4 ms·
I'm confused about how precedent works in this kind of case. Generally, the precedent that a particular court must follow in a case is the rulings of courts th
by tzs 12y ago
I'm confused about how precedent works in this kind of case.
Generally, the precedent that a particular court must follow in a case is the rulings of courts that its ruling in the case can be appealed to. So, a California district court has to follow 9th Circuit precedent in a copyright case, because it will be the 9th Circuit appeals court that gets the case on appeal. The California district court does not have to follow, say, 2nd Circuit precedent, because the case will not ever reach the 2nd Circuit appeals court.
For a patent case, the path is a little different. All patent appeals go to the Court of Appeals for the Federal Circuit (CAFC) rather then to the Circuit appeals courts. Thus, a California district court hearing a patent case follows CAFC precedent, because that's where the case will go on appeal.
The Oracle-Google case is both copyright and patent. Because of the patent aspect, the appeal from the district court went to the CAFC. Although a copyright appeal would not go to CAFC on its own, CAFC is allowed to handle it when it is part of a patent case. Thus, we end up with the CAFC issuing a copyright ruling.
What I do not understand is which courts have to take the CAFC copyright ruling as precedent.
Suppose I sue someone over copyright in California, and suppose there are no patent issues anywhere near the case...it's just a pure copyright case. The appeal then will go to the 9th Circuit appeals court, not to CAFC, so does the district court in this case have to follow CAFC's Oracle ruling? Or do they look strictly to what the 9th Circuit has said?
Given the theoretical basis for precedent, I'd expect that the district court follows the 9th Circuit.
If that's the case, suppose that the defendant would really prefer to operate under CAFC copyright precedent rather than 9th Circuit copyright precedent. Could he try to add a patent counterclaim, so that the appeal would go to CAFC, and so the district court would have to follow CAFC precedent? Would I have a reasonable chance under FRCP Rule 42 to ask for separate trials on the copyright and patent issues?