done in two places - the place of manufacture and the place where the machine was manufactured.
The "Marxist" labor theory of value was held by Benjamin Franklin, Adam Smith and all of the pre-Marxist political economists I know of. It is also a theory you seem to know little about as you're constructing a false, strawman notion of what LTV is and then knocking it down. Not that you're alone in this, I've read Paul Krugman attribute theories to the LTV which its proponents never had, so as to, like you, knock down the strawman theories. I honestly believe he is doing it out of ignorance as opposed to malice.
Actually, like all economic theories, the LTV does have holes which serious critics have pointed out. You don't seem to know what those are though.
- notahacker 12y agoI'd warrant the girl quoted in the article's view of "it's the labour that matters" is a lot closer to Marxist normative view of the significance of the LTV, than Smith's notion that the exchange value of a particular good should under normal circumstances be broadly equivalent to the cost of the labour to get someone else to make a new good instead. (Not that Smith's notion exchange value is much use for valuing designer handbags, mind you.) The additional Marxian "embedded labour" in the sewing machines and even the ad agencies reponsible for building brand equity doesn't even get close to identifying why Prada handbags cost more than artisanally made ones though...
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]