40 ms·
How to raise successful children
- swombat 12y agoRead only the first couple of sections. Seemed like a pretty terrible article. Maybe there's some sort of insight hiding somewhere in there, but it's well disguised. Skip.
- tokenadult 12y agoAnother top-level comment asks, Is anyone willing to contribute insight or actionable information in the interest of a better discussion? The article is steadily climbing the front page, so this is clearly a popular topic. I'll put in an edit to my first comment here to answer that question. This is advice based on the research I did as I brought up four children, beginning in 1992: 1) The book The First Three Years of Life[A] by the late Burton White is a good book about child development. His perspective on how (to use the title of another of his books[B]) to raise a happy, unspoiled child is helpful for parents. 2) Be open to shopping for educational choices. Don't assume the school down the street will do a good job, no matter where you live. We have mostly been homeschoolers as our children have grown up, and our firstborn sent me a very kind email on Father's Day two years ago telling me he is glad I did that. He still thinks so two years later. 3) The book The Optimistic Child[C] by Martin E. P. Seligman is good for teaching children how to deal with inevitable problems and setbacks of human life. 4) The book Mindset[D] by Carol Dweck is a very good book on helping young people and people of all ages to maximize their abilities. We have seen wonderful results from "growth mindset" with our two younger children, who are young enough not to have known any other mindset in our household. 5) Develop a network of parents who are your close friends--close enough friends to be real with and to vent with when parenting becomes challenging. It's too easy for parents to isolate themselves by wanting to keep up a show of not having challenges in their parenting. [A] http://www.amazon.com/New-First-Three-Years-Life/dp/0684804190 http://www.amazon.com/New-First-Three-Years-Life/dp/06848041... [B] http://www.amazon.com/Raising-Unspoiled-Parents-Develop-Secure/dp/0684801345/ http://www.amazon.com/Raising-Unspoiled-Parents-Develop-Secu... [C] http://www.amazon.com/Optimistic-Child-Safeguard-Depression-Resilience/dp/0618918094/ http://www.amazon.com/Optimistic-Child-Safeguard-Depression-... [D] http://www.amazon.com/Mindset-Psychology-Success-Carol-Dweck/dp/0345472322/ http://www.amazon.com/Mindset-Psychology-Success-Carol-Dweck... Having written that, I'm open for more discussion. What's below is my original comment on the submitted article. Here is the gist of the article, in the author's own words: "I think a lot about parenting. Last year, I moved to the D.C. area after 16 years in Oregon. Although I grew up on the East Coast, I hadn’t been immersed in the competitive parenting scene since I left home for college. But since my husband and I returned, I’ve caught myself fretting over whether enrolling my daughter in the “right” activities — sports or academic enrichment? Karate or Odyssey of the Mind? Or both? — will guarantee her entrance into a good college and success in life. "I don’t have time to talk about parenting with the moms of my daughter’s friends, and, besides, they’re all going through the same thing I am. I started thinking about the people who have raised successful children, and I wanted to explore how they did it." She then relates anecdotes about various families she has encountered, who have had children who appear to be successful by differing definitions of success. Good for them. As a parent myself (four children, one grown up and launched into adult life, and three still in my care in my household), I thought I might see some actionable information here, but I really didn't. The experiences of the families described in the article differ enough from mine that even after reading the whole article, I will seek other sources of advice on how to continually refine my parenting. Collections of anecdotes like this suffer from problems that everyone who reads Hacker News knows about, and anecdotes about effective parenting suffer from one more problem that a lot of people miss. Any collection of anecdotes suffers from sample bias: how do we know that these families are representative of the many millions of other families who have either unsuccessful or successful children? A collection of anecdotes about people who reach some defined endpoint suffers from "survivorship bias,"[1] the tendency to look only at what the people who reach the endpoint have in common, without looking at how they differ from people who drop out of the competition to reach that endpoint. Maybe we have no idea, after looking at the successful, if any of their characteristics really make them different from the unsuccessful. A powerful mistake in many studies of parenting is not setting up a genetically sensitive design for the study. All human beings everywhere have systematic similarities with all other human beings everywhere. But in the aspects of human life that show individual variation, usually people resemble close relatives more than they resemble random members of all humanity. If some individual differences contribute to success, and some do not, we may have observations of children who become successful not because their parents parented well, but because their parents passed on genes for success to the children. Any correlation between parent behaviors and child outcomes has to be tested for whether or not it arises from genetic similarity. (The study designs that help tease out these issues, but do NOT fully resolve them, involve including observations of identical twins and adopted children--and at best identical twins adopted into different adoptive households, who are rare--to separate upbringing influences from biological inheritance influences.) Children resemble their parents sometimes more than parents wish. [1] http://youarenotsosmart.com/2013/05/23/survivorship-bias/ http://youarenotsosmart.com/2013/05/23/survivorship-bias/ http://rationalwiki.org/wiki/Survivorship_bias http://rationalwiki.org/wiki/Survivorship_bias http://www.businessweek.com/articles/2014-08-11/success-stories-how-survivorship-bias-tricks-entrepreneurs http://www.businessweek.com/articles/2014-08-11/success-stor...
- sogen 12y agoHuge thanks, specially since we'll be parents in june Regards
- brc 12y agoI found the article to be of low value as well, partly because of anecdata and partly because it wasn't clear to me how any of the profiled were really 'successful'. Really what would be more useful is in finding the turnaround stories - examples where parents have been on a wrong path, and where their kids have started to fail, and where they changed their approach and succeeded with helping the children to succeed. And with this I don't mean where a parent escaped an abusive household or where someone kicked drugs and alcohol, but where a normal parent with relatively normal children managed to turn a child with little spark for life and zero achievements into one who was motivated and excited by possibility. In my extended family there are children I have watched grow up - some of these have been spectacularly successful, while others haven't managed to get traction on life. As both can be self-reinforcing negative or positive feedback loops, the interesting thing is finding out those small inputs that steer a growing child one way or another. I think these are often how we respond to external events (such as coping with criticism or failure) but also if we have developed self belief. For parents, knowing how best to help a child navigate these tricky waters is crucial. And the article doesn't help with any of that.
- mrfusion 12y agoI liked "mindset" but I don't remember getting any actionable parenting advice from it. Can you tell us how it affected your parenting?
- j_s 12y agoSo far (4 hours in) it seems the vocal portion of the HN brain trust would vote for removing the link and changing the title to a question... Is anyone willing to contribute insight or actionable information in the interest of a better discussion? The article is steadily climbing the front page, so this is clearly a popular topic. Parenting is a tough subject to discuss without resorting to anecdotes; I would be interested to hear what HN-ers have to add even if it wasn't particularly insightful or actionable!
- deeviant 12y agoTrending has little or no correlation with content quality (See: Linkbait) and as far as I can tell after reading about half the article and all of the comments, they seem spot on, it's a bad article. I think that is pretty valuable feedback...
- j_s 12y agoThanks for your input. I didn't intend to minimize the value of the feedback received so far; I look forward to seeing how HN can do better!
- ant6n 12y agoWho actually reads the article? ;-)
- suprgeek 12y agoA good Definition (from the article): "... Success is having an interesting life. "
- AnimalMuppet 12y ago... as long as you don't have the Chinese definition of "interesting life".
- swatow 12y agoThere is no Chinese curse of an "interesting life" or "interesting times" http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/May_you_live_in_interesting_times http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/May_you_live_in_interesting_tim...
- madengr 12y agoEh, screw all that. Wolf dad, AKA "how to beat your kids into the top university": http://www.npr.org/2011/12/14/143659027/and-you-thought-the-tiger-mother-was-tough http://www.npr.org/2011/12/14/143659027/and-you-thought-the-...
- jpatokal 12y agoI'll see you Wolf Dad and raise you Eagle Dad: http://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/worldnews/asia/china/9597951/Chinas-Eagle-Dad-and-son-get-stranded-on-Mount-Fuji.html http://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/worldnews/asia/china/9597951...
- therealdrag0 12y agoI listened to a Freakanomics Episode on parenting a few years ago. Worth a listen (transcript available too)[0]. From what I remember, activities aren't much of a determinate of a child success so much as appropriate parental attention/affection. (This corresponds to what I've heard from exes who were in graduate lvl psych programs). [0] http://freakonomics.com/2011/08/17/new-freakonomics-radio-podcast-the-economists-guide-to-parenting/ http://freakonomics.com/2011/08/17/new-freakonomics-radio-po...
- jriley 12y agoI found this course helpful: http://www.thegreatcourses.com/courses/scientific-secrets-for-raising-kids-who-thrive.html http://www.thegreatcourses.com/courses/scientific-secrets-fo...
- refurb 12y agoStudying something like this is a great example of the "halo effect". If you raise a child who turns out to be successful, you'll attribute all sorts of things to that success. Doesn't mean they actually had an impact. I think one thing most people can agree on is that a stable up-bringing can certainly make things easier on a kid.
- petegrif 12y agoGood point. Like reviewing the strategies of successful entrepreneurs. :)
- refurb 12y agoThere is a book by the name of "The Halo Effect" about the same thing in business. It's a great read. It really tears apart all of the business books people rave about. http://www.amazon.com/The-Halo-Effect-Business-Delusions-ebook/dp/B000NY128M http://www.amazon.com/The-Halo-Effect-Business-Delusions-ebo...
- electromagnetic 12y agoMost just seem to treat their kids like they're human beings, which essentially is the "Don't live vicariously through your children" and "don't be abusive" that are sure fire ways to destroy your children's lives, or at least emotional well being. I mentioned in my post about JK Rowling's commencement speech to Harvard. Most people would consider her a success, but I don't think most people would take being a divorced single mother living on welfare as a great way to become successful.
- gwern 12y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Nurture_Assumption https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Nurture_Assumption
- simplexion 12y agoDefine success.
- UrMomReadsHN 12y agoI'd rather have a happy child who appreciates what shes has than a successful one (measuring sucess as having a bachelor's degree and a high paying job and an assortment of material goods).
- lgas 12y agoI'm with you 100%. From what I've seen most parents fall into one of two extremes. Those that are simply bad parents. They are, on balance, neglectful and/or mean to their children. Or they are hyper involved with their kids because they want them to be super successful. That set bifurcates into two more groups: basically the helicopter parents that try to protect their child from everything and arrange for the child to face no really challenges until they have graduated college and left the nest and those that push their children super hard to give them a perfect Ivy League entrance resume. The first groups kids are absolutely helpless and have almost no chance of being successful. The second groups kids probably will be successful if they don't kill themselves but grow up to be high pressure asshole parents to their kids repeating the cycle. It's so rare that I find parents that really seem to be focused on what's best for their children and their children's happiness. Even among my close friends who I thought we're smart enough to avoid these traps they largely fit one of the stereotypes. I almost want to have kids just to see if it would happen to me too but I think that's probably not a good reason to have kids.
- electromagnetic 12y agoWhat it appears to boil down to in the article is: do what's best for your kids by taking your ego out of the picture. JK Rowling did the Harvard Commencement Speech in (IIRC) 2008 in which she speaks of failure, where she basically tells the audience of students (along the lines of) "For you, just being ordinary is a failure." It was the Michele Zavos one that reminded me of this, where she's talking about her daughter basically following in her footsteps to become a lawyer, and was on the path to go to Harvard. > So she’s now 19, and she’s the youngest assistant cook they’ve ever had. And then I guess after about a year and a half, she says, “I’m going back to school.” And she does not do well at all, and she says, “I don’t want to be here.” She gets a job in Boston as the kitchen manager of the Beacon Hill Friends house. We go out to dinner, and she says to me, “Mom, I think I want to go to culinary school. Are you disappointed?” And, sort of your whole being a parent flashes by. And I thought, I better get this right. I said to her, “You know what, Add? Even if I am disappointed, here’s what you say to me: ‘F--- you, Mom, it’s my life.’ She sort of flinched and said, “My therapist said that, too, but not like that.” It was really funny. It kind of eloquently paints the angst of a teenager against her mom just wanting to do what's best for her. However, that situation plays out very differently when you've got a parent who wants to live vicariously through their own child's successes as determined by the parent. From the objective view, I totally screwed up. My dad had his own rags to upper-middle class story, and my parents only wanted what's best for me and wanted me to succeed. I wanted to be--I feel there should be a drum roll here--a novelist. I've lived my life predicated on the belief that "well if it all fucks up, at least I got a story out of it." So far it's served me well. I'm married, own a house, have a kid and one on the way, two dogs, and I did it all early. I sleep pretty good at night, because I get to walk into my kids room, stroke his hair and I go to bed with a smile on my face. My brother is the success. He did well, better than my father. Except, I don't know if he's happy and he basically broke of most communication. All I know is he keeps himself very busy, and seems to drink a lot. I think I've got a bottle of Scotch stored somewhere for a special occasion, but I'd be hard pressed to actually rustle something up to get drunk off of. I haven't drank at home in almost three years, me and my wife used to do Fuzzy Navel Wednesday before my kid was born, but that was about our extent after we bought our house, which is about where I hit my own metric of success and where I actually became happy, or at least satiated. So I think the trick to raising successful children is teaching your kids to set their own criteria for success.
- AndrewKemendo 12y agoI have three kids. They are all still in the house, but my wife and I have put a lot of effort into understanding how we make "successful" children. After a lot of reading, reminiscing and thinking about it I have come to three conclusions about how to have successful kids. 1. Don't be poor. Statistically, those who are under or near the poverty line have exponentially worse outcomes than those who are even slightly above it. This will get them at least 50% of the way there. 2. Don't be abusive. Either physical, emotional or sexual abuse will destroy and poison a child. While it may seem obvious, some people don't realize that they are doing it because that is what they were brought up with. This gets them another 20% of the way. 3. Be part of the right social groups. Social mobility is huge for being in "the right place at the right time" or in other words "being lucky." This will get the kid into 80% territory. The last 20% is a crap shoot that is largely dependent on a mix of external factors and individual actions past peak parenting age. edit: By the way, notice how the families in the article hit all my points. No poor, abused or outcast people in that group.
- spydum 12y agogood points, but "don't be abusive" doesn't quite cover it for me. while that for sure should be there, maybe there is a 2 subsection a), which is be your childs mentor. in that you need to give them the push sometimes or be a motivator to hit those stretch goals (heck, to teach them what a stretch goal is). Not doing these things is borderline abuse (the word doesnt sound right, but hopefully you get my meaning), and might lead a kid to mediocracy -- not success.
- AndrewKemendo 12y agoI think that comes from the right place, and I tended to agree even a few years ago, but the data doesn't bear that out. Such pressurizing interactions end up being neutral to destructive depending on how it is implemented. Sports is a good place to look for data on this. Higher parental pressure is related to negative outcomes in sports[1]. Aside from extreme outliers like Woods et. al. at least in sports, being a motivator or putting pressure on the kid generally makes it worse. Almost across the board with cases of where children show extreme competence, they should be supported and given room to thrive, but not pressured. [1]http://www.rcgd.isr.umich.edu/garp/articles/eccles04e.pdf http://www.rcgd.isr.umich.edu/garp/articles/eccles04e.pdf
- bcantrill 12y agoThe article contains the best parenting advice ever: "Your job is to see who your kid is. And help your kid be whoever that is." Lest any of the childless here become too smug, this is much, much harder than it sounds -- especially because kids are often different from their parents in ways that may seem genetically impossible. My advice to parents is: as an adult, you are inherently more flexible than your child, and it is easier for you to change yourself to help them become who they are than it is for them to change themselves to become someone that they aren't. Again, if this sounds easy, it isn't...
- rdtsc 12y ago> especially because kids are often different from their parents in ways that may seem genetically impossible The alternantive is just as scary -- you realize how much they are like you. My kid will talk and and act and I can almost hear myself or see myself or my wife saying or doing those things.
- bcantrill 12y agoSure -- that too, of course. But would you agree that both the similarities and the differences are surprising -- and that the degree that those things (or some of those things, anyway) seem to be uncorrelated to nurture is also surprising?
- KayEss 12y agoIt's a little more complex than that I think. The truth is that the young are more flexible than the old. The nature/nurture debate actually works the other way around than what people think. When young it's nearly all nurture, and as we age our lives much more reflect our nature. This simply reflects the difference in the power we have over our lives at these different ages. The reason for taking to heart "help your kid be whoever that is" is because you don't want them wasting their best years trying to be something that they're not. If you try to push them into what you want you'll win to start with, but eventually you will lose. It's far better for them to get the nature part earlier and get to be who they are rather than spend years trying to be somebody else with all the pain, frustration and ennui that will foster.
- kinkora 12y agoFunny this topic came up. A few months back, it suddenly dawn to me that throughout my childhood, my parents NEVER ever praised me directly. As in, when I got straight As they never called me smart. Or when I won a sports competition, they never said I'm good. It was frustrating as a child at times (they reward me in other ways) but now in my adulthood, I realised they did praise me albeit it in a different way. They praised my effort, and not the results. So, when I got straight As, instead of saying I am smart, they said I got it because I studied hard and they praise me for spending my nights studying. Or when I won that competition, instead of saying good job on being first, they praise me for the extra effort i put in to train on the weekends. I never thought much about it but after going through life, I noticed now that a lot of people mostly tend to just focus on the rewards but never consider the hard work that needs to be put in. Due to my parents quirkiness in my upbringing, I value the work I put in more than the reward itself when achieving for something which makes it so fulfilling. Just my anecdotal 2 cents.
- AndrewKemendo 12y agoYep, a lot of data coming out about this approach in recent years. The thinking is that effort can be adjusted with real impact on outcome, while being smart can't in the same way - thus telling someone they are "smart" places being "smart" as the thing that makes you successful instead of effort and therefore you don't need to try. https://www.khanacademy.org/about/blog/post/95208400815/the-learning-myth-why-ill-never-tell-my-son-hes https://www.khanacademy.org/about/blog/post/95208400815/the-...
- IndianAstronaut 12y agoThe flip side of this is my nephew. His mom always praises him for being smart and being a special kid. She even says things like "now I know how Einstein's mother felt". The kid is turning out pretty average and a bit lazy.
- zeroonetwothree 12y agoEh, everyone praised me for being smart. I never studied much in school. When I got to college that didn't work anymore and I couldn't just get As without trying much. But I did work hard and did well, despite the lack of praise for effort. So I'm skeptical that it really matters that much what people do. I do think that too much praise isn't useful, because kids aren't stupid and understand what's going on.
- emptytheory 12y agoI was raised in an unconventional way. One piece of advice I would give is to be open with your kids. Don't be afraid to talk about certain things, including your own insecurities and dogmas. Speaking from my own experience, a restricted dialogue can lead to frustration, conflict, and anxiety. If a kid isn't comfortable asking questions, he'll guess at the answer and worry about being wrong. What happens when he's wrong? All I'll say is that it's pretty difficult to have a calm resolution when the subject matter cannot be discussed. I'm making no guarantees about success... but at least you'll have a "healthy" relationship (healthier than mine).
- tootie 12y agoThis is fluff. Corrleation, causation and so forth. There is actual academic research on this kind of thing. The fact that responsible, motivated parents raised responsible, motivated kids is largely genetic rather than a result of their parenting techniques.
- critium 12y agostep 1, define success. not a joke. Is it monetary success? Is it happiness?
- collyw 12y agoNo definition of success in the article, which I take to be a very personal thing. Personally I view "being happy and content with life" as more of a success than the materialistic or academic view of success that this article seems to imply.