3 ms·
> Farmers have been doing this for thousands of years. If Schmeiser had done "what farmers have been doing for thousands of years" and had selectively bred a r
by jjoonathan 12y ago
> Farmers have been doing this for thousands of years.
If Schmeiser had done "what farmers have been doing for thousands of years" and had selectively bred a roundup-resistant plant without using Monsanto's addition (farmers thousands of years ago didn't have Monsanto plants to breed, did they?) then the courts would have found no issue with it.
> IP rights over organisms
Monsanto didn't claim IP rights over the organism, they claimed IP rights over their addition to the organism. If Schmeiser had grown "pirated" Monsanto canola without taking advantage of Monsanto's roundup-resistant gene, he would not have been in any trouble with the law whatsoever.
Calling Monsanto's patent "IP rights over organisms" is like calling Adobe's rights over Illustrator "IP rights over computers." It makes a sensible patent on a particular piece of the whole look like a nonsensical patent on the whole.
> misinformation from either side of the divide does not help at all
Right back at you.
> If you're going for analogies: Monsanto has taken a public domain item (say a fairy tale) and has added some minor changes to that (see: Disney and the Grimm brothers tales, which in turn were recorded in Germany from old ladies) and has proceeded to restrict the further reproduction of the derived work.
You realize that it's illegal to copy Disney movies even though they were based on Grimm fairy tails, right? Most people seem to agree that this state of affairs promotes the production of further artwork, as do I. Ditto for the Monsanto case.
> I think that they have totally blown their chance to portray GMO in a positive light by their attitude
To me it looks like they are being minimally restrictive subject to the constraint that they are allowed to charge for their product. What "attitude" change would you suggest?
- jacquesm 12y ago>> misinformation from either side of the divide does not help at all > Right back at you. Ah, you took that to be aimed specifically at you, sorry that wasn't the intention. But it is telling.
- alextgordon 12y agoFood is not a disney movie, it is a necessity of life. The power to control what can and can't be planted is the power of life and death. In many countries utility companies cannot turn off the water if a property is occupied, regardless of whether the occupant pays or not. The profitability of the utility companies isn't relevant. If Monsanto needs money then they can receive it from sources other than poor Ghanaian farmers.
- victorhooi 12y agoThen don't use the Monsanto plants? I really don't get people's inflated sense of entitlement. It's like, I have these perfectly fine plants over here. But wait, those Monsanto guys in labcoats have plants that produce 1000x more. I could make more money using their plants. You know what, I'll steal their seeds, grow them, and when they come over and say, hey, that's not fair, you need to pay us for our research, I'll cry, BUT FOOD SHOULD BE FREE! The "poor Ghanian farmers" you refer to (which is a pretty pathetic attempt to tug at heartstrings) should be perfectly fine to use the same seeds they've been using for thousands of years. And your water analogy is...just wrong. I'm sorry, if I refuse to pay my water bill, I assure you, the utility company will chase me up. It's not a God-given right to freeload. In my personal context, water comes as part of the apartment's strata, so we don't pay per use - but the same thing applies to other utility services, like gas and electricity - my provider will chase me up (and has, when I've been careless or absent-minded) if I don't pay my bill.