3 ms·
I had the chance to dive into this issue a few years ago for a school project, and I was shocked by two things: one, the restraint that Monsanto showed when see
by jjoonathan 12y ago
I had the chance to dive into this issue a few years ago for a school project, and I was shocked by two things: one, the restraint that Monsanto showed when seeking and litigating protections for their products, and two, the aggressive exaggerations and deceptive wording that environmental groups employed to attack Monsanto.
Case #1: "Monsanto seeds/pollen from the neighboring farm blew into my farm and Monsanto sued me!" is the line that gets brandied about with regularity by environmental groups. Percy Schmeiser, the farmer in question, used it to launch a political career. It's also a highly selective retelling of the story that completely omits the __only__ part of the story that the courts objected to: upon learning that certain plants on his property contained the Monsanto roundup resistance gene, Schmeiser purposefully cultivated large quantities of these plants and deliberately took advantage of Monsanto's specific addition for commercial gain.
The courts were very clear: cultivating the Monsanto Canola without a license was OK, but deliberately taking advantage of roundup resistance without a license was not. How do we know it was deliberate? Because non-Monsanto canola dies when you spray roundup on it. If Percy Schmeiser wasn't aware that he was "pirating" Monsanto crops, spraying his field with roundup would have killed his crop.
Analogy: My neighbor downloaded Adobe Illustrator over unsecured wifi and I captured their serial number with a sniffer. Now Adobe is suing me because I used that serial number to register 100 new copies of Illustrator at the graphic design business I own. I claim (and the media reports) that I'm being sued because a serial-number laden wifi signal intruded on my property. After all, it could happen to you too!
Case #2: Terminator genes. The way the media / environmental groups reported it: "Monsanto has patented genes which will prevent farmers from re-planting seeds if they can't pay Monsanto's fees! Monsanto's greed will cause poor people to starve!" The way Monsanto reported it: "Monsanto commits to never using terminator genes; we patented them so that we are never forced to use them in order to compete against someone who does." Monsanto has kept to their word. Come on, guys -- it seems a bit thankless to reward Monsanto for good behavior by lying and making it look like bad behavior.
Case #3: Seralini's "GMOs cause cancer in rats" study. When we discussed it (the school project was a team project), we agreed that it had some seriously shoddy methodology (if you're teaching about PCA abuse, this paper is a good example). It was retracted shortly thereafter, naturally to cries of "conspiracy!" from environmental groups (and sighs of relief from us). Incidentally, a study reaching the opposite conclusion was recently released using a somewhat larger sample size (N=90,000,000,000 vs N=20).
EDIT: clarified the Percy Schmeiser narrative to make it clearer that he knew exactly what he was doing (as was established in court).
- jacquesm 12y ago> It's also a highly selective retelling of the story that completely omits the __only__ part of the story that the courts objected to: upon identifying certain plants on his property as roundup-resistant, Schmeiser purposefully cultivated large quantities of roundup-resistant plants and took advantage of their roundup-resistance for commercial gain. Farmers have been doing this for thousands of years. That's the reason we have these extremely efficient crops to begin with. Your typical apple, orange, lemon, grains, rice, potato, soy bean and so on as found 'wild' bear little to no resemblance to what we use as crops. Your looking at an end-product of a lot of hard work. Farmers have been in the food improvement business since just about forever. What should bother you is that there even is such a thing as IP rights over organisms. It's not as if Monsanto created that organism. If you're going for analogies: Monsanto has taken a public domain item (say a fairy tale) and has added some minor changes to that (see: Disney and the Grimm brothers tales, which in turn were recorded in Germany from old ladies) and has proceeded to restrict the further reproduction of the derived work. Keep in mind that every living organism tends to reproduce all by itself and that we're merely helping things along a bit. I'm not happy about the whole patents and genes situation, misinformation from either side of the divide does not help at all, I think Monsanto is excellent at lobbying and finding ways to gain a competitive edge and getting people to use their products (see: Posilac: http://www.huffingtonpost.com/jeffrey-smith/monsanto-forced-fox-tv-to_b_186428.html http://www.huffingtonpost.com/jeffrey-smith/monsanto-forced-...) and I think that they have totally blown their chance to portray GMO in a positive light by their attitude. The C4 Rice project may be able to restore the balance, let's hope that the way Monsanto has been positioning itself and GMO will not hurt their prospects.
- jjoonathan 12y ago> Farmers have been doing this for thousands of years. If Schmeiser had done "what farmers have been doing for thousands of years" and had selectively bred a roundup-resistant plant without using Monsanto's addition (farmers thousands of years ago didn't have Monsanto plants to breed, did they?) then the courts would have found no issue with it. > IP rights over organisms Monsanto didn't claim IP rights over the organism, they claimed IP rights over their addition to the organism. If Schmeiser had grown "pirated" Monsanto canola without taking advantage of Monsanto's roundup-resistant gene, he would not have been in any trouble with the law whatsoever. Calling Monsanto's patent "IP rights over organisms" is like calling Adobe's rights over Illustrator "IP rights over computers." It makes a sensible patent on a particular piece of the whole look like a nonsensical patent on the whole. > misinformation from either side of the divide does not help at all Right back at you. > If you're going for analogies: Monsanto has taken a public domain item (say a fairy tale) and has added some minor changes to that (see: Disney and the Grimm brothers tales, which in turn were recorded in Germany from old ladies) and has proceeded to restrict the further reproduction of the derived work. You realize that it's illegal to copy Disney movies even though they were based on Grimm fairy tails, right? Most people seem to agree that this state of affairs promotes the production of further artwork, as do I. Ditto for the Monsanto case. > I think that they have totally blown their chance to portray GMO in a positive light by their attitude To me it looks like they are being minimally restrictive subject to the constraint that they are allowed to charge for their product. What "attitude" change would you suggest?