3 ms·
The problem is that Google can't force phone vendors to support old devices or carriers not to slack on allowing them. Suppose they did release a patch for 4.3
by acdha 12y ago
The problem is that Google can't force phone vendors to support old devices or carriers not to slack on allowing them. Suppose they did release a patch for 4.3 – how long would it take for the phone vendor to update their custom UI value-subtraction patches, package a release, test it, ship it to the carriers, who will do their own branding and testing, etc?
This only applies to old devices so the manufacturer sees it as pure cost unless many people get exploited so badly that they will never buy a new model again; similarly the phone carriers only consider this a problem if you leave your contract – and given that the most likely reaction is “Android sucks – I'm buying an iPhone” or “Verizon/AT&T/etc. sucks – I'm switching to the other one” they obviously haven't been feeling much pressure to change.
What we need is a legal fix to avoid them punting the costs onto customers: e.g. not shipping security updates within, say, two months requires the carrier has to unlock your phone and release any remaining contract without penalty. Unless it affects revenue, they're going to continue to treat support as a cost-minimization exercise.
- Fargren 12y agoCouldn't they have the Play Store and/or Google Play Services not work on unpatched devices? That would probably force carriers to update.
- acdha 12y agoI'd like to think so but it seems equally likely that carriers would either push you towards their own stores or tell you that you need to buy a new phone if the message was anything less aggressive than “There is a critical security available which must be installed before using the web. Please contact your carrier to ask for it”
- 9point6 12y agoThey actually do this on a lot of the oldest devices, but probably not for the same reasoning. I occasionally come across phones that are too old to support Google Play Services (<2.2 IIRC), so they're stuck on the Android Market, which no longer works. It would seem that's not made OEMs/Carries feel the need to update them.
- vetinari 12y agoAre you sure? I think that the Android Market on 1.6 (ADP1) still works.
- 9point6 12y agoPerhaps the dev phone has a slightly different situation? I know someone with a 1st generation HTC Wildfire (formerly) for testing and when you the market throws a connection error and refuses to go any further. I've seen the same thing on other Android phones from that era.